Fort Myers

Rum Bucket Fort Myers Menu & Prices

Rum Bucket Bar And Grill · 5150 Buckingham Rd · restaurant

90 items read from Rum Bucket's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: Fire Cracker Burger $15, Blackened Caesar wrap $15, Chopped Steak $17.

Rum Bucket Menu

Fort Myers · 90 items

Appetizer

  • Fried Coconut Shrimp$15

    Jumbo shrimp hand breaded in a coconut batter and deep fried to a golden perfection, served with our tropical marmalade to dip!

  • Gator Bites$16

    Gator tail breaded and fried and served with our house remoulade

  • 1lb Peel & Eat Shrimp$23

    1/2 pound of gulf shrimp boiled in Old Bay and other secret fixins, served cold with lemon and house zesty cocktail sauce

  • 1/2lb Peel & Eat Shrimp$14

    Full pound of gulf shrimp boiled in Old Bay and other secret fixins, served cold with lemon and house zesty cocktail sauce

  • Ahi Tuna App$15
  • Onion ring basket$11
  • Smoked mahi dip Appetizer$15
  • Fried Mushrooms$11
  • Pretzels$14
  • Boneless wings$12.95
  • *Conch Fritter$16
  • Mac N Cheese Bites$10
  • Potato Skins$13

Salads see more salad in Fort Myers

  • Rum Bucket Salad$10

    A bed of spring mix and romaine blend, red onion, tomatoes, cucumbers, pepperoni, topped with shredded cheese

  • Crispy Caesar$11

    Fresh romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese and cracked black pepper, with our housemade croutons. Add anchovies for $0.99.

Burgers see more burger in Fort Myers

  • Black N' Blue burger$16
  • Cowboy Burger$16

    Applewood-smoked bacon, cheddar cheese, onion rings, and a BBQ drizzle

  • Fire Cracker Burger$15

    Pepper jack cheese and our firecracker sticks

  • Rum Burger$15
  • Surf Turf BURGER$21
  • Cheeseburger$14
  • Mushroom Swiss burger$15

Sandwiches see more sandwich in Fort Myers

  • Smoked Sausage Hoagie$14

    Smoked sausage with carmelized peppers and onions on a fresh hoagie

  • Blackened Shrimp Wrap$16

    Blackened shrimp cheese lettuce tomato and rom sauce

  • Big Fish Sandwich (Basa)$17
  • Shrimp Po Boy$17
  • Mahi Sandwich$20.95
  • Grilled Chicken Sand$16
  • Low Country Crab Grilled Cheese$19

    Lump blue crab smothered inside of a buttery grilled cheese sandwich

  • Blackened Caesar wrap$15
  • Pesto mozzarella chicken sandwich$17
  • Ultimate BLT$15

Sides

  • French Fries$3
  • Side Caesar salad$5
  • Side House Salad$5
  • Mashed Potatoes$3
  • Rice Pilaf$3
  • Seasonal Veggies$3
  • Sweet potato fries$3
  • Onion Rings side$3

Add Ons

  • Lemon Beurre Blanc$1.95
  • ADD Peppercorn Demi-Glaze$1.95
  • ADD Rum Bucket Sauce$1.95
  • ADD Blue Cheese Crumbles$2
  • ADD Sauteed Mushrooms$1.95
  • ADD Carmelized Onions$1.95
  • Add Shrimp Skewer$7
  • Anchovy$2
  • Garlic toast basket (4)$5
  • Gravy$1.95
  • ADD Extra Dressing$0.50
  • ADD Mango Chille Sauce$1.95
  • Alfredo Side$2
  • Loaded$1.95
  • Burger Patty$5.95
  • Beer cheese 2oz$1.95
  • Beer Cheese - 4oz.$3.95

Desserts see more dessert in Fort Myers

  • *Brownie Sunday$8.95
  • ADD* Scoop Ice Cream$1
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie$8.95
  • HM Keylime pie$9.95
  • Kids Ice Cream$1.95
  • Bread Pudding$9.95
  • Blueberry cheesecake$9.95
  • Reese Pie$9.95

Entrees

  • Mango chili glazed shrimp$19
  • Chopped Steak$17
  • Fried shrimp Basket$17
  • Shrimp & sausage alfredo$19
  • Bone-in pork shank$21
  • Rum bucket rice bowl$17
  • Crab cakes$23
  • Full Rib Dinner$28.95
  • Lobster Ravioli$23
  • Chicken & Sausage Alfredo$19
  • Half Rack Rib dinner$16.95

Kid menu

  • Kids Cheeseburger$8.95
  • Kids Fried Shrimp$8.95
  • KIDS Grilled cheese$8.95
  • Mac and cheese$8.95
  • Kids Chicken Alfredo$8.95

Steaks see more steak in Fort Myers

  • Surf and Turf$28.95

    10oz sirloin with shrimp skewers

  • 12 oz Ribeye$33.95
  • 8oz Sirloin$24.95
  • New York$28.95

Fresh Catch

  • Triple Tail$28.95
  • Grouper$35.95
  • Mahi Mahi$26.95
  • Red Fish$28.95
  • Snapper$28.95

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Rum Bucket at other Fort Myers restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Fort Myers results, every place ranked, so you can compare Rum Bucket with the rest of the city.

What things cost at Rum Bucket

Rum Bucket's signature plates against the Fort Myers median for the same dish.

Own Rum Bucket? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Fort Myers

See all 43 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Fort Myers

See all 135 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho4Cheeseburger69Pepperoni pizza29Cuban sandwich12Fried rice27Cheesesteak20Italian sub10Spaghetti and meatballs18Grouper sandwich12Fish and chips40General tso3Vodka sauce11Pad thai9Smash burger22Birria tacos6Filet mignon31Ribeye31Fettuccine alfredo7Chicken parm41Lasagna14Breakfast burrito6Lo mein10Orange chicken4Brisket13Pulled pork22Baby back ribs17Cold brew13Iced latte15Margarita46Mojito14Espresso martini15Acai bowl3Pancakes33French toast28Eggs benedict11Bacon egg and cheese5Key lime pie11Ceviche11Caesar salad97Grilled salmon93Calamari71Chicken sandwich58Mac and cheese56Cheesecake52Onion rings50Dumplings38Ipa36Caprese33Teriyaki31Omelette30Crab cakes29Mozzarella sticks27Ahi tuna27NY strip26Sangria26Coconut shrimp25Burrata25Fried shrimp23Ravioli23Old fashioned22Egg roll22Eggplant parm22Guacamole21Edamame20Reuben20Espresso20Clam chowder19Shrimp scampi19Spring rolls19Fajitas19Lobster tail19Mimosa18Chocolate cake17Bloody mary17French onion soup16Milkshake16Gnocchi16Avocado toast15Fish tacos14Bolognese14Chicken noodle soup13Paloma13Cannoli12Poke bowl11Carbonara11Tiramisu11Pina colada11Patty melt11Crab rangoon10California roll10Prime rib10Chicken and waffles9Meatball sub9Enchiladas9Biscuits and gravy9Lobster roll9Carne asada9Mahi sandwich8Margherita pizza8Churros7Cortadito7Gyro7Wonton soup7Chilaquiles7Spicy tuna roll7Pastrami6Bao buns6Jerk chicken6Hummus6Nashville hot chicken5Lobster bisque5Conch fritters5Tamales5Picanha5Wagyu5Al pastor5Burnt ends4Tom yum4Thai curry4Empanadas4Croquetas4Tostones4Oxtail4Tres leches4Flan4Gelato4Moscow mule3Samosa3Churrasco3Drunken noodles3Bagel and lox3Negroni3Cacio e pepe3Matcha latte3Korean bbq3