Key West

Pirate's Cove Key West Menu & Prices

Pirate's Cove Key West · 619 Front St · Breakfast

55 items read from Pirate's Cove's own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026. Signature plates: ONE-EYE WILLY (Classic Reuben) $17.99, Bilge Or Veggie Bilge Breakfast Ba $12.95, Popeye’s Omelette $14.95.

Pirate's Cove Menu

Key West · 55 items

Omelettes and Plates see more omelette in Key West

  • Popeye’s Omelette$14.95

    Spinach, mushrooms, garlic and cheese

  • Yardarm (Western) Omelette$14.99

    ham, onion, green pepper & choice of cheese. (served: with toast & home fries, hash brown or grits)

  • Keel Haul Omelette$14.95

    Bacon, onion, tomato & choice of cheese. (served: with toast & home fries, hash brown or grits)

  • Poop Deck$17.99

    Corned beef hash topped with cheddar jack, 2 eggs any style

  • Jolly Roger RIB EYE Steak$17.99

    6 oz. char-broiled steak, with two eggs any style

Benedicts&Specials

  • Classic Benedict$15.99

    Choice of Ham, Sausage, Bacon, or Pulled Pork. Served on an English muffin topped with 2 poached eggs, homefries, and hollandaise sauce

  • Pirate's Cove Benedict$20.99

    Crab & Avocado, Lobster, or Smoked Salmon. Served on an English muffin topped with 2 poached eggs, homefries, and hollandaise sauce

  • Veggie Benedict$17.99

    Spinach, mushrooms, avocado topped with a Hollandaise touch of pesto. Served on an English muffin topped with 2 poached eggs, homefries, and hollandaise sauce

Pirate's Cove Sweet Breakfast Menu see more breakfast in Key West

  • OHH Matey Toast!$15.95

    2 French toast, sausage or bacon, 2 eggs any style with home fries

  • Wicked Wench$15.99

    French Toast with Ham & Swiss Cheese stuck in the middle, topped with touch of hollandaise, one egg any style

  • 2-2-2$11.95

    2 eggs any style, 2 pancakes & 2 strip of bacon

  • Full Stack Pancake$9.95
  • French Toast$7.95

Pirate's Cove Breakfast Sandwiches Menu see more breakfast in Key West

  • PEG LEG Billy$12.95

    2 fried eggs, tomato, ham & American cheese on Cuban bread

  • Breakfast Burrito$13.95

    Egg, green pepper, onion, cheddar jack cheese & choice of Bacon, Sausage or Ham with salsa & sour cream on the side

  • Captain Blie$15.95

    2 fried eggs, Turkey, Ham, Swiss & Provolone Cheese on toasted Kaiser roll

  • Bilge Or Veggie Bilge Breakfast Bagel$12.95

    Eggs omelet style & choice of toasted bagel and cheese also ham, bacon or sausage. Veggie is with spinach, tomato, mushroom

  • Scourge OF Seven Seas$18.99

    6oz. smoked salmon, capers, cucumber, tomato, red onions, a choice of bagel & cream cheese

  • Cheese Grits With Lobster Or Shrimp$12.95

    sauteed in season butter, on top of cheesed grits, and a pirate salsa served on the side

Appetizers

  • Conch Fritters$15.99

    Handmade Conch fritters lightly fried, on a bed of greens with cocktail sauce

  • Coconut shrimp$15.99

    Lightly fried coconut-crusted shrimp served on a bed of greens with mango sauce

  • Chicken wings$15.99

    Deep fried chicken wings with your choice: Buffalo (Mild, Medium or Hot), or BBQ or Teriyaki. Served with celery and Blue cheese or Ranch dressing

  • Chicken tenders$14.99

    Chicken tenders served with curly Q fries and honey mustard

  • Calamari rings$11.99
  • Onion Rings$6.99

Salads see more salad in Key West

  • Greek Salad$12.99

    Crisp-chilled Romain ettuce, cucumber, tomato, red onion, black olives, banana peppers, feta cheese & cucumber sauce

  • Avocado Ranch Salad$12.99

    Crisp-chilled Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, red onion, avocado slices, black beans, salsa, cheese and avocado ranch sauce

  • Ceaser Salad$11.99

    Crisp-chilled Romaine lettuce, topped with Parmesan cheese, crunchy croutons and creamy Caesar dressing

  • Garden Salad$11.99
  • Seared Tuna Salad$18.99

    Blend of salad, fresh tomato, onion, black olives, cucumber, roasted red pepper, feta cheese side of balsamic vinaigrette and wasabi

Sandwiches see more sandwich in Key West

  • RED BEARD CUBAN MIX (Panini style)$15.99

    Roasted Pork, Ham, mustard, pickles, Swiss cheese on Cuban bread

  • ONE-EYE WILLY (Classic Reuben)$17.99

    Grilled rye bread, thousand island dressing, thin sliced corned beet, sauerkraut & melted Swiss cheese

  • CUBAN PIRATE (panini style)$15.99

    Turkey, Bacon, garlic mayo, tomato & Swiss cheese pressed to perfection on a cuban roll

  • Italian Pirate$16.99

    Ham, Salami, red onion, red peppers, crisp lettuce, reduced Balsamic vinaigrette, pesto and provolone cheese on toasted cuban roll

  • Sneaky Pete$15.99

    Ham, Turkey, mayo, lettuce, tomato, red onion & Swiss cheese wrap into flat bread

  • THE Nasty Wench$16.99

    Pulled Pork with Chipotle BBQ sauce, melted cheddar topped with fried onions on a kasier roll

  • Pirate's Booty$16.99

    Grilled -Marinated Chicken, with wine sauteed onion and mushroom, lettuce, tomato, & melted Swiss cheese on a cuban roll

  • Scallywag$17.99

    Blackened Mahi, Cole Slaw, tomato, fresh avocado, creamy cilantro & lime sauce on the side. Placed in a Brie Roll

  • MAN O WAR$18.99

    Charred-Grilled Ribeye-eye steak with wine caramelized onion and mushroom with melted Swiss cheese in kaiser roll

  • Hornswaggling$17.99

    Fried seasoned New Orleans-style shrimp with crunchy cabbage, tomatoes drizzled with remoulade sauce on lightly toasted cuban roll with a side of curly fries

Burgers see more burger in Key West

  • Howling Lusty Wench$16.99

    1/2 1b. Black Angus ground beef, garlic mayo, lettuce, tomato, smoked bacon, topped with golden fried onion and melted cheese

  • Royal Fortune$15.99

    1/2 1b. Black Augus ground beef,lettuce, tomato, onion and melted cheese

  • Blue Mattie$16.99

    1/2 1b. Black Angus ground beef, lettuce, tomato, onion with blue cheese and topped with smoked bacon

Wrap and Burrito see more burrito in Key West

  • THE Caesar Wrap$15.95

    Caesar salad with Grilled Chicken in a wrap

  • BIG FAT Burrito$15.95

    Grilled Chicken, lettuce, cucumber, red onion, black olives, banana peppers, feta cheese & our creamy Greek Dressing, Toppings $1 each (roasted red bell pepper, banana peppers, jalapeno, dressings, sl

  • Quesadilla$15.95

    Grilled chicken , onion, green pepper and sour cream and salsa on the side

  • Fish Tacos$16.99

    Blackened Mahi, with wine sautéed onion and mushrooms, lettuce, tomato, melted Swiss cheese on a cuban roll

Pirate’s Cove Kids’ Menu

  • Key West Breakfast Platter

    includes fluffy eggs, crispy bacon, and homemade grits

  • Grilled Cheese
  • Chicken Tenders
  • Mini Burgers
  • Fresh Catch Sandwich

    Made with locally caught fish, it’s served on a toasted bun with crisp lettuce and a tangy sauce

  • Sunset Breeze Cocktail

    refreshing mix of tropical flavors that captures the spirit of Key West

  • Pirate’s Rum Punch

    Made with a blend of rums and fresh fruit juices

  • Coconut Lime Cooler

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Pirate's Cove at other Key West restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Key West results, every place ranked, so you can compare Pirate's Cove with the rest of the city.

What things cost at Pirate's Cove

Pirate's Cove's signature plates against the Key West median for the same dish.

Own Pirate's Cove? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Key West

See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Key West

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list