Key West

Pepperoni pizza in Key West

Every pepperoni pizza on every menu we have read in Key West, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

12 places in Key West have pepperoni pizza on the menu, from $10 at Onlywood Grill to $29.99 at Duetto Pizza and Gelato. Highest rated: White Street Pizza (4.7), Mr. Z's (4.6), Smokin' Tuna Saloon (4.6). Smokin' Tuna Saloon, Onlywood Grill, Bruschetta Francesca run a happy hour. 9 of 12 list a price.

Duetto Pizza and Gelato

540 Greene St #1 · Pizza · website

Full menu 4.5 (1,589)3 pepperoni pizzas
1
  • Valentino Pepperoni Pizza$24.75
  • GF- Pepperoni$26.75
  • Pepperoni + Pint$29.99

    "Roni Cups" that curl up to keep the mouth-watering oil on your pizza, mozzarella and our special tomato sauce

Valentino Pepperoni Pizza at Duetto Pizza and Gelato is $24.75 in Key West. Duetto Pizza and Gelato on 540 Greene St #1 is a pizza rated 4.5 (1,589 reviews). The menu lists 3 pepperoni pizzas, from $24.75 for the Valentino Pepperoni Pizza to $29.99, above the Key West median of $22. Also on the menu: caesar salad, caprese, chicken.

Own Duetto Pizza and Gelato? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

White Street Pizza

1110 White St · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.7 (173)1 pepperoni pizza
2
  • Pepperoni Pizza$23

    Tomato sauce, fior di latte mozzarella, pepperoni, and shaved parmigiano reggiano

Pepperoni Pizza at White Street Pizza is $23 in Key West. White Street Pizza on 1110 White St is a restaurant rated 4.7 (173 reviews). The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza at $23, above the Key West median of $22. Also on the menu: caesar salad, caprese, chicken.

Own White Street Pizza? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Angelina's Pizzeria

208 Duval St #6508 · Pizza · website

Full menu 4.1 (748)2 pepperoni pizzas
3
  • Pepperoni Slice A slice of cheese pizza topped with pepperoni$6.25
  • Pepperoni Sub Made with Angelina's Marinara & Provolone$15

Pepperoni Slice A slice of cheese pizza topped wit at Angelina's Pizzeria is $6.25 in Key West. Angelina's Pizzeria on 208 Duval St #6508 is a pizza rated 4.1 (748 reviews). The menu lists 2 pepperoni pizzas, from $6.25 for the Pepperoni Slice A slice of cheese pizza to $15, below the Key West median of $22. Also on the menu: chicken parm, chicken tenders, dessert.

Own Angelina's Pizzeria? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Bruschetta Francesca, Key West

Bruschetta Francesca

112 Fitzpatrick St · italian · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4 PM-6:30 PM1 pepperoni pizza
4
  • Pepperoni$29

    Pepperoni, mozzarella, marinara sauce

Pepperoni at Bruschetta Francesca is $29 in Key West. Bruschetta Francesca on 112 Fitzpatrick St is an italian. The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza at $29, above the Key West median of $22. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6:30 PM. Also on the menu: beer, bolognese, cacio e pepe.

Own Bruschetta Francesca? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Conchiglia, Key West

Conchiglia

816 Duval St · italian · website

Full menu 2 pepperoni pizzas
5
  • Pepperoni Storm Pizza$24

    Wood-fired pizza with crisp pepperoni, bubbling mozzarella, and classic Italian-American comfort.

  • Pepperoni Storm

    Mozzarella, spicy pepperoni, San Marzano tomato

Pepperoni Storm Pizza at Conchiglia is $24 in Key West. Conchiglia on 816 Duval St is an italian. The menu lists 2 pepperoni pizzas at $24, above the Key West median of $22. Also on the menu: avocado toast, bolognese, breakfast.

Own Conchiglia? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Mr. Z's

501 Southard St · Cheesesteak · website

Full menu 4.6 (2,220)1 pepperoni pizza
6
  • Slice Of Pepperoni Pizza$6

Slice Of Pepperoni Pizza at Mr. Z's is $6 in Key West. Mr. Z's on 501 Southard St is a cheesesteak rated 4.6 (2,220 reviews). The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza at $6, below the Key West median of $22. Also on the menu: cheesesteak, chicken, chicken parm.

Own Mr. Z's? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Onlywood Grill, Key West

Onlywood Grill

725 Caroline St Unit E · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4:30 PM - 6:00 PM2 pepperoni pizzas
8
  • Mini Pepperoni Pizza$10
  • Pepperoni$21.50

    With pepperoni and homemade mozzarella

Mini Pepperoni Pizza at Onlywood Grill is $10 in Key West. Onlywood Grill on 725 Caroline St Unit E is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 pepperoni pizzas, from $10 for the Mini Pepperoni Pizza to $21.50, below the Key West median of $22. Happy hour Daily 4:30 PM - 6:00 PM. Also on the menu: bolognese, burger, burrata.

Own Onlywood Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Tavern N Town, Key West

Tavern N Town

Marriott Beachside Hotel · american · website

Full menu Happy Hour 5-7 PM & 9-11 PM1 pepperoni pizza
9
  • Spicy Pepperoni

    ricotta cheese, pestom vodka sauce, house hot honey, basil

Tavern N Town on Marriott Beachside Hotel is an american. The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza. Happy hour 5-7 PM & 9-11 PM. Also on the menu: burger, calamari, chicken.

Own Tavern N Town? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Smokin' Tuna Saloon

313 Duval St · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.6 (1,982)Happy Hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM1 pepperoni pizza
10
  • Pepperoni$16

    Mozzarella, marinara, pepperoni

Pepperoni at Smokin' Tuna Saloon is $16 in Key West. Smokin' Tuna Saloon on 313 Duval St is a restaurant rated 4.6 (1,982 reviews). The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza at $16, below the Key West median of $22. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: baby back ribs, bbq, beer.

Own Smokin' Tuna Saloon? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Grove, Key West

The Grove

2801 N Roosevelt Blvd · bar · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4pm-6pm1 pepperoni pizza
11
  • Pepperoni$22

Pepperoni at The Grove is $22 in Key West. The Grove on 2801 N Roosevelt Blvd is a bar. The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza at $22, around the Key West median of $22. Happy hour Daily 4pm-6pm. Also on the menu: acai bowl, al pastor, beer.

Own The Grove? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine

1019 White St · mediterranean · website

Full menu 1 pepperoni pizza
12
  • Pepperoni21/25

    beef pepperoni, tomato sauce, mozzarella

Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine on 1019 White St is a mediterranean. The menu lists 1 pepperoni pizza. Also on the menu: breakfast, brunch, burrata.

Own Oasis Mediterranean Cuisine? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About pepperoni pizza in Key West

12 of the 162 restaurants and bars we track in Key West list pepperoni pizza. Prices run from $10 at Onlywood Grill to $29.99 at Duetto Pizza and Gelato, with a median of $22. Most of them sit along Duval St and White St. The highest rated is White Street Pizza (4.7), and Smokin' Tuna Saloon, Onlywood Grill pair it with a happy hour.

12places
$10–$29.99price range
$22median
White Street Pizzatop rated
Cheapest
$10 at Onlywood Grill
Most expensive
$29.99 at Duetto Pizza and Gelato
Most spots
Duval St · White St · Southard St
Happy hour
Smokin' Tuna Saloon, Onlywood Grill, Bruschetta Francesca, Tavern N Town
Menus read
October 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Key West

Questions

Where is the cheapest pepperoni pizza in Key West?

Onlywood Grill lists Mini Pepperoni Pizza at $10. Median across 12 places is $22.

Which Key West spot has the best-rated pepperoni pizza?

White Street Pizza (4.7 from 173 reviews), Mr. Z's (4.6 from 2,220 reviews), Smokin' Tuna Saloon (4.6 from 1,982 reviews).

Any pepperoni pizza places with a happy hour?

Smokin' Tuna Saloon: Daily 4 PM-6 PM; Onlywood Grill: Daily 4:30 PM - 6:00 PM; Bruschetta Francesca: Daily 4 PM-6:30 PM.

Every cuisine and category in Key West

See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Key West

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?