Every cheesecake on every menu we have read in St. Augustine, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.
26 places in St. Augustine have cheesecake on the menu, from $3.75 at The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe to $13 at Forgotten Tonic. Highest rated: The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe (4.7), Carmelo's Pizzeria (4.6), Casa Benedetto's (4.6). Sogno, Forgotten Tonic, The Floridian run a happy hour. 24 of 26 list a price.
New York-Style Cheesecake Slice at Village Inn is $7 in St. Augustine. Village Inn on 900 N Ponce De Leon Blvd is a breakfast rated 4.3 (4,121 reviews). The menu lists 2 cheesecakes, from $7 for the New York-Style Cheesecake Slice to $40, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: biscuits and gravy, breakfast, breakfast burrito.
NY Style Cheesecake at Carmelo's Pizzeria is $6.49 in St. Augustine. Carmelo's Pizzeria on 146 W King St is a pizza rated 4.6 (2,903 reviews). The menu lists 2 cheesecakes at $6.49, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: chicken, dessert, fried chicken.
From Blueberry Bakery: crispy gingersnap cookies sandwiching house-made cheesecake filling. Spiced, creamy, and perfectly portable
Mini Turtle Cheesecake$6.50
From Blueberry Bakery: a mini house-made cheesecake on a graham cracker crust with dulce de leche, chocolate ganache, and chopped pecans. Rich, layered, and dangerously good. Contains nuts
Mini Oreo Cheesecake$6.50
From Blueberry Bakery: a mini house-made cheesecake on an Oreo crust, topped with caramel, chocolate ganache, and crushed Oreo. Cookies and cream, perfected
Mini Chocolate Cheesecake$6.50
From Blueberry Bakery: a mini chocolate cheesecake on an Oreo crust, topped with strawberry Chantilly. Dark, creamy, and fruit-kissed
Gingersnap Cheesecake Sandwich at Southern Grounds & Co. is $5.70 in St. Augustine. Southern Grounds & Co. on 124 King St is a cafe. The menu lists 4 cheesecakes, from $5.70 for the Gingersnap Cheesecake Sandwich to $6.50, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: avocado toast, bagel and lox, breakfast.
Key Lime Cheesecake at The Floridian is $12 in St. Augustine. The Floridian on 485 Old Beach Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 cheesecakes at $12, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Wed-Mon 3-5 PM. Also on the menu: banh mi, beer, brisket.
New York Style Cheesecake at Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine is $7.99 in St. Augustine. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - St Augustine on 200 Cbl Dr #101 is an italian. The menu lists 2 cheesecakes, from $7.99 for the New York Style Cheesecake to $8.99, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: baked ziti, bbq, bolognese.
Creamy peanut butter–banana cheesecake set atop a fudgy brownie crust, crowned with vanilla bean coconut whip, toasted almonds, and bittersweet chocolate chips
Lemon Meringue Cheesecake$13
Lemon cheesecake nestled on pistachio shortbread, layered with lemon curd and torched lemon meringue fluff, crowned with strawberry and thyme relish, finished with fragrant lemon zest and a drizzle of
Peanut Butter Brownie Cheesecake at Forgotten Tonic is $12 in St. Augustine. Forgotten Tonic on 6 Aviles St is an american. The menu lists 2 cheesecakes, from $12 for the Peanut Butter Brownie Cheesecake to $13, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Daily 5-7PM. Also on the menu: burger, burrata, chicken.
Mama Guava Cheesecake at Columbia Restaurant is $10 in St. Augustine. Columbia Restaurant on 98 St George St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $10, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: cheeseburger, chicken, chicken sandwich.
Cheesecake at Sogno is $12 in St. Augustine. Sogno on 830 Anastasia Blvd is an italian rated 4.4 (228 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $12, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Mon-Thu 4:30 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bolognese, burrata, caesar salad.
New York Cheesecake at Ruby Tuesday is $8.99 in St. Augustine. Ruby Tuesday on 2443 FL-16 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $8.99, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, bbq, burger.
Limoncello Cheesecake at Saint Italian Restaurant is $12 in St. Augustine. Saint Italian Restaurant on 44 Avenida Menendez is an italian rated 4.4 (1,400 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $12, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, brunch, burger.
Key Lime Pie, Double Chocolate Cake, or Salted Car at The Reef is $9 in St. Augustine. The Reef on 4100 Coastal Hwy is a seafood. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9, around the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Mon-Sat 3 PM-7 PM; Sun 4:30 PM-7 PM. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, biscuits and gravy, brunch.
Italian Cheesecake at Casa Benedetto's is $9.49 in St. Augustine. Casa Benedetto's on 197 Blackford Way is a southern italian rated 4.6 (827 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9.49, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: baked ziti, beer, caesar salad.
Strawberry Cheesecake at Texas Roadhouse is $6.99 in St. Augustine. Texas Roadhouse on 410 Outlet Mall Blvd is a steak house rated 4.3 (1,174 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $6.99, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: bbq, burger, caesar salad.
Seasonal Cheesecake at Sainte-George Restaurant is $10 in St. Augustine. Sainte-George Restaurant on 1 St George St is a restaurant rated 4.1 (1,193 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $10, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, breakfast, brunch.
Fried Cheesecake at Violas is $10 in St. Augustine. Violas on 6149 A1A S is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $10, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: baked ziti, bbq, beer.
Cheesecake at The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe is $3.75 in St. Augustine. The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe on 7 Old Mission Ave is a cafe rated 4.7 (851 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $3.75, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: bacon egg and cheese, beer, brunch.
New York Style Cheesecake at La Strada Italian Restaurant is $9.95 in St. Augustine. La Strada Italian Restaurant on 4075 A1A S is an italian rated 4.3 (647 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9.95, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, caesar salad, calamari.
Housemade Chocolate Cheesecake at Pizzalley's Chianti Room is $12 in St. Augustine. Pizzalley's Chianti Room on 60 Charlotte St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $12, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, caesar salad, calamari.
Chimi Cheesecake at La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar, St. Augustine is $10 in St. Augustine. La Catrina Tacos & Tequila Bar, St. Augustine on 155 Hampton Point Dr Ste 10 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $10, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, burrito, ceviche.
Strawberry Cheesecake at Carrabba's Italian Grill is $12.49 in St. Augustine. Carrabba's Italian Grill on 155 State Rte 312 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $12.49, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, burrata, caesar salad.
Oreo Cheesecake at Pesca Vilano Rooftop is $10 in St. Augustine. Pesca Vilano Rooftop on 117 Vilano Rd Unit R is a bar & grill. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $10, above the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Wed, Thu, Sun; Monday All Day 4-6 PM (Mon all day). Also on the menu: beer, burger, caesar salad.
Fried Cheesecake at Beaches At Vilano is $8.99 in St. Augustine. Beaches At Vilano on 254 Vilano Rd is a seafood. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $8.99, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Happy hour Monday-Friday 3pm-7pm. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.
Cheesecake Rolls at Vinny's Pizza is $7.27 in St. Augustine. Vinny's Pizza on 105 Yacht Club Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $7.27, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: baked ziti, bbq, caesar salad.
Fried Cheesecake at Jin Sushi Hibachi Thai is $7.95 in St. Augustine. Jin Sushi Hibachi Thai on 2730 FL-16 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $7.95, below the St. Augustine median of $9. Also on the menu: calamari, chicken, crab rangoon.
26 of the 199 restaurants and bars we track in St. Augustine list cheesecake. Prices run from $3.75 at The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe to $13 at Forgotten Tonic, with a median of $9. Most of them sit along A1A S and St George St. The highest rated is The Witty Whisker Cat Cafe (4.7), and Sogno, Forgotten Tonic pair it with a happy hour.
