Every old fashioned on every menu we have read in Key West, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.
17 places in Key West have old fashioned on the menu, from $13 at Mac's Place to $20 at Stinkin Crawfish Key West. Highest rated: Party Pass Key West (4.7), Sarabeth's in Key West (4.5), Pickles Pub Key West (4.3). Bel Mare Restaurant, Stinkin Crawfish Key West, Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar run a happy hour. 12 of 17 list a price.
Diplomatico Exclusiva Reserva, Figgy Pudding Bitters, Sugar
Tiki Old Fashioned at Tiki House is $15 in Key West. Tiki House on 203 Duval St is a bar. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $15, below the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 12 PM-3 PM. Also on the menu: beer, cocktails, espresso.
Old forrester bourbon, ginger syrup, spicy ginger shrub, angostura
Spicy Ginger Old Fashioned at The Roost is $17 in Key West. The Roost on 508 Fleming St is a cocktail bar. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $17, below the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 12-6. Also on the menu: beer, cocktails, ipa.
Papa Pilar Dark Rum, Cherry Simple, House Bitters, Expressed Oil of Fresh Orange, Black Cherry
Papa's Old Fashioned at Willie T's is $18 in Key West. Willie T's on 525 Duval St is a bar. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $18, around the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.
Made With The Rum Bar’s Own Prohibition Rum
The Rum Bar on 1117 Duval St is a bar. The menu lists 1 old fashioned. Also on the menu: espresso martini, key lime pie, mojito.
Appleton Estate Rum, orange bitters, Filthy cherry
Rum Old Fashioned at Southernmost Beach Café is $15 in Key West. Southernmost Beach Café on 1405 Duval St is an american. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $15, below the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, biscuits and gravy, bloody mary.
Own Southernmost Beach Café? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Peeled shrimp, corn, potato, andouille pork sausage in garlic butter sauce
Old Fashioned Shrimp at Stinkin Crawfish Key West is $20 in Key West. Stinkin Crawfish Key West on 217 Duval St is a seafood. The menu lists 2 old fashioneds at $20, above the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 12 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, bloody mary, breakfast.
Own Stinkin Crawfish Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Whistlepig Piggy Back 6 Year Bourbon, bitters, orange, cherry
MAC's OLD Fashioned at Mac's Place is $13 in Key West. Mac's Place on 1605 N Roosevelt Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $13, below the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 3-6pm + 9-11pm. Also on the menu: bagel and lox, bbq, beer.
Twin P Champion Whiskey, Trader Vic’s Macadamia Nut Liqueur, orange bitters, luxardo cherry and orange twist. Served “up” or “on one large rock”
Pickles Pub Key West on 511 Greene St is a restaurant rated 4.3 (2,183 reviews). The menu lists 1 old fashioned. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, bloody mary.
Own Pickles Pub Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Bulleit Bourbon, Espresso, Maple Syrup, Orange Bitters
Woodford Reserve, Marshmallow Syrup, Chocolate Bitters with Toasted Marshmallow
Espresso OLD Fashioned at Bel Mare Restaurant is $16 in Key West. Bel Mare Restaurant on 700 Front St is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 old fashioneds at $16, below the Key West median of $18. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, bolognese, caesar salad.
Own Bel Mare Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
papa's pilar sherry cask rum, maple simple, house bitters, filthy cherry, expressed orange
Papa's Old Fashioned at Cafe Marquesa is $20 in Key West. Cafe Marquesa on 600 Fleming St is a fine dining. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $20, above the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: aperol spritz, beer, cocktails.
Own Cafe Marquesa? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
fried chicken breast, pickles, spicy mayo
Old Fashioned Fried Chicken Sandwich at Sarabeth's in Key West is $19.95 in Key West. Sarabeth's in Key West on 530 Simonton St is an american rated 4.5 (1,340 reviews). The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $19.95, above the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: bagel and lox, breakfast, burger.
Own Sarabeth's in Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Buffalo Trace Bourbon, Demerara Syrup, Angostura + Regans' #6
Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar on 223 Petronia St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 old fashioned. Happy hour Daily 3-5 PM. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, caesar salad, ceviche.
Own Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Hand selected private label barrels, chocolate bitters, simple syrup, black cherry, orange zest, large rock. Choose from Woodford Reserve Bourbon or Papa's Pilar Sherry Cask Rum
Nine One Five on 915 Duval St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 old fashioned. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, beer, burger.
Own Nine One Five? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva rum, Angostura bitters, maraschino cherries and orange peel
Rum Old Fashioned at Viva Argentinian Steakhouse is $19 in Key West. Viva Argentinian Steakhouse on 903 Duval St is a steak house. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $19, above the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, brunch.
Own Viva Argentinian Steakhouse? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300 · restaurant · website
Papa Pilar Dark Rum, Cherry Simple, House Bitters, Expressed Oil of Fresh Orange, Black Cherry
Papa's Old Fashioned at Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar is $18 in Key West. Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar on 7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $18, around the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.
Own Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300 · restaurant · website
Papa Pilar Dark Rum, Cherry Simple, House Bitters, Expressed Oil of Fresh Orange, Black Cherry
Papa's Old Fashioned at Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill is $18 in Key West. Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill on 7001 Shrimp Rd Suite 300 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 old fashioned at $18, around the Key West median of $18. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.
Own Salty Oyster Dockside Bar & Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
Four Roses whiskey, orange, cherry, sugar, bitters
Party Pass Key West on 1107 Key Plaza is a restaurant rated 4.7 (31 reviews). The menu lists 1 old fashioned. Also on the menu: beer, burger, burrata.
Own Party Pass Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
17 of the 162 restaurants and bars we track in Key West list old fashioned. Prices run from $13 at Mac's Place to $20 at Stinkin Crawfish Key West, with a median of $18. Most of them sit along Duval St and Fleming St. The highest rated is Party Pass Key West (4.7), and Bel Mare Restaurant, Stinkin Crawfish Key West pair it with a happy hour.
Nachos34 places
Calamari32 places
Oysters25 places
Cocktails58 places
Margarita45 places
Mojito34 places
Espresso martini11 places
Mimosa18 places
Pina colada18 places
Paloma16 places
Bloody mary15 placesCocktails in Key West
American / BBQ140 placesSeafood88 placesCoffee85 places
Beer / Wine84 places
Mexican77 places
Dessert77 placesDietary Restrictions76 placesItalian67 places
Steak55 places
Brunch49 placesEverything in Key West162 places · 148 dishes and drinksMac's Place lists MAC's OLD Fashioned at $13. Median across 17 places is $18.
Party Pass Key West (4.7 from 31 reviews), Sarabeth's in Key West (4.5 from 1,340 reviews), Pickles Pub Key West (4.3 from 2,183 reviews).
Bel Mare Restaurant: Daily 4 PM-6 PM; Stinkin Crawfish Key West: Daily 12 PM-6 PM; Fishwife Restaurant & Raw Bar: Daily 3-5 PM.
