Casa Benedetto's St. Augustine Menu & Prices
197 Blackford Way · Southern Italian
Catering, Wine List, Drinks. 183 items read from Casa Benedetto's' own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026. Signature plates: Sausage and Peppers with Pasta $15.95, Chicken Marsala $28.95, Zuppa de' Pesce $39.95.
Search popular dishes & drinks found at Casa Benedetto's at other St. Augustine restaurants
Each card opens that dish's St. Augustine results, every place ranked, so you can compare Casa Benedetto's with the rest of the city.
Pasta30 on the menuSausage and Peppers with Pasta$15.95$3 under city medianChicken6 on the menuChicken Marsala$28.95$12.96 over city medianSeafood6 on the menuZuppa de' Pesce$39.95$15.95 over city medianDessert11 on the menuChocolate Mocha Cake$10.49$1.49 over city medianSalad5 on the menuScungilli Salad$14.95$1.95 over city medianChicken parm4 on the menuChicken Parmigiana$27.95$7.95 over city medianCaprese3 on the menuMozzarella Caprese$14.95about the city medianEggplant parm3 on the menuEggplant Parmigiana$25.95$7.46 over city median
Lasagna3 on the menuHomemade Lasagna$23.95about the city medianCalamari2 on the menuCalamari Fritti$15.95about the city medianBaked ziti1 on the menuBaked ZitiCaesar salad1 on the menuHouse or Caesar SaladCarbonara1 on the menuTortellini Carbonara$28.95$7.05 under city medianCheesecake1 on the menuItalian Cheesecake$9.49about the city medianGluten free1 on the menuItalian Cheesecake$9.49$4.50 under city medianRavioli1 on the menuLobster Ravioli in Pink Cream Sauce$32.95$12.95 over city medianShrimp scampi1 on the menuShrimp Scampi$31.95$8.96 over city medianSoup1 on the menuHomemade SoupsTiramisu1 on the menuTiramisu 55 • Carrot Cake 52 • Coconut Cake 52Vegetarian1 on the menuLasagna (Meat or Veggie)Wine26 on the menu12eMezzo Primitivo Italy$34$4 under city medianSangria1 on the menuRed or White Made in-houseBeer2 on the menuImported Beer$6.95about the city medianTea2 on the menuHot Tea$3.50about the city medianCoffee1 on the menuHouse Coffee$3.95$1.05 under city medianEspresso1 on the menuEspresso$4.95about the city median
What things cost at Casa Benedetto's
Casa Benedetto's' signature plates against the St. Augustine median for the same dish.
- Sausage and Peppers with Pasta $15.95 under the St. Augustine pasta median of $18.95
- Chicken Marsala $28.95 over the St. Augustine chicken median of $15.99
- Zuppa de' Pesce $39.95 over the St. Augustine seafood median of $24
- Chicken Parmigiana $27.95 over the St. Augustine chicken parm median of $20
- Mozzarella Caprese $14.95 under the St. Augustine caprese median of $15.99
- Eggplant Parmigiana $25.95 over the St. Augustine eggplant parm median of $18.49
Own Casa Benedetto's? Claim it free, add photos & videos
Every cuisine and category in St. Augustine
American / BBQCoffeeDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianDessertBeer / WineMexicanSeafoodItalianSteakCocktailsBrunchJapaneseChineseLatin / CaribbeanThaiMediterraneanPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamSandwichPastaSmoothiesSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersChicken
See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ170Coffee96Dietary Restrictions96Gluten free33Vegan27Vegetarian72Dessert86Beer / Wine85Mexican77Seafood75Italian70Steak65Cocktails63Brunch46Japanese20Chinese14Latin / Caribbean14Thai7Mediterranean5Pizza37Burger68Sushi16Tacos47Wings59Burrito34Ice cream20Sandwich86Pasta43Smoothies7Soup69Breakfast36Salad138Fries94Chicken tenders47Tea78Fried chicken22Hot dog16Nachos28Quesadilla32Oysters30Chicken123
Every dish and drink in St. Augustine
CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsVodka saucePad thaiSmash burgerFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonChicken sandwichCalamariIpaOnion ringsMac and cheeseHummusCheesecakeSangriaCrab cakesFried shrimpEspressoOmeletteCapreseReubenGuacamoleAhi tunaMimosaEmpanadasBiscuits and gravyOld fashionedNY stripDumplingsEggplant parmAvocado toastRavioliMilkshakeEdamameFajitasFish tacosConch frittersPoke bowlMozzarella sticksEgg rollCortaditoBagel and loxSpring rollsBloody maryClam chowderBurrataCoconut shrimpGnocchiThai curryShrimp scampiChicken and wafflesTeriyakiLobster tailLobster rollPatty meltCrab rangoonTom yumCarne asadaTiramisuPrime ribBaked zitiEnchiladasGyroDrunken noodlesTamalesCannoliChocolate cakePina coladaMargherita pizzaFrench onion soupChurrosJerk chickenBologneseCroquetasCarbonaraWagyuArepasSurf and turfMatcha latteChurrascoTostonesSpicy tuna rollMahi sandwichPalomaPastramiBanh miBurnt endsLobster bisqueNegroni
See all 116 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger33Pepperoni pizza13Cuban sandwich11Fried rice15Cheesesteak10Italian sub6Spaghetti and meatballs9Grouper sandwich3Fish and chips23Vodka sauce5Pad thai7Smash burger6Filet mignon14Ribeye18Fettuccine alfredo3Chicken parm21Lasagna11Breakfast burrito6Brisket9Pulled pork12Baby back ribs6Cold brew12Iced latte19Margarita27Mojito12Espresso martini8Pancakes20French toast27Eggs benedict7Bacon egg and cheese10Key lime pie15Ceviche16Caesar salad60Grilled salmon58Chicken sandwich45Calamari43Ipa32Onion rings28Mac and cheese27Hummus26Cheesecake26Sangria26Crab cakes24Fried shrimp24Espresso23Omelette23Caprese19Reuben18Guacamole17Ahi tuna17Mimosa17Empanadas15Biscuits and gravy15Old fashioned15NY strip14Dumplings13Eggplant parm13Avocado toast13Ravioli13Milkshake13Edamame12Fajitas12Fish tacos12Conch fritters12Poke bowl11Mozzarella sticks11Egg roll10Cortadito10Bagel and lox10Spring rolls10Bloody mary10Clam chowder10Burrata9Coconut shrimp9Gnocchi8Thai curry8Shrimp scampi8Chicken and waffles7Teriyaki7Lobster tail7Lobster roll7Patty melt7Crab rangoon6Tom yum6Carne asada6Tiramisu6Prime rib6Baked ziti6Enchiladas6Gyro6Drunken noodles5Tamales5Cannoli5Chocolate cake5Pina colada5Margherita pizza5French onion soup5Churros5Jerk chicken4Bolognese4Croquetas4Carbonara4Wagyu4Arepas4Surf and turf4Matcha latte3Churrasco3Tostones3Spicy tuna roll3Mahi sandwich3Paloma3Pastrami3Banh mi3Burnt ends3Lobster bisque3Negroni3