Key West

Reuben in Key West

Every reuben on every menu we have read in Key West, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

12 places in Key West have reuben on the menu, from $13.50 at Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market to $26 at The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant. Highest rated: Goldman's Deli (4.7), White Street Pizza (4.7), Fisherman's Cafe (4.6). The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant, Salty Frog's Bar & Grill, Celtic Conch Public House run a happy hour. 10 of 12 list a price.

Fisherman's Cafe

205 Elizabeth St Unit D · American · website

Full menu 4.6 (557)1 reuben
1
  • Traditional Reuben Sandwich$14.95

    Served with side of french fries

Traditional Reuben Sandwich at Fisherman's Cafe is $14.95 in Key West. Fisherman's Cafe on 205 Elizabeth St Unit D is an american rated 4.6 (557 reviews). The menu lists 1 reuben at $14.95, below the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: breakfast, burrito, cheesesteak.

Own Fisherman's Cafe? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Harpoon Harry's, Key West

Harpoon Harry's

832 Caroline St · american · website

Full menu 1 reuben
2
  • Grilled Reuben$13.95

    corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, Thousand Island on rye

Grilled Reuben at Harpoon Harry's is $13.95 in Key West. Harpoon Harry's on 832 Caroline St is an american. The menu lists 1 reuben at $13.95, below the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: bagel and lox, beer, bloody mary.

Own Harpoon Harry's? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Goldman's Deli

2796 N Roosevelt Blvd · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.7 (1,123)2 reubens
3
  • The Reuben$17.95

    Hot Corned Beef with Kraut, Swiss & Russian Dressing on grilled Rye

  • Monster Reuben$23.95

    Hot Corned Beef & Hot Pastrami with Kraut, Swiss Russian Dressing, grilled on Rye

The Reuben at Goldman's Deli is $17.95 in Key West. Goldman's Deli on 2796 N Roosevelt Blvd is a restaurant rated 4.7 (1,123 reviews). The menu lists 2 reubens, from $17.95 for the The Reuben to $23.95, around the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: avocado toast, bagel and lox, breakfast.

Own Goldman's Deli? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

White Street Pizza

1110 White St · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.7 (173)1 reuben
4
  • Reuben Sandwich$18

    Classic Rueben sandwich on grilled fresh rye bread with sliced corned beef, melted swiss cheese, sauerkraut & thousand island dressing served with our crispy crunchers, homemade red sauce & pickles

Reuben Sandwich at White Street Pizza is $18 in Key West. White Street Pizza on 1110 White St is a restaurant rated 4.7 (173 reviews). The menu lists 1 reuben at $18, above the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: caesar salad, caprese, chicken.

Own White Street Pizza? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Hurricane Hole, Key West

Hurricane Hole

5130 Overseas Hwy · american, seafood · website

Full menu Happy Hour 3pm-6pm1 reuben
5
  • Catch Reuben$22.75

    Catch of the day lightly breaded & fried crispy, sauerkraut, swiss cheese & house thousand island on texas toast

Catch Reuben at Hurricane Hole is $22.75 in Key West. Hurricane Hole on 5130 Overseas Hwy is an american, seafood. The menu lists 1 reuben at $22.75, above the Key West median of $17.95. Happy hour 3pm-6pm. Also on the menu: beer, burger, caesar salad.

Own Hurricane Hole? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Celtic Conch Public House, Key West

Celtic Conch Public House

528 Front St Key West FL 33040 · irish pub · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Fri 4-7 PM1 reuben
6
  • Corn Beef Reuben

    sliced corn beef, sauerkraut & melted Swiss on grilled rye with a side of Thousand island dressing

Celtic Conch Public House on 528 Front St Key West FL 33040 is an irish pub. The menu lists 1 reuben. Happy hour Mon-Fri 4-7 PM. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, cheeseburger.

Own Celtic Conch Public House? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Brady's Pub Key West, Key West

Brady's Pub Key West

1900 Flagler Ave · bar & grill · website

Full menu 1 reuben
7
  • Classic Reuben

    Corned beef cooked to perfection, sauerkraut, swiss cheese & 1,000 Island on grilled marbled rye bread

Brady's Pub Key West on 1900 Flagler Ave is a bar & grill. The menu lists 1 reuben. Also on the menu: breakfast, burger, caesar salad.

Own Brady's Pub Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant

700 Front St #105 · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.5 (1,008)Happy Hour Daily 3 PM-5:30 PM1 reuben
8
  • Island Fish Reuben$26

    Fish of the Day (Grilled, Blackened or Fried) Citrus Slaw, 1000 Island and Swiss on Marble Rye

Island Fish Reuben at The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant is $26 in Key West. The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant on 700 Front St #105 is a restaurant rated 4.5 (1,008 reviews). The menu lists 1 reuben at $26, above the Key West median of $17.95. Happy hour Daily 3 PM-5:30 PM. Also on the menu: burger, ceviche, cheesesteak.

Own The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Pirate's Cove Key West

619 Front St · Breakfast · website

Full menu 3.8 (163)1 reuben
9
  • ONE-EYE WILLY (Classic Reuben)$17.99

    Grilled rye bread, thousand island dressing, thin sliced corned beet, sauerkraut & melted Swiss cheese

ONE-EYE WILLY (Classic Reuben) at Pirate's Cove Key West is $17.99 in Key West. Pirate's Cove Key West on 619 Front St is a breakfast rated 3.8 (163 reviews). The menu lists 1 reuben at $17.99, above the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: breakfast, burger, burrito.

Own Pirate's Cove Key West? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Salty Frog's Bar & Grill

407 Front St · Bar · website

Full menu 4.4 (715)Happy Hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM1 reuben
10
  • Cuban Reuben$15

    Corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and 1,000 island dressing on Cuban bread

Cuban Reuben at Salty Frog's Bar & Grill is $15 in Key West. Salty Frog's Bar & Grill on 407 Front St is a bar rated 4.4 (715 reviews). The menu lists 1 reuben at $15, below the Key West median of $17.95. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, burger, caesar salad.

Own Salty Frog's Bar & Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden, Key West

Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden

900 Duval St · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM and 1 reuben
11
  • To Go Reuben Egg Rolls$16

    slow cooked corn beef, sauerkraut, swiss, caraway, w/ thousand island dressing

To Go Reuben Egg Rolls at Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden is $16 in Key West. Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden on 900 Duval St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 reuben at $16, below the Key West median of $17.95. Happy hour Daily 4:00 PM - 7:00 PM and 11:00 PM - 1:00 AM. Also on the menu: bbq, burger, burrata.

Own Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market

917 Simonton St · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 reuben
12
  • Tempeh Reuben$13.50

    Tempeh on bakery bread with organic sauerkraut and vegan thousand island dressing and a salad.

Tempeh Reuben at Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market is $13.50 in Key West. Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market on 917 Simonton St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 reuben at $13.50, below the Key West median of $17.95. Also on the menu: acai bowl, burger, hot dog.

Own Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About reuben in Key West

12 of the 162 restaurants and bars we track in Key West list reuben. Prices run from $13.50 at Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market to $26 at The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant, with a median of $17.95. Most of them sit along Front St and N Roosevelt Blvd. The highest rated is Goldman's Deli (4.7), and The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant, Salty Frog's Bar & Grill pair it with a happy hour.

12places
$13.50–$26price range
$17.95median
Goldman's Delitop rated
Cheapest
$13.50 at Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market
Most expensive
$26 at The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant
Most spots
Front St · N Roosevelt Blvd · Elizabeth St Unit D
Happy hour
The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant, Salty Frog's Bar & Grill, Celtic Conch Public House, Hurricane Hole
Menus read
October 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Key West

Questions

Where is the cheapest reuben in Key West?

Sugar Apple Organic Cafe & Market lists Tempeh Reuben at $13.50. Median across 12 places is $17.95.

Which Key West spot has the best-rated reuben?

Goldman's Deli (4.7 from 1,123 reviews), White Street Pizza (4.7 from 173 reviews), Fisherman's Cafe (4.6 from 557 reviews).

Any reuben places with a happy hour?

The White Tarpon Bar & Restaurant: Daily 3 PM-5:30 PM; Salty Frog's Bar & Grill: Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM; Celtic Conch Public House: Mon-Fri 4-7 PM.

Every cuisine and category in Key West

See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Key West

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?