Fort Myers

Dessert in Fort Myers

Every dessert on every menu we have read in Fort Myers, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

120 places in Fort Myers have dessert on the menu, from $2.99 at Tijuana Flats to $30 at Irie I Jamaican American cafe. Highest rated: Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers (4.7), The Pirate Seafood & Chicken (4.7), Ihop (4.6). The Firestone Skybar & Martini Bar, Lumber Axe Whiskey Bar & Grill, BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse run a happy hour. 106 of 120 list a price.

Key lime pie 11Cheesecake 52Chocolate cake 17Milkshake 16Tres leches 4Flan 4Gelato 4

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

12870 S Cleveland Ave · Italian · website

Full menu 4.3 (3,951)9 desserts
1
  • Warm Italian Doughnuts (V)$8.99

    Fried doughnuts tossed in vanilla sugar. Served with raspberry or chocolate sauce.

  • Tiramisu (V)$9.49

    The classic Italian dessert. A layer of creamy custard set atop espresso-soaked ladyfingers.

  • Sicilian Cheesecake with Strawberry Topping (V)$9.49

    Our rich and creamy ricotta cheesecake features a shortbread cookie crust and is topped with a sweet strawberry sauce. Go ahead, order dessert!

  • Chocolate Lasagna (V)$9.79

    Decadent layers of chocolate cake, creamy chocolate mousse, and a delicate layer of crushed wafers. Topped with chocolate sauce.

  • Strawberry Cream Cake (V)$9.79

    Vanilla sponge cake layered with sweet vanilla cream and topped with fresh strawberries.

  • Black Tie Mousse Cake (V)$9.99

    Rich layers of chocolate cake, dark chocolate cheesecake and creamy custard mousse.

  • Sicilian Cheesecake$38.99

    Our rich and creamy ricotta cheesecake features a shortbread cookie crust and is topped with a seasonal strawberry sauce. Order a whole or half cake today.

  • Tiramisu$38.99

    The classic Italian dessert. A layer of creamy custard set atop espresso-soaked ladyfingers. Order a whole or half cake today.

  • Black Tie Mousse Cake$38.99

    Rich layers of chocolate cake, dark chocolate cheesecake and creamy custard mousse. Order a whole or half cake today.

Warm Italian Doughnuts (V) at Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is $8.99 in Fort Myers. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant on 12870 S Cleveland Ave is an italian rated 4.3 (3,951 reviews). The menu lists 9 desserts, from $8.99 for the Warm Italian Doughnuts (V) to $38.99, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, calamari, carbonara.

Own Olive Garden Italian Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Sensaciones Restaurant - Cuban Cuisine

4650 S Cleveland Ave · Cuban · website

Full menu 4.6 (2,039)10 desserts
2
  • Flan$2.50

    Classic Cuban caramel custard

  • Arroz con Leche$3

    Traditional rice pudding (Cuban style)

  • Tiramisu$3.50

    Italian-style coee-avored dessert

  • Ice Cream$3.50

    Rich, velvety ice cream crafted for a refreshing and indulgent nish to your experience

  • Coffees$4.50
  • Espresso
  • Cortado
  • Cappuccino
  • Coffee w/ Milk
  • Café Bombón

Flan at Sensaciones Restaurant - Cuban Cuisine is $2.50 in Fort Myers. Sensaciones Restaurant - Cuban Cuisine on 4650 S Cleveland Ave is a cuban rated 4.6 (2,039 reviews). The menu lists 10 desserts, from $2.50 for the Flan to $4.50, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: calamari, cheeseburger, chicken sandwich.

Own Sensaciones Restaurant - Cuban Cuisine? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market

13451-16 McGregor Blvd · Seafood · website

Full menu 4.5 (1,528)7 desserts
3
  • Country Vanilla Ice Cream$7

    Plain or with your choice of chocolate or caramel topping

  • Villa Dolce Raspberry Sorbet$8
  • Apple Crisp$9

    served warm with vanilla ice cream and caramel

  • Key Lime Pie$9

    graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream & strawberry drizzle

  • Triple Chocolate Cake$10

    Layers of rich chocolate cake with chocolate frosting (a la mode $2)

  • Vanilla Bean Crème Brûlé$10

    "Burnt Cream" with caramelized sugar

  • Ask to see our list!

Country Vanilla Ice Cream at Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market is $7 in Fort Myers. Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market on 13451-16 McGregor Blvd is a seafood rated 4.5 (1,528 reviews). The menu lists 7 desserts, from $7 for the Country Vanilla Ice Cream to $10, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, caesar salad, calamari.

Own Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Terra Nostra Ristorante, Fort Myers

Terra Nostra Ristorante

15880 San Carlos Blvd · italian · website

Full menu 13 desserts
4
  • Vanilla ICE Cream$8
  • Double Mini Cannoli$8
  • Pistachio Gelato$9
  • Tiramisu$9
  • Crème Brulee$9
  • Cognac & Maple Syrup Crème Brûlée$9
  • Gelato Al Pistachio$9
  • Strawberry Sorbet$9
  • Chocolate Soufle$10
  • NY Cheese Cake$10
Show all 13 desserts
  • NY Cheesecake$10

    wild berry or chocolate covered

  • Cannoli-Misu$10
  • Chocolate Soufflé with Love Boat Vanilla Ice Cream$10

Vanilla ICE Cream at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $8 in Fort Myers. Double Mini Cannoli at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $8 in Fort Myers. Pistachio Gelato at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $9 in Fort Myers. Tiramisu at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $9 in Fort Myers. Crème Brulee at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $9 in Fort Myers. Cognac & Maple Syrup Crème Brûlée at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $9 in Fort Myers. Gelato Al Pistachio at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $9 in Fort Myers. Strawberry Sorbet at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $

Vanilla ICE Cream at Terra Nostra Ristorante is $8 in Fort Myers. Terra Nostra Ristorante on 15880 San Carlos Blvd is an italian. The menu lists 13 desserts, from $8 for the Vanilla ICE Cream to $10, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, bolognese, burrata.

Own Terra Nostra Ristorante? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Veranda

2122 Second St · Fine dining · website

Full menu 4.5 (1,425)15 desserts
5
  • Traditional Pumpkin Pie$10.95
  • Southern Pecan Praline Tart$10.95
  • Triple Layer Chocolate Pate with Raspberry Coulis$10.95
  • Creme Brûlée$13.95
  • Fresh Berries and Whipped Cream
  • Traditional Florida Key Lime Pie
  • Classic Vanilla Creme Brulee
  • Bailey's Irish Cream Cheesecake
  • Triple Layer Chocolate Pâté with Raspberry Coulis
  • Rich & Creamy Peanut Butter Fudge Pie
Show all 15 desserts
  • Warm Southern Pecan Praline Tart with Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Florida Key Lime Pie
  • Triple Chocolate Pate

    with Raspberry Coulis

  • Crème Brûlée
  • The Veranda Sampler

    A decadent sampling of our house made Triple Chocolate Pate & Key Lime Pie presented on a bed of raspberry coulis, garnished with fresh berries & whipped cream

Traditional Pumpkin Pie at The Veranda is $10.95 in Fort Myers. Southern Pecan Praline Tart at The Veranda is $10.95 in Fort Myers. Triple Layer Chocolate Pate with Raspberry Coulis at The Veranda is $10.95 in Fort Myers. Creme Brûlée at The Veranda is $13.95 in Fort Myers.

Traditional Pumpkin Pie at The Veranda is $10.95 in Fort Myers. The Veranda on 2122 Second St is a fine dining rated 4.5 (1,425 reviews). The menu lists 15 desserts, from $10.95 for the Traditional Pumpkin Pie to $13.95, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, caesar salad, cheesecake.

Own The Veranda? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

University Grill, Fort Myers

University Grill

7790 Cypress Lake Dr · bar & grill · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 3pm-6pm13 desserts
6
  • Key Lime Pie$8

    Florida fresh from Miami. Zest citrus filling in a graham cracker crust

  • Apple Crisp$8

    Warmed and topped with vanilla ice cream and salted caramel

  • Rotating Dessert$10

    ask your server for selection

  • Créme Brûlée Cheesecake$10

    topped with caramel sauce

  • Flourless Chocolate Cake$10

    dense, made with rich Belgian chocolate, sugar and cocoa powder

  • University Grill$10

    Kahlua & Amaretto

  • Prawnbroker$10

    Grand Marnier & Tia Maria

  • Tuacolate$10

    Tuaca & créme de cocoa

  • Mintini$10

    Green créme de menthe, white créme de cocoa, Kahlua & cream

  • Toffee Drop$10

    Jim Beam, butterscotch schnapps, white créme de cocoa & cream

Show all 13 desserts
  • Carrot Cake$10
  • Coffee 10
  • Martini Potions 10

Key Lime Pie at University Grill is $8 in Fort Myers. Apple Crisp at University Grill is $8 in Fort Myers. Rotating Dessert at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Créme Brûlée Cheesecake at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Flourless Chocolate Cake at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. University Grill at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Prawnbroker at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Tuacolate at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Mintini at University Grill is $10 in Fort Myers. Toffee

Key Lime Pie at University Grill is $8 in Fort Myers. University Grill on 7790 Cypress Lake Dr is a bar & grill. The menu lists 13 desserts, from $8 for the Key Lime Pie to $10, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Happy hour Daily 3pm-6pm. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, burger.

Own University Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Bellini's Fort Myers, Fort Myers

Bellini's Fort Myers

13451 McGregor Blvd Suites 5-9 · restaurant · website

Full menu 9 desserts
7
  • Homemade Gelato OR Sorbet$10
  • Chef DRE's White Chocolate, Prosecco & Peach Creme Brulee$12
  • Nonna’s Limondline Ricotta Bread Pudding$12
  • Ultimate Florida KEY Lime PIE$12
  • Basque Cheesecake$12
  • Lava Cake With Raspberry Coulis & Chocolate Ganache$13
  • Bellini's Tiramisu Experience$14

    Kahlja-espresso anglaise

  • Chocolate Toffee Mousse PIE Caramel, Chocolate Ganache$14
  • $ 8.00 – Bread Pudding-Cheesecake- Gelato or Sorbet

Homemade Gelato OR Sorbet at Bellini's Fort Myers is $10 in Fort Myers. Bellini's Fort Myers on 13451 McGregor Blvd Suites 5-9 is a restaurant. The menu lists 9 desserts, from $10 for the Homemade Gelato OR Sorbet to $14, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.

Own Bellini's Fort Myers? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill, Fort Myers

Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill

4125 Cleveland Ave · restaurant · website

Full menu 11 desserts
8
  • Ice cream 1 scoop$5.99
  • Churros only$8.99
  • Homemade Flan$9.99
  • Ice Cream 2 Scoops$9.99
  • Cuatro Leches$10.99
  • Fried Ice Cream$11.99
  • Sopapilla With Honey And Ice Cream$11.99
  • Churros With Ice Cream$12.99
  • 3 Layer Chocolate Cake With Ice Cream$13.99
  • (Regular) Cake fee$14.99
Show all 11 desserts
  • (Large) Cake fee$19.99

Ice cream 1 scoop at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $5.99 in Fort Myers. Churros only at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $8.99 in Fort Myers. Homemade Flan at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $9.99 in Fort Myers. Ice Cream 2 Scoops at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $9.99 in Fort Myers. Cuatro Leches at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $10.99 in Fort Myers. Fried Ice Cream at Mo

Ice cream 1 scoop at Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill is $5.99 in Fort Myers. Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill on 4125 Cleveland Ave is a restaurant. The menu lists 11 desserts, from $5.99 for the Ice cream 1 scoop to $19.99, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: al pastor, burrito, carne asada.

Own Monarca's Authentic Mexican Cuisine Bar & Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Bimini Bait Shack, Fort Myers

Bimini Bait Shack

17501 Harbour Pointe Dr · restaurant · website

Full menu 8 desserts
9
  • ICE Cream$3.99

    Ask your servers about today's flavors.

  • Authentic Caribbean Island RUM Cake$7.99

    A Bimini Bait Shack Classic! Baked with Dark Rum and chopped walnuts. Drizzled with a sweet White Rum sauce.

  • Brownie Sundae$7.99

    You choose your ice cream flavor, and we put it on our chocolate brownie then top it with chocolate & caramel syrup, candied walnuts, and whipped cream.

  • Pina Colada Cheesecake$8.99

    Makes a perfect compliment to our in-house frozen Pina Colada.

  • KEY Lime PIE$8.99

    A traditional Key West recipe.

  • Gilligan's Coconut Cream PIE$9.99

    Just like Ginger & Mary Ann used to make!

  • Florida Valencia Orange Cheesecake$9.99

    Just like biting into a Florida Valencia orange.

  • Chocoloco Bombshell$9.99

    Love Boat's Brownie batter fried Ice cream in a brown sugar dusted chocolate tortilla bowl, topped with brownie pieces, chocolate syrup and whipped cream.

ICE Cream at Bimini Bait Shack is $3.99 in Fort Myers. Bimini Bait Shack on 17501 Harbour Pointe Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 8 desserts, from $3.99 for the ICE Cream to $9.99, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, baby back ribs, beer.

Own Bimini Bait Shack? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar, Fort Myers

CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar

12901 McGregor Blvd #16 · restaurant · website

Full menu 10 desserts
10
  • Espresso Martini$12

    Stoli Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua, Espresso

  • Espresso & Baileys Tini$12
  • Espresso & Peanut Butter Tini$12
  • Espresso & White Choco Tini$12
  • Espresso & Buca Martini$12
  • Chocolate Martini$12

    Stoli Vanilla Vodka, Mozart White & Dark Chocolate Liquor

  • Mint Choco Tini$12

    Creme de Menthe White

  • Raspberry Choco Tini$12
  • White Choco Tini$12
  • Pistachio White Choco Tini$12

Espresso Martini at CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar is $12 in Fort Myers. CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar on 12901 McGregor Blvd #16 is a restaurant. The menu lists 10 desserts at $12, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, bolognese, calamari.

Own CIBO Italian Restaurant & Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Downtown House of Pizza, Fort Myers

Downtown House of Pizza

1520 Hendry St · restaurant · website

Full menu 8 desserts
11
  • NY cheesecake with chocolate drizzle
  • Carrot Cake with cream cheese frosting
  • Tiramisu
  • Chocolate Mousse
  • Gluten free brownie
  • Chocolate Cake
  • NY cheesecake
  • Chocolate dipped cannoli

Downtown House of Pizza on 1520 Hendry St is a restaurant. The menu lists 8 desserts. Also on the menu: cannoli, cheesecake, chicken.

Own Downtown House of Pizza? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Silver King Ocean Brasserie, Fort Myers

The Silver King Ocean Brasserie

2200 Edwards Dr · seafood · website

Full menu 9 desserts
12
  • Tiramisu Tres Leches$9

    Dean Street espresso cream-soaked cake, whipped mascarpone, cocoa dust, chocolate-covered espresso beans

  • Cream Sherry$10

    jose ramon • jerez-xérès • spain

  • Sauternes$10

    emotions de la tour • france

  • Raspberry-Chocolate Tart$11

    dark chocolate, raspberry mousse, raspberry coulis, crispy raspberry

  • Port - 10YR$11

    taylor fladgate • tawny • portugal

  • Petite Ice Cream Cones$12

    Four petite ice cream cones, rotating ice cream and gelato

  • Calvados$12

    christian drouin vsop • coudray-rabut • france

  • Black Muscat$18

    quady elysium, california

  • Port - 20YR$22

    penfolds • rare tawny • australia

Tiramisu Tres Leches at The Silver King Ocean Brasserie is $9 in Fort Myers. The Silver King Ocean Brasserie on 2200 Edwards Dr is a seafood. The menu lists 9 desserts, from $9 for the Tiramisu Tres Leches to $22, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, burger, chicken.

Own The Silver King Ocean Brasserie? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Blue Moon Pizza, Fort Myers

Blue Moon Pizza

7381 College Pkwy Ste 120 · pizza · website

Full menu 4.5 (1,135)4 desserts
13
  • Key Lime Pie$5.49

    Homemade mini pie/graham cracker crust creamy filling with key west lime juice/whipped cream

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae$5.99

    Homemade chocolate chip cookie baked fresh to order/vanilla ice cream chocolate

  • Turtle Cheese Cake$6.49

    Chocolate chip cheesecake/oreo cookie crust chocolate/pecans/caramel

  • Peanut Butter Heath Bar Brownie$6.59

    Homemade triple chocolate and peanut butter brownie/vanilla ice cream/heath bits/chocolate and caramel sauce

Key Lime Pie at Blue Moon Pizza is $5.49 in Fort Myers. Blue Moon Pizza on 7381 College Pkwy Ste 120 is a pizza rated 4.5 (1,135 reviews). The menu lists 4 desserts, from $5.49 for the Key Lime Pie to $6.59, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: bbq, caesar salad, caprese.

Own Blue Moon Pizza? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Unico Ristorante Italiano, Fort Myers

Unico Ristorante Italiano

19810 Village Center Dr Ste 145/A · restaurant · website

Full menu 7 desserts
14
  • Tiramisu$11.50
  • Cannoli$11.50
  • Delizia al Limone$13.50
  • Ricotta & Pere$13.50
  • Pastiera Napoletana$13.50
  • Torta Caprese$13.50
  • Nutella Pizza$16.50

Tiramisu at Unico Ristorante Italiano is $11.50 in Fort Myers. Unico Ristorante Italiano on 19810 Village Center Dr Ste 145/A is a restaurant. The menu lists 7 desserts, from $11.50 for the Tiramisu to $16.50, above the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: bolognese, burger, burrata.

Own Unico Ristorante Italiano? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Cracker Barrel Old Country Store

10090 Daniels Pkwy · American · website

Full menu 4.3 (5,473)4 desserts
15
  • Double Chocolate Fudge Coca-Cola® Cake$6.49

    A family sized rich, warm double chocolate fudge cake made with real Coca-Cola®. A true Cracker Barrel Old Country Store tradition.

  • Carrot Cake$6.99

    Moist carrot cake baked with coconut, pineapple, walnuts, cinnamon, and vanilla. Topped with cream cheese icing and chopped pecans.

  • Apple Cobbler Cheesecake$7.49

    Creamy apple cheesecake layered over a graham cracker crust. Topped with buttery streusel and caramel drizzle.

  • Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookies$11.29

    Serves 5 | Five Homestyle Chocolate Chip Cookies.

Double Chocolate Fudge Coca-Cola® Cake at Cracker Barrel Old Country Store is $6.49 in Fort Myers. Cracker Barrel Old Country Store on 10090 Daniels Pkwy is an american rated 4.3 (5,473 reviews). The menu lists 4 desserts, from $6.49 for the Double Chocolate Fudge Coca-Cola® Cake to $11.29, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: breakfast, burger, cheeseburger.

Own Cracker Barrel Old Country Store? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine, Fort Myers

Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine

15271 McGregor Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu 14 desserts
16
  • Greek Cookies$2.50

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Koulourakia$2.50

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Scoop of Ice Cream$2.75

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Rizogalo$6

    Greek Style rice pudding made with milk, rice and sugar and topped with cinnamon

  • Baklava$8

    Honey-brushed phyllo stuffed with walnuts and almonds baked. Served with Greek honey syrup and ice-cream. (Ice-cream dine-in only)

  • Baklava Cheesecake$8

    Greek style cheesecake filled with walnuts and almonds topped with phyllo

  • Sokolatina$8

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Kataifi$8

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Ekmek Kataifi$8.95

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Milfei$8.95

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

Show all 14 desserts
  • Galaktoboureko$8.95

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Mpougatsa$8.95

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

  • Loukoumades$12

    Greek doughnuts with your choice of Honey, Cinnamon and nuts or Nutella with nuts served with Ice-cream (ice-cream dine-in only)

  • Tsoureki$12.95

    Layers of rich chocolate cake and fudge frosting

Greek Cookies at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $2.50 in Fort Myers. Koulourakia at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $2.50 in Fort Myers. Scoop of Ice Cream at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $2.75 in Fort Myers. Rizogalo at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $6 in Fort Myers. Baklava at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $8 in Fort Myers. Baklava Cheesecake at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $8 in Fort Myers. Sokolatina at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $8 in Fort Myers. Kataifi at Mythos Authentic Greek

Greek Cookies at Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine is $2.50 in Fort Myers. Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine on 15271 McGregor Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 14 desserts, from $2.50 for the Greek Cookies to $12.95, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: burger, cheeseburger, cheesecake.

Own Mythos Authentic Greek Cuisine? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Fort Myers

Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

8841 College Pkwy · restaurant · website

Full menu 7 desserts
17
  • Zeppolis (Half)$6

    our homemade dough flash fried, tossed with powered sugar and served with chocolate and caramel sauce. A little taste of heaven in every bite.

  • Cannoli$8
  • Cheesecake$8
  • Chocolate Cake$8
  • Tiramisu$8
  • Carrot Cake$9

    No Nuts, just raisins. Moist carrot cake with a buttercream frosting.

  • Zeppolis (Full)$10

    our homemade dough flash fried, tossed with powered sugar and served with chocolate and caramel sauce. A little taste of heaven in every bite.

Zeppolis (Half) at Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is $6 in Fort Myers. Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria on 8841 College Pkwy is a restaurant. The menu lists 7 desserts, from $6 for the Zeppolis (Half) to $10, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, bolognese, caesar salad.

Own Citrola's on College Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Lucky Screw, Fort Myers

The Lucky Screw

1527 Hendry St · bar · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4 – 9 PM6 desserts
18
  • Ice Cream$4
  • Key Lime Pie$7
  • Peanut Butter Pie$8
  • Mud Pie$8
  • Brownie ala Mode$9
  • The Trifle$10

Ice Cream at The Lucky Screw is $4 in Fort Myers. The Lucky Screw on 1527 Hendry St is a bar. The menu lists 6 desserts, from $4 for the Ice Cream to $10, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Happy hour Daily 4 – 9 PM. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, bbq, beer.

Own The Lucky Screw? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Irie I Jamaican American cafe

3559 Fowler St · Jamaican · website

Full menu 4.2 (556)5 desserts
19
  • Spice Bun Small$3.25
  • Rum Cake$5.50
  • Rum Cake 6 Inch$30
  • Rum Cake 10 Inch$56
  • Rum Cake 12 Inch$62

Spice Bun Small at Irie I Jamaican American cafe is $3.25 in Fort Myers. Irie I Jamaican American cafe on 3559 Fowler St is a jamaican rated 4.2 (556 reviews). The menu lists 5 desserts, from $3.25 for the Spice Bun Small to $62, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Also on the menu: beer, breakfast, chicken.

Own Irie I Jamaican American cafe? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Connors Steak & Seafood, Fort Myers

Connors Steak & Seafood

10076 Gulf Coast Main St · steakhouse · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 11 AM – 4 PM; 4 – 6 PM7 desserts
20
  • Homemade Ice Cream$7

    Single large scoop

  • Crème Brûlée$10

    Fresh vanilla bean custard, caramelized top, fresh berries

  • Key Lime Cheesecake$12

    Cool & refreshing Key Lime-infused cheesecake topped with sweetened whipped topping & fresh lime

  • Carrot Cake$12

    Warm cake, cream cheese icing, caramel topping

  • Chocolate Mousse Cake$12

    White and dark chocolate mousse between rich chocolate cake topped with chocolate ganache

  • Strawberry Shortcake$13

    Warm butter cake, homemade vanilla bean ice cream, fresh strawberry topping, whipped cream

  • German Chocolate Upside Down Cake$13

    Warm chocolate cake with coconut filling served with homemade vanilla bean ice cream

Homemade Ice Cream at Connors Steak & Seafood is $7 in Fort Myers. Connors Steak & Seafood on 10076 Gulf Coast Main St is a steakhouse. The menu lists 7 desserts, from $7 for the Homemade Ice Cream to $13, below the Fort Myers median of $8.50. Happy hour Daily 11 AM – 4 PM; 4 – 6 PM lounge. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.

Own Connors Steak & Seafood? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About dessert in Fort Myers

120 of the 262 restaurants and bars we track in Fort Myers list dessert. Prices run from $2.99 at Tijuana Flats to $30 at Irie I Jamaican American cafe, with a median of $8.50. Most of them sit along S Cleveland Ave and McGregor Blvd. The highest rated is Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers (4.7), and The Firestone Skybar & Martini Bar, Lumber Axe Whiskey Bar & Grill pair it with a happy hour.

120places
$2.99–$30price range
$8.50median
Uncle Rico’s Pizzatop rated
Cheapest
$2.99 at Tijuana Flats
Most expensive
$30 at Irie I Jamaican American cafe
Most spots
S Cleveland Ave · McGregor Blvd · Cleveland Ave
Happy hour
The Firestone Skybar & Martini Bar, Lumber Axe Whiskey Bar & Grill, BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse, Connors Steak & Seafood
Menus read
September 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Fort Myers

Questions

Where is the cheapest dessert in Fort Myers?

Tijuana Flats lists 3-Piece Cookie Dough Flautas at $2.99. Median across 120 places is $8.50.

Which Fort Myers spot has the best-rated dessert?

Uncle Rico’s Pizza Fort Myers (4.7 from 1,439 reviews), The Pirate Seafood & Chicken (4.7 from 758 reviews), Ihop (4.6 from 7,393 reviews).

Any dessert places with a happy hour?

The Firestone Skybar & Martini Bar: Tue-Fri 4 PM-9 PM; Lumber Axe Whiskey Bar & Grill: Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM; BJ's Restaurant & Brewhouse: Mon-Fri 3 PM - 7 PM.

Every cuisine and category in Fort Myers

See all 43 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Fort Myers

See all 135 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho4Cheeseburger69Pepperoni pizza29Cuban sandwich12Fried rice27Cheesesteak20Italian sub10Spaghetti and meatballs18Grouper sandwich12Fish and chips40General tso3Vodka sauce11Pad thai9Smash burger22Birria tacos6Filet mignon31Ribeye31Fettuccine alfredo7Chicken parm41Lasagna14Breakfast burrito6Lo mein10Orange chicken4Brisket13Pulled pork22Baby back ribs17Cold brew13Iced latte15Margarita46Mojito14Espresso martini15Acai bowl3Pancakes33French toast28Eggs benedict11Bacon egg and cheese5Key lime pie11Ceviche11Caesar salad97Grilled salmon93Calamari71Chicken sandwich58Mac and cheese56Cheesecake52Onion rings50Dumplings38Ipa36Caprese33Teriyaki31Omelette30Crab cakes29Mozzarella sticks27Ahi tuna27NY strip26Sangria26Coconut shrimp25Burrata25Fried shrimp23Ravioli23Old fashioned22Egg roll22Eggplant parm22Guacamole21Edamame20Reuben20Espresso20Clam chowder19Shrimp scampi19Spring rolls19Fajitas19Lobster tail19Mimosa18Chocolate cake17Bloody mary17French onion soup16Milkshake16Gnocchi16Avocado toast15Fish tacos14Bolognese14Chicken noodle soup13Paloma13Cannoli12Poke bowl11Carbonara11Tiramisu11Pina colada11Patty melt11Crab rangoon10California roll10Prime rib10Chicken and waffles9Meatball sub9Enchiladas9Biscuits and gravy9Lobster roll9Carne asada9Mahi sandwich8Margherita pizza8Churros7Cortadito7Gyro7Wonton soup7Chilaquiles7Spicy tuna roll7Pastrami6Bao buns6Jerk chicken6Hummus6Nashville hot chicken5Lobster bisque5Conch fritters5Tamales5Picanha5Wagyu5Al pastor5Burnt ends4Tom yum4Thai curry4Empanadas4Croquetas4Tostones4Oxtail4Tres leches4Flan4Gelato4Moscow mule3Samosa3Churrasco3Drunken noodles3Bagel and lox3Negroni3Cacio e pepe3Matcha latte3Korean bbq3

Craving something else?