Old Town Mexican Cafe Key West Menu & Prices
609 Duval St · Mexican
Food Menu Page 1, Tequila Varieties. 265 items read from Old Town Mexican Cafe's own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026. Signature plates: 3-Cheese Quesadilla $17.50, Veggie $20.50, Baja Tacos $24.50.
Search popular dishes & drinks found at Old Town Mexican Cafe at other Key West restaurants
Each card opens that dish's Key West results, every place ranked, so you can compare Old Town Mexican Cafe with the rest of the city.
Salad5 on the menuGarden Salad$19$3.05 over city medianSoup1 on the menuTortilla Soup$9.50about the city medianFajitas6 on the menuVeggie$20.50$7 under city medianTacos6 on the menuBaja Tacos$24.50$6.50 over city medianEnchiladas5 on the menuEnchilada Verde$21.50$2.50 over city medianBurrito6 on the menuGarden Burrito$20.50$3.80 over city medianQuesadilla7 on the menu3-Cheese Quesadilla$17.50$2.51 over city medianDessert6 on the menuVery Traditional KEY LIME PIE$10.50$1.50 over city median
Guacamole5 on the menuGUACAMOLE Traditional Style$13$3.01 over city medianGrilled salmon4 on the menuGrilled Salmon & Spinach$22.50$3.50 over city medianSteak3 on the menuSTEAK 8 Oz. Angus$28about the city medianVegetarian3 on the menuVeggie$20.50$3.75 over city medianFries2 on the menuFish Fingers With Fries$12.50$3.50 over city medianIce cream2 on the menuFried ICE Cream With Belgian Chocolate Sauce & C$10.50$1.50 over city medianCalamari1 on the menuCalamari Cabo$17$2 over city medianCarne asada1 on the menuCarne Asada$34.50$9.55 over city medianCheeseburger1 on the menu8 OZ. Cheeseburger$19.50$3 over city medianCrab cakes1 on the menuCRAB CAKES on a Bed of Greens$19.50about the city medianFlan1 on the menuToasted Coconut Flan$9$5 under city medianKey lime pie1 on the menuVery Traditional KEY LIME PIE$10.50about the city medianLasagna1 on the menuMexican Lasagna$22.50about the city medianNachos1 on the menuOLD Town Nachos$19about the city medianPulled pork1 on the menuPulled Pork Chimichanga$21.50$3.50 over city medianSeafood1 on the menuSeafood Veracruz$34.50$10.01 over city medianTamales1 on the menuTAMALE GRANDE with Salad & Casamientos$20.50$8.50 over city medianCoffee1 on the menuCuban Coffee ICE Cream$8.50$3.05 over city medianCortadito1 on the menuCuban Coffee ICE Cream$8.50$3.75 over city medianTea1 on the menuPepsi • Diet Pepsi • Club Soda • Lemonade Ginger$4.50about the city median
What things cost at Old Town Mexican Cafe
Old Town Mexican Cafe's signature plates against the Key West median for the same dish.
- 3-Cheese Quesadilla $17.50 over the Key West quesadilla median of $14.99
- Veggie $20.50 under the Key West fajitas median of $27.50
- Baja Tacos $24.50 over the Key West tacos median of $18
- Garden Burrito $20.50 over the Key West burrito median of $16.70
- Enchilada Verde $21.50 over the Key West enchiladas median of $19
- GUACAMOLE Traditional Style $13 over the Key West guacamole median of $9.99
Own Old Town Mexican Cafe? Claim it free, add photos & videos
Every cuisine and category in Key West
American / BBQSeafoodCoffeeBeer / WineCocktailsMexicanDessertDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianItalianSteakBrunchLatin / CaribbeanJapaneseChinesePizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamSandwichPastaSmoothiesSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersChicken
See all 39 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ140Seafood88Coffee85Beer / Wine84Cocktails79Mexican77Dessert77Dietary Restrictions76Gluten free26Vegan15Vegetarian62Italian67Steak55Brunch49Latin / Caribbean17Japanese11Chinese6Pizza21Burger80Sushi8Tacos52Wings59Burrito25Ice cream17Sandwich87Pasta47Smoothies17Soup52Breakfast44Salad112Fries70Chicken tenders47Tea68Fried chicken7Hot dog14Nachos34Quesadilla33Oysters25Chicken87
Every dish and drink in Key West
CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoSmash burgerFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladConch frittersIpaOmeletteCapreseCalamariChicken sandwichGrilled salmonEspressoCoconut shrimpCortaditoCrab cakesBurrataCheesecakeMac and cheeseFish tacosMimosaPina coladaOld fashionedNY stripPalomaOnion ringsBloody maryLobster tailGuacamoleRavioliSangriaLobster rollHummusFried shrimpMozzarella sticksBologneseReubenGnocchiAhi tunaDumplingsAvocado toastTeriyakiTostonesPoke bowlCroquetasMahi sandwichMargherita pizzaTiramisuSpring rollsEmpanadasMilkshakeCarne asadaChurrascoCarbonaraShrimp scampiStone crabFajitasLobster bisqueBagel and loxThai curryTamalesFrench onion soupChocolate cakeJerk chickenCannoliEggplant parmRopa viejaEgg rollTres lechesFlanAperol spritzGyroCrab rangoonEdamameAl pastorNegroniWagyuChicken and wafflesEnchiladasNashville hot chickenChicken noodle soupPatty meltCacio e pepeGelatoBiscuits and gravyClam chowder
See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger25Pepperoni pizza12Cuban sandwich15Fried rice8Cheesesteak11Italian sub3Spaghetti and meatballs3Grouper sandwich3Fish and chips22General tso3Smash burger7Filet mignon17Ribeye15Fettuccine alfredo4Chicken parm12Lasagna9Breakfast burrito6Brisket3Pulled pork10Baby back ribs9Cold brew8Iced latte21Margarita45Mojito34Espresso martini11Acai bowl5Pancakes27French toast18Eggs benedict8Bacon egg and cheese6Key lime pie50Ceviche27Caesar salad55Conch fritters46Ipa37Omelette34Caprese33Calamari32Chicken sandwich31Grilled salmon30Espresso29Coconut shrimp26Cortadito24Crab cakes22Burrata21Cheesecake21Mac and cheese19Fish tacos19Mimosa18Pina colada18Old fashioned17NY strip17Paloma16Onion rings15Bloody mary15Lobster tail14Guacamole14Ravioli14Sangria14Lobster roll13Hummus13Fried shrimp13Mozzarella sticks12Bolognese12Reuben12Gnocchi12Ahi tuna11Dumplings10Avocado toast9Teriyaki9Tostones9Poke bowl9Croquetas8Mahi sandwich8Margherita pizza8Tiramisu8Spring rolls8Empanadas7Milkshake7Carne asada7Churrasco7Carbonara7Shrimp scampi7Stone crab6Fajitas6Lobster bisque6Bagel and lox6Thai curry6Tamales6French onion soup6Chocolate cake6Jerk chicken6Cannoli5Eggplant parm5Ropa vieja5Egg roll5Tres leches5Flan5Aperol spritz4Gyro4Crab rangoon4Edamame4Al pastor4Negroni4Wagyu4Chicken and waffles3Enchiladas3Nashville hot chicken3Chicken noodle soup3Patty melt3Cacio e pepe3Gelato3Biscuits and gravy3Clam chowder3