Sarabeth's in Key West Menu & Prices

Sarabeth's in Key West · 530 Simonton St · American

Brunch. 28 items read from Sarabeth's in's own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026. Signature plates: Traditional Breakfast* $15.95, Western Omelet $15.95, Almond Crusted Cinnamon French Toa $15.95.

Brunch 28

Sarabeth's in Brunch Menu

Key West · 28 items

Smoked Atlantic Salmon$19.95
toasted bagel, cream cheese, sliced tomato, capers, sliced onion
Eggs Benedict*$13.95
two poached eggs, English muffin, spinach, hollandaise sauce
Berry Bowl$15.95
yogurt, fresh assorted fruits and toasted granola
Breakfast Sandwich*$15.95
bacon, eggs, and cheese on ciabatta bread, three pepper home fries

Extraordinary Eggs & Omelets

With Your Choice Of Multigrain Toast Or Homemade Blueberry Muffin
Shrimp & Bacon Omelet$18.95
with scallions, herbs, and smoked mozzarella
Green & White$14.95
scrambled eggs with scallions and cream cheese
Goldie Lox$16.95
our signature; smoked salmon scrambled with eggs and cream cheese
Western Omelet$15.95
sautéed peppers and onions, ham, cheddar cheese
Spinach & Goat Cheese Omelet$15.95
nothing more need be said, silky perfection
Traditional Breakfast*$15.95
eggs your way, bacon or ham, toast or muffin

Sarabeth's in Sweet Breakfasts Menu see more breakfast in Key West

Buttermilk Pancakes$13.95
a simply perfect classic with a garnish of sliced strawberries
Lemon Ricotta Pancakes$14.95
light and yummy with blueberries
Fat & Fluffy French Toast$14.95
powdered sugar with blueberries and strawberries
Almond Crusted Cinnamon French Toast$15.95
sliced bananas, toasted almonds, powdered sugar
Key Lime Pie French Toast$16.95
pie filling with graham cracker sprinkle, strawberries

Sarabeth's in Savory Lunch Menu

Sarabeth's Velvety Cream of Tomato Soup$14.95
with chunks of tomato, cream, dill, cheddar cheese
Blackened Shrimp Macaroni & Cheese$19.95
with aged cheddar, Swiss and parmesan cheeses
Shrimp Tacos (2)$21.95
grilled shrimp, flour tortillas, cabbage slaw, pico de gallo, creamy lime-cilantro sauce
Quesadilla$19.95
chicken or shrimp with peppers and onions, sour cream, pico de gallo
Our Own Key West Cheesesteak$19.95
peppers, onions and white cheddar
Shrimp & Andouille Sausage Po'boy$19.95
crispy shrimp, andouille sausage, Cajun remoulade
Old Fashioned Fried Chicken Sandwich$19.95
fried chicken breast, pickles, spicy mayo
One Great Simple Burger*$19.95
charbroiled ground beef, mixed greens, sliced tomato
House Made Veggie Burger$18.95
mixed greens, sliced tomato, zesty mayo
Open-Faced Tuna Salad$18.95
aged balsamic marinated tomatoes, garlic rubbed multi-grain bread
Grilled Caesar*$21.95
choice of chicken or shrimp, crunchy hearts of romaine, shaved parmesan
Gulf Shrimp Salad$21.95
tossed with lemon dressing over mixed greens, sliced tomato garnish

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Sarabeth's in at other Key West restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Key West results, every place ranked, so you can compare Sarabeth's in with the rest of the city.

Omelette6 on the menuWestern Omelet$15.95about the city median Breakfast7 on the menuTraditional Breakfast*$15.95$2.45 over city median French toast3 on the menuAlmond Crusted Cinnamon French Toast$15.95about the city median Burger2 on the menuOne Great Simple Burger*$19.95$2.45 over city median Pancakes2 on the menuLemon Ricotta Pancakes$14.95$5 over city median Bagel and lox1 on the menuGoldie Lox$16.95about the city median Caesar salad1 on the menuGrilled Caesar*$21.95$7 over city median Cheesesteak1 on the menuOur Own Key West Cheesesteak$19.95$5.95 over city median

What things cost at Sarabeth's in

Sarabeth's in's signature plates against the Key West median for the same dish.

Traditional Breakfast* $15.95 over the Key West breakfast median of $13.50
Western Omelet $15.95 over the Key West omelette median of $14.95
Almond Crusted Cinnamon French Toast $15.95 under the Key West french toast median of $16.95
One Great Simple Burger* $19.95 over the Key West burger median of $17.50
Lemon Ricotta Pancakes $14.95 over the Key West pancakes median of $9.95
Goldie Lox $16.95 at the Key West bagel and lox median of $16.95

Own Sarabeth's in? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Key West

See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Key West

Cheeseburger Pepperoni pizza Cuban sandwich Fried rice Cheesesteak Italian sub Spaghetti and meatballs Grouper sandwich Fish and chips General tso Smash burger Filet mignon Ribeye Fettuccine alfredo Chicken parm Lasagna Breakfast burrito Brisket Pulled pork Baby back ribs Cold brew Iced latte Margarita Mojito Espresso martini Acai bowl Pancakes French toast Eggs benedict Bacon egg and cheese Key lime pie Ceviche Caesar salad Conch fritters Ipa Omelette Caprese Calamari Chicken sandwich Grilled salmon Espresso Coconut shrimp Cortadito Crab cakes Burrata Cheesecake Mac and cheese Fish tacos Mimosa Pina colada Old fashioned NY strip Paloma Onion rings Bloody mary Lobster tail Guacamole Ravioli Sangria Lobster roll Hummus Fried shrimp Mozzarella sticks Bolognese Reuben Gnocchi Ahi tuna Dumplings Avocado toast Teriyaki Tostones Poke bowl Croquetas Mahi sandwich Margherita pizza Tiramisu Spring rolls Empanadas Milkshake Carne asada Churrasco Carbonara Shrimp scampi Stone crab Fajitas Lobster bisque Bagel and lox Thai curry Tamales French onion soup Chocolate cake Jerk chicken Cannoli Eggplant parm Ropa vieja Egg roll Tres leches Flan Aperol spritz Gyro Crab rangoon Edamame Al pastor Negroni Wagyu Chicken and waffles Enchiladas Nashville hot chicken Chicken noodle soup Patty melt Cacio e pepe Gelato Biscuits and gravy Clam chowder

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list

Cheeseburger25 Pepperoni pizza12 Cuban sandwich15 Fried rice8 Cheesesteak11 Italian sub3 Spaghetti and meatballs3 Grouper sandwich3 Fish and chips22 General tso3 Smash burger7 Filet mignon17 Ribeye15 Fettuccine alfredo4 Chicken parm12 Lasagna9 Breakfast burrito6 Brisket3 Pulled pork10 Baby back ribs9 Cold brew8 Iced latte21 Margarita45 Mojito34 Espresso martini11 Acai bowl5 Pancakes27 French toast18 Eggs benedict8 Bacon egg and cheese6 Key lime pie50 Ceviche27 Caesar salad55 Conch fritters46 Ipa37 Omelette34 Caprese33 Calamari32 Chicken sandwich31 Grilled salmon30 Espresso29 Coconut shrimp26 Cortadito24 Crab cakes22 Burrata21 Cheesecake21 Mac and cheese19 Fish tacos19 Mimosa18 Pina colada18 Old fashioned17 NY strip17 Paloma16 Onion rings15 Bloody mary15 Lobster tail14 Guacamole14 Ravioli14 Sangria14 Lobster roll13 Hummus13 Fried shrimp13 Mozzarella sticks12 Bolognese12 Reuben12 Gnocchi12 Ahi tuna11 Dumplings10 Avocado toast9 Teriyaki9 Tostones9 Poke bowl9 Croquetas8 Mahi sandwich8 Margherita pizza8 Tiramisu8 Spring rolls8 Empanadas7 Milkshake7 Carne asada7 Churrasco7 Carbonara7 Shrimp scampi7 Stone crab6 Fajitas6 Lobster bisque6 Bagel and lox6 Thai curry6 Tamales6 French onion soup6 Chocolate cake6 Jerk chicken6 Cannoli5 Eggplant parm5 Ropa vieja5 Egg roll5 Tres leches5 Flan5 Aperol spritz4 Gyro4 Crab rangoon4 Edamame4 Al pastor4 Negroni4 Wagyu4 Chicken and waffles3 Enchiladas3 Nashville hot chicken3 Chicken noodle soup3 Patty melt3 Cacio e pepe3 Gelato3 Biscuits and gravy3 Clam chowder3