Key West

Seafood in Key West

Every seafood on every menu we have read in Key West, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

51 places in Key West have seafood on the menu, from $12 at The Conch Shack to $78 at Yummy Crab. Highest rated: Square Grouper Key West (4.8), The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. (4.7), Misohappy Sushi and Thai (4.6). Conch Republic Seafood Company, Old Town Mexican Cafe, Grand Cafe Key West run a happy hour. 42 of 51 list a price.

Grouper sandwich 3Fish and chips 22Conch fritters 46Grilled salmon 30Coconut shrimp 26Crab cakes 22Lobster tail 14

Conch Republic Seafood Company

631 Greene St · Seafood · website

Full menu 4.4 (12,076)Happy Hour Daily 4 PM-7 PM1 seafood
1
  • For Fresher Seafood You’ll Have to Catch It Yourself!

Conch Republic Seafood Company on 631 Greene St is a seafood rated 4.4 (12,076 reviews). The menu lists 1 seafood. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-7 PM. Also on the menu: beer, burger, chicken.

Own Conch Republic Seafood Company? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Yummy Crab, Key West

Yummy Crab

300 Front St Upstair · seafood · website

Full menu 24 seafoods
2
  • A6. Crawfish$14

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A1. Clams$15

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A2. Green Mussels$15

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A3. Black Mussels$15

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A7. Blue Crab$15

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A4. Shrimp (No Head)$18

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A5. Snow Crab Legs$24

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A8. Dungeness Crab$25

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • A9. Lobster Tail 1Pc$31

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • 1. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head)$38

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

Show all 24 seafoods
  • 5. 1/2 Lb Clam, 1/2 Lb Green Mussels, 1/2 Lb Black Mussels$38

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 7. 1Lb Crawfish, 1Lb Shrimp (No Head)$45

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 13. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head), 1/2 Lb Black Mussel$48

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 6. 1 Lb Crawfish, 1 Lb Snow Crab$55

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 8. 1 Lb Shrimp (No Head), 1 Pc Lobster Tail$55

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 3. 1Lb Snow Crab, 1 Pc Lobster Tail$59

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 10. 1 Lb Crawfish, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head), 1 Pc Lobster Tail$60

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 2. 1 Lb Snow Crab, 1 Lb Shrimp (No Head)$61

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 11. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1 Pc Lobster Tail, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head)$62

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 9. 1 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Green Mussels, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head)$63

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 4. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 2 Pcs Lobster Tail$73

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • A10. King Crab Legs$78

    Come w. Corn & Potato (Order 1 Lb and up)

  • 12. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head), 1Lb Crawfish, 1 Pc Lobs$78

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

  • 14. 1Lb King Crab, 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head)$112

    All Come W. Corn & Potato

A6. Crawfish at Yummy Crab is $14 in Key West. A1. Clams at Yummy Crab is $15 in Key West. A2. Green Mussels at Yummy Crab is $15 in Key West. A3. Black Mussels at Yummy Crab is $15 in Key West. A7. Blue Crab at Yummy Crab is $15 in Key West. A4. Shrimp (No Head) at Yummy Crab is $18 in Key West. A5. Snow Crab Legs at Yummy Crab is $24 in Key West. A8. Dungeness Crab at Yummy Crab is $25 in Key West. A9. Lobster Tail 1Pc at Yummy Crab is $31 in Key West. 1. 1/2 Lb Snow Crab, 1/2 Lb Shrimp (No Head) at Yummy Crab is

A6. Crawfish at Yummy Crab is $14 in Key West. Yummy Crab on 300 Front St Upstair is a seafood. The menu lists 24 seafoods, from $14 for the A6. Crawfish to $112, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: calamari, chicken, chicken tenders.

Own Yummy Crab? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Stoned Crab

3101 N Roosevelt Blvd · Seafood · website

Full menu 3.5 (4,127)3 seafoods
3
  • TWO Decks$144

    Fresh Catch of the Day, Key West Pink Shrimp, Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Snow Crab, Stone Crab Claws & Half a Lobster

  • Three Decks$189

    Even more Fresh Catch of the Day, Key West Pink Shrimp, Calamari, Clams, Mussels, Snow Crab Clusters, Stone Crab Claws & Whole Lobster

  • Tender & moist Florida Lobster stuffed and roasted with loads of seafo

TWO Decks at The Stoned Crab is $144 in Key West. The Stoned Crab on 3101 N Roosevelt Blvd is a seafood rated 3.5 (4,127 reviews). The menu lists 3 seafoods, from $144 for the TWO Decks to $189, above the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, burger.

Own The Stoned Crab? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Square Grouper Key West

920 Caroline St · American · website

Full menu 4.8 (530)11 seafoods
4
  • Shrimp$31

    Grilled, Blackened or Fried

  • Coconut Shrimp$33

    Sautéed, Blackened or Fried

  • Fried Conch$33

    Sautéed, Blackened or Fried

  • Classic

    Pan Sautéed or Blackened, Key Lime Tartar, Fresh Lemon "GF"

  • Santorini

    Grilled, Green Peppercorn Chimichurri, Feta +2

  • Thai Style

    Pan Sautéed, Thai Sweet Chili Butter Sauce, Chopped Cashews, Spinach +2

  • Almondine

    Almond Encrusted, Warm Caribbean Pineapple Relish +2

  • Picatta

    Pan Sautéed with Key Lime Butter Sauce, Crispy Capers, Confit Tomato (Choice of Cavatappi Pasta or Rice) +2

  • Cajun Oscar

    Cajun Breadcrumbs, Andouille Etouffee Sauce, Jumbo Lump Crab +12

  • Local FishMP

    Sautéed, Blackened or Fried

Show all 11 seafoods
  • FishMP

    Sautéed, blackened or Fried

Shrimp at Square Grouper Key West is $31 in Key West. Coconut Shrimp at Square Grouper Key West is $33 in Key West. Fried Conch at Square Grouper Key West is $33 in Key West.

Shrimp at Square Grouper Key West is $31 in Key West. Square Grouper Key West on 920 Caroline St is an american rated 4.8 (530 reviews). The menu lists 11 seafoods, from $31 for the Shrimp to $33, above the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, burrata.

Own Square Grouper Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Half Shell Raw Bar, Key West

Half Shell Raw Bar

231 Margaret St · seafood · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4:30 PM - 6:30 PM3 seafoods
5
  • Seafood Sampler

    Crab Fritters, Conch Fritters, Calamari and Popcorn Shrimp served with Key Lime Mustard, Cocktail and Marinara Sauce

  • Fried or Broiled Seafood Combo

    Dolphin, Shrimp, and Scallops, Golden Fried or Broiled with White Wine, Garlic, Lemon and Butter. served with choice of two sides

  • Baked Seafood Pasta

    Sauteed Shrimp & Scallops with a Tomato Cream Sauce with Seasoned Breadcrumbs Served with Garlic Bread

Half Shell Raw Bar on 231 Margaret St is a seafood. The menu lists 3 seafoods. Happy hour Daily 4:30 PM - 6:30 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, calamari.

Own Half Shell Raw Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Stinkin Crawfish Key West, Key West

Stinkin Crawfish Key West

217 Duval St · seafood · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 12 PM-6 PM1 seafood
6
  • Best for Sharing Seafood Medley$23

    Shrimp, mussels, clams, corn, potato, andouille sausage, cajun or garlic butter

Best for Sharing Seafood Medley at Stinkin Crawfish Key West is $23 in Key West. Stinkin Crawfish Key West on 217 Duval St is a seafood. The menu lists 1 seafood at $23, below the Key West median of $24.49. Happy hour Daily 12 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, bloody mary, breakfast.

Own Stinkin Crawfish Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar, Key West

El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar

Mallory Square · cuban · website

Full menu 9 seafoods
7
  • Seviche de Mariscos (Seafood Ceviche)$19

    Pepe's blend of Seafood Seviche

  • Camarones Empanizado (Breaded Shrimp)$30

    Lightly breaded shrimp fried and served with a mustard/garlic sauce

  • Filete de Cherna Empanizada (Breaded Grouper)$32

    Grouper filet breaded and fried, served on a bed of lettuce and onions

  • Camarones en Salsa Criolla (Shrimp in Creole Sauce)$32

    Fresh shrimp in a homemade Cuban Creole sauce

  • Camarones al Ajillo (Garlic Shrimp)$32

    Shrimp sautéed in garlic, olive oil, lemon, and white wine

  • Mahi Mahi con Salsa de Camarones$34

    Fresh dolphin filet topped with a shrimp Cuban creole sauce

  • Rabirubia Frita Entera (Whole Fried Yellowtail)$38

    Fried whole yellowtail, marinated w/fresh key lime, garlic and onions

  • Zarzuela de Marisco (Seafood Medley)$48

    A medley of seafood in a homemade Cuban Creole sauce

  • Pescado del Dia (Fish of the Day)MKT

    Pepe's selection of fresh fish in a new creation each day

Seviche de Mariscos (Seafood Ceviche) at El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar is $19 in Key West. El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar on Mallory Square is a cuban. The menu lists 9 seafoods, from $19 for the Seviche de Mariscos (Seafood Ceviche) to $48, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: ceviche, cheeseburger, chicken.

Own El Meson De Pepe's Restaurant & Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Two Friends Patio Restaurant, Key West

Two Friends Patio Restaurant

512 Front St · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM17 seafoods
8
  • Seafood Omelette$19.95

    with shrimp, scallops, swiss & hollandaise

  • Mahi-Mahi Fish Tacos$25.95

    fried, broiled or blackened. cajun tartar

  • Key West Pink Shrimp Tacos$25.95

    fried, broiled or blackened, cajun tartar

  • Fried Seafood Combo$26.95

    lightly battered pink shrimp, mahi-mahi & calamari

  • Mahi-mahi$29.95
  • Coconut Shrimp$29.95

    pineapple chutney

  • Key West Fried Shrimp$29.95

    key west pinks, regular or buffalo

  • Caribbean Crab Cakes$31.95

    lump crab meat pan seared with house-made caper tartar sauce

  • Shrimp Trio$31.95

    coconut, scampi & steamed shrimp

  • Fried Captain's Platter$31.95

    key west pinks; mahi-mahi & calamari

Show all 17 seafoods
  • Seafood Penne$33.95

    sautéed shrimp, scallops & mahi with a lobster cream sauce

  • Yellow Tail Snapper$33.95
  • Broiled Seafood Platter$34.95

    mahi-mahi, scallops & skewered shrimp

  • Dante's Pan-Fried Snapper$34.95

    breaded& pan fired in scampi butter

  • Steamed Snow Crab Legs$36.95

    pound of jumbo crab legs

  • Seafood Favorites
  • Today's Fresh Catch

    choose: broiled, blackened, fried or bahamian style

Seafood Omelette at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $19.95 in Key West. Mahi-Mahi Fish Tacos at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $25.95 in Key West. Key West Pink Shrimp Tacos at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $25.95 in Key West. Fried Seafood Combo at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $26.95 in Key West. Mahi-mahi at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $29.95 in Key West. Coconut Shrimp at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $29.95 in Key West. Key West Fried Shrimp at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $29.95 in Key West. Car

Seafood Omelette at Two Friends Patio Restaurant is $19.95 in Key West. Two Friends Patio Restaurant on 512 Front St is a restaurant. The menu lists 17 seafoods, from $19.95 for the Seafood Omelette to $36.95, below the Key West median of $24.49. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, bloody mary, breakfast.

Own Two Friends Patio Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Outback Steakhouse, Key West

Outback Steakhouse

3230 N Roosevelt Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu 6 seafoods
9
  • Seared Peppered Ahi*$21.49

    Seared rare with garlic pepper seasoning, sliced and served over a bed of lettuce, cabbage, carrots, and crispy noodles. Served with creamy soy ginger sauce, wasabi and choice of two freshly made side

  • Hooley Dooley Grilled Shrimp$24.49

    Jumbo prawns (shrimp) grilled with garlic butter. Served with two freshly made sides.

  • Hooley Dooley Coconut Shrimp$24.49

    Jumbo prawns (shrimp) Gold Coast Coconut-style with creole marmalade. Served with two freshly made sides.

  • Perfectly Grilled Salmon$27.49

    Seasoned and grilled. Served with our classic rémoulade sauce. Served with two freshly made sides.

  • Toowoomba Salmon$28.79

    Grilled Salmon topped with seasoned and sautéed shrimp tossed with mushrooms in a creamy creole sauce. Served with two freshly made sides.

  • Steamed Lobster Tails$37.79

    Two cold water tails perfectly steamed for maximum tenderness. Served with two freshly made sides.

Seared Peppered Ahi* at Outback Steakhouse is $21.49 in Key West. Outback Steakhouse on 3230 N Roosevelt Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 6 seafoods, from $21.49 for the Seared Peppered Ahi* to $37.79, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, baby back ribs, bbq.

Own Outback Steakhouse? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Seven Fish, Key West

Seven Fish

921 Truman Avenue · american, fish · website

Full menu 3 seafoods
10
  • Chef’s Selection Seafood Feast$1

    Grilled Mahi Mahi, Jumbo Sea Scallops, Skewered Grilled Shrimp, over sushi rice and steamed veggies with Mango Citrus Butter Sauce

  • Seafood Ceviche$18

    Bay scallops & shrimp with avocado and tortilla chips

  • Seafood Marinara Pasta$35

    grilled mahi-mahi with chopped baby clams and shrimp over angel hair

Chef’s Selection Seafood Feast at Seven Fish is $1 in Key West. Seven Fish on 921 Truman Avenue is an american, fish. The menu lists 3 seafoods, from $1 for the Chef’s Selection Seafood Feast to $35, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: caesar salad, ceviche, cheesecake.

Own Seven Fish? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

424 Eaton St · Seafood · website

Full menu 4.7 (1,002)1 seafood
11
  • Seafood Marinara$36

    grilled key west pink shrimp & grouper topped with parmesan cheese

Seafood Marinara at The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. is $36 in Key West. The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. on 424 Eaton St is a seafood rated 4.7 (1,002 reviews). The menu lists 1 seafood at $36, above the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: baby back ribs, bbq, caprese.

Own The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

China Garden

3300 N Roosevelt Blvd · Chinese · website

Full menu 3.9 (540)16 seafoods
12
  • Szechuan Shrimp$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Hunan Shrimp$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Curry Shrimp$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Shrimp w. Chinese Vegetable$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Shrimp w.Cashew Nuts$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Shrimp w Broccoli$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Kung Pao Shrimp$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Shrimp w. Garlic Sauce$15.50

    w. Rice

  • Moo Shu Shrimp$16.95

    w. Rice

  • Jumbo Shrimp w.Lobster Sauce$16.95

    w. Rice

Show all 16 seafoods
  • Curry Calamari$16.95

    w. Rice

  • Butterfly Shrimp w. Special Sauce$18.25

    w. Rice

  • General Tso's Shrimp$18.95

    w. Rice

  • Seafood Delight$23.95

    w. Rice

  • Scallop w. Garlic Sauce$23.95

    w. Rice

  • General Tso's Scallop$23.95

    w. Rice

Szechuan Shrimp at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Hunan Shrimp at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Curry Shrimp at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Shrimp w. Chinese Vegetable at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Shrimp w.Cashew Nuts at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Shrimp w Broccoli at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Kung Pao Shrimp at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Shrimp w. Garlic Sauce at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. Moo Shu Shrimp at China Garden is $16.95 in Key West. Jumbo

Szechuan Shrimp at China Garden is $15.50 in Key West. China Garden on 3300 N Roosevelt Blvd is a chinese rated 3.9 (540 reviews). The menu lists 16 seafoods, from $15.50 for the Szechuan Shrimp to $23.95, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: calamari, chicken, dessert.

Own China Garden? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

China Garden West Downtown

531 Fleming St · Chinese · website

Full menu 4.1 (548)8 seafoods
13
  • Shrimp with Bean Sprouts$13.95
  • Shrimp With Lobster Sauce$14.95
  • Shrimp with Broccoli$14.95
  • Shrimp with Black Bean Sauce$14.95
  • Shrimp with Mixed Vegetable$14.95
  • Curry Shrimp$14.95
  • Shrimp With Cashew Nuts$15.95
  • Butterfly Shrimp with Special Sauce$16.95

Shrimp with Bean Sprouts at China Garden West Downtown is $13.95 in Key West. China Garden West Downtown on 531 Fleming St is a chinese rated 4.1 (548 reviews). The menu lists 8 seafoods, from $13.95 for the Shrimp with Bean Sprouts to $16.95, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: beer, chicken, chicken noodle soup.

Own China Garden West Downtown? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown), Key West

El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown)

900 Catherine St · restaurant · website

Full menu 10 seafoods
14
  • 24. Coconut Shrimp$18.95
  • 22.Mahi-Mahi$20.95
  • 21.Breaded Grouper$21.95
  • 25. Grilled Shrimp$21.95
  • 26. Grilled Grouper Fillet$21.95
  • 20.Butterfly Y.Tail$23.95
  • 23.Shrimp Enchilado$23.95
  • 23A. Garlic Shrimp$23.95
  • 28. Grilled YellowTail$23.95
  • 27. Whole Fry Fish$32.95

24. Coconut Shrimp at El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown) is $18.95 in Key West. El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown) on 900 Catherine St is a restaurant. The menu lists 10 seafoods, from $18.95 for the 24. Coconut Shrimp to $32.95, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, burger.

Own El Siboney Restaurant (Downtown)? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island), Key West

El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island)

5501 5Th Ave · cuban · website

Full menu 10 seafoods
15
  • Coconut Shrimp$18.95
  • Mahi-Mahi$20.95
  • Breaded Grouper$21.95
  • Grilled Shrimp$21.95
  • Grilled Grouper Fillet$21.95
  • Butterfly Y.Tail$23.95
  • Shrimp Enchilado$23.95
  • Garlic Shrimp$23.95
  • Grilled YellowTail$23.95
  • Whole Fry Fish$32.95

Coconut Shrimp at El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island) is $18.95 in Key West. El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island) on 5501 5Th Ave is a cuban. The menu lists 10 seafoods, from $18.95 for the Coconut Shrimp to $32.95, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, burger.

Own El Siboney Restaurant ( Stock Island)? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Grand Cafe Key West, Key West

Grand Cafe Key West

314 Duval St · new american · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily8 seafoods
16
  • Blackened Mahi Mahi$32

    Rice, havana black beans, fried plantains and tropical fruit salsa

  • Grilled Rare Yellowfin Tuna$32

    Cool black sesame rice noodles, wasabi aioli, and citrus relish

  • Baked Branzino$38

    Whole sea bass baked with lemon, garlic and caper berries, basamati rice and summer salad

  • Sauteed Snapper With Shrimp Cream Sauce$40

    Seasonal vegetable and rice

  • PAN Seared SEA Scallops$42

    Key lime beurre blanc, saffron rice, seasonal vegetable

  • Seafood Pasta$45

    Petite lobster tail, sea scallop, key west pink shrimp and mussels served with your choice of white wine garlic cream sauce or red sauce over linguini

  • Grand Lobster$MKT

    Pan seared lobster tail sauteed with cherry tomatoes, caramelized shallots and cilantro. Finished with a touch of cream, and limoncello. Served over mushroom raviolis with a balsamic vinegar reduction

  • Grand Cafe Surf AND Turf$MARKET PRIC

    5 OZ. Hand cut fire grilled filet mignon, 8 OZ. Baked lobster tail with herbed potatoes and seasonal vegetable

Blackened Mahi Mahi at Grand Cafe Key West is $32 in Key West. Grand Cafe Key West on 314 Duval St is a new american. The menu lists 8 seafoods, from $32 for the Blackened Mahi Mahi to $45, above the Key West median of $24.49. Happy hour Daily. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, calamari.

Own Grand Cafe Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House, Key West

Duffy's Steak & Lobster House

1007 Simonton St · steak house · website

Full menu 11 seafoods
17
  • Duffy's Seafood$22.99

    Shrimp & Crabmeat, Romaine & Leaf Lettuce, carrot, radish, cucumber, red pepper, tomato, onion, egg

  • Fresh Fillet OF Salmon$27.99

    Sautéed and served with a Key Lime Dill Butter Sauce

  • Seafood Summer Pasta$32.99

    Fillet of Fresh Fish & Shrimp sautéed with Garlic, Butter, Olive Oil & Tomatoes with Linguini

  • Lump Crab Cakes$32.99

    Two cakes of Jumbo Lump Crab served with our homemade Remoulade sauce

  • Golden Fried Jumbo Shrimp$35.99

    Lightly Breaded per order

  • Fresh Fillet OF Fish - OUR Local Catch$39.99

    Fresh Caught Local Fillet served Pan-seared, Teriyaki style, Fried or Blackened

  • Florida Lobster Tail$39.99

    Tender 6oz Tail broiled with drawn butter

  • Seafood Medley$41.99

    Florida Lobster, Shrimp & Fresh Fish in a light Garlic Butter Sauce

  • Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp$42.99

    w/Crabmeat Stuffing and a Citrus Hollandaise Sauce

  • Local Catch Fresh Fillet OF DAY "maison"$44.99

    Fresh Caught Local Fillet sautéed with Shrimp, Capers, Mushrooms, White Wine & butter

Show all 11 seafoods
  • Live Maine Lobster Stuffed With CrabmeatMKT

    Maine Lobster split broiled stuffed with Crab served with drawn butter

Duffy's Seafood at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $22.99 in Key West. Fresh Fillet OF Salmon at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $27.99 in Key West. Seafood Summer Pasta at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $32.99 in Key West. Lump Crab Cakes at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $32.99 in Key West. Golden Fried Jumbo Shrimp at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $35.99 in Key West. Fresh Fillet OF Fish - OUR Local Catch at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $39.

Duffy's Seafood at Duffy's Steak & Lobster House is $22.99 in Key West. Duffy's Steak & Lobster House on 1007 Simonton St is a steak house. The menu lists 11 seafoods, from $22.99 for the Duffy's Seafood to $44.99, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, chicken.

Own Duffy's Steak & Lobster House? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Conch Shack

118 Duval St · restaurant · website

Full menu 9 seafoods
18
  • Mahi Bites$12

    Bite size pieces of Mahi lightly breaded and fried to a golden brown

  • Fried Fish Sandwich$13

    Lightly breaded Mahi perfectly fried and served on a toasted kaiser with lettuce, tomato, onion & our special key lime aioli

  • Shrimp Basket$16

    Freshly battered plump fried shrimp, with hand cut fries

  • Fish & Chips$17

    Beer-battered Mahi fried to a golden brown and served with hand cut fries

  • Seafood Sampler Platter$18

    Fried Mahi, conch fritters and fried shrimp, served with hand cut fries

  • Cracked Conch & Fries$19

    Tenderized conch filet lightly breaded and flash fried to a golden brown, served with hand cut fries

  • Conch Trio$19

    A sampling of conch ceviche, cracked conch and our "Best Ever" conch fritters, served with hand cut fries

  • Maine Lobster Roll$22

    Traditional New England style, on a butter-grilled top split bun

  • The “Best Ever” Conch Fritters

    Our own secret recipe w/ key lime aioli or spicy pink sauce

Mahi Bites at The Conch Shack is $12 in Key West. The Conch Shack on 118 Duval St is a restaurant. The menu lists 9 seafoods, from $12 for the Mahi Bites to $22, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: beer, burger, chicken tenders.

Own The Conch Shack? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Bobalu's Southern Café, Key West

Bobalu's Southern Café

301 US-1 · restaurant · website

Full menu 8 seafoods
19
  • Fried Conch Steak$19.99

    Crispy golden & tender

  • Grouper or Mahi$19.99

    Fried, blackened, grilled or broiled

  • Whole Yellowtail Snapper$19.99

    Served fried - head on

  • Hogfish$21.99

    Fried, blackened, grilled or broiled

  • Key West Pink Shrimp$21.99

    Fried, blackened, grilled or broiled

  • Baked Stuffed Grouper$23.99

    Stuffed with our homemade crabmeat stuffing

  • Stuffed Hogfish$24.99

    Stuffed with fresh local crabmeat

  • Ocean Platter$24.99

    Filet of fish, scallops & shrimp Fried, blackened, grilled or broiled

Fried Conch Steak at Bobalu's Southern Café is $19.99 in Key West. Bobalu's Southern Café on 301 US-1 is a restaurant. The menu lists 8 seafoods, from $19.99 for the Fried Conch Steak to $24.99, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: fries, mac and cheese, steak.

Own Bobalu's Southern Café? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Havana Island Cafe Big Coppitt, Key West

Havana Island Cafe Big Coppitt

319 Overseas Hwy · restaurant · website

Full menu 4 seafoods
20
  • Garlic Shrimp Plate$16.99

    Sautéed garlic shrimp over rice with maduros

  • Grilled Fish Plate$17.99

    Fresh grilled fish, pico de gallo, avocado, fries

  • Camarones al Ajillo$17.99

    Shrimp in garlic butter sauce, white rice

  • Shrimp & Pork Combo$18.99

    Grilled shrimp skewer, pulled pork, tostones

Garlic Shrimp Plate at Havana Island Cafe Big Coppitt is $16.99 in Key West. Havana Island Cafe Big Coppitt on 319 Overseas Hwy is a restaurant. The menu lists 4 seafoods, from $16.99 for the Garlic Shrimp Plate to $18.99, below the Key West median of $24.49. Also on the menu: breakfast, burrito, chicken.

Own Havana Island Cafe Big Coppitt? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About seafood in Key West

51 of the 162 restaurants and bars we track in Key West list seafood. Prices run from $12 at The Conch Shack to $78 at Yummy Crab, with a median of $24.49. Most of them sit along Duval St and N Roosevelt Blvd. The highest rated is Square Grouper Key West (4.8), and Conch Republic Seafood Company, Old Town Mexican Cafe pair it with a happy hour.

51places
$12–$78price range
$24.49median
Square Grouper Keytop rated
Cheapest
$12 at The Conch Shack
Most expensive
$78 at Yummy Crab
Most spots
Duval St · N Roosevelt Blvd · Front St
Happy hour
Conch Republic Seafood Company, Old Town Mexican Cafe, Grand Cafe Key West, Two Friends Patio Restaurant
Menus read
October 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Key West

Questions

Where is the cheapest seafood in Key West?

The Conch Shack lists Mahi Bites at $12. Median across 51 places is $24.49.

Which Key West spot has the best-rated seafood?

Square Grouper Key West (4.8 from 530 reviews), The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. (4.7 from 1,002 reviews), Misohappy Sushi and Thai (4.6 from 1,440 reviews).

Any seafood places with a happy hour?

Conch Republic Seafood Company: Daily 4 PM-7 PM; Old Town Mexican Cafe: Daily 4 PM-6 PM; Grand Cafe Key West: Daily.

Every cuisine and category in Key West

See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Key West

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?