- Traditional Florida Key Lime Pie
- Florida Key Lime Pie
The Veranda on 2122 Second St is a fine dining rated 4.5 (1,425 reviews). The menu lists 2 key lime pies. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, caesar salad, cheesecake.
Every key lime pie on every menu we have read in Fort Myers, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.
11 places in Fort Myers have key lime pie on the menu, from $5 at Burntwood Tavern to $24 at Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House. Highest rated: The Veranda (4.5). Blue Pointe Oyster Bar, Burntwood Tavern, Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant run a happy hour. 10 of 11 list a price.
The Veranda on 2122 Second St is a fine dining rated 4.5 (1,425 reviews). The menu lists 2 key lime pies. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, caesar salad, cheesecake.

2360 West 1St Street · restaurant · website
served slightly frozen
Absolut Vanilia, pineapple, Blue Chair Bay key lime rum
Signature Key Lime Pie at Pinchers Crab Shack - Marina At Edison Ford is $8 in Fort Myers. Pinchers Crab Shack - Marina At Edison Ford on 2360 West 1St Street is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies at $8, below the Fort Myers median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, baby back ribs, beer.
Own Pinchers Crab Shack - Marina At Edison Ford? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

14040 McGregor Blvd · restaurant · website
Our Famous Key Lime Pie (slice) at Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House is $9 in Fort Myers. Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House on 14040 McGregor Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies, from $9 for the Our Famous Key Lime Pie (slice) to $24, around the Fort Myers median of $9. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, calamari.
Own Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
4Ultimate Florida KEY Lime PIE at Bellini's Fort Myers is $12 in Fort Myers. Bellini's Fort Myers on 13451 McGregor Blvd Suites 5-9 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $12, above the Fort Myers median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.
Own Bellini's Fort Myers? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
citrus, blueberry, cinnamon, cream
Key Lime Pie* at Burntwood Tavern is $5 in Fort Myers. Burntwood Tavern on 10035 Gulf Center Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $5, below the Fort Myers median of $9. Happy hour Daily 3 – 6 PM & 9 PM – Close. Also on the menu: avocado toast, beer, bloody mary.
Own Burntwood Tavern? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

13499 S Cleveland Ave Ste 111 · restaurant · website
Homemade Key Lime Pie. Biscoff Crust.
Famous Feckin' KEY Lime PIE at McGregor's Public House is $10 in Fort Myers. McGregor's Public House on 13499 S Cleveland Ave Ste 111 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $10, above the Fort Myers median of $9. Also on the menu: burger, coffee, dessert.
Own McGregor's Public House? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
served slightly frozen
Absolut Vanilia, pineapple, Blue Chair Bay key lime rum
Signature Key Lime Pie at Pinchers Crab Shack is $8 in Fort Myers. Pinchers Crab Shack on 10029 Gulf Center Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies at $8, below the Fort Myers median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, baby back ribs, beer.
Own Pinchers Crab Shack? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
13051 Bell Tower Dr · restaurant · website
Served with whipped cream and raspberry sauce
Florida Key Lime Pie at Shoeless Joe's Sports Cafe is $9 in Fort Myers. Shoeless Joe's Sports Cafe on 13051 Bell Tower Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $9, around the Fort Myers median of $9. Happy hour Mon-Fri. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.
Own Shoeless Joe's Sports Cafe? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
13671 Olympic Ct · restaurant
(Bin 77)
Riesling Slightly sweet with aromas of key lime pi at Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant is $19.99 in Fort Myers. Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant on 13671 Olympic Ct is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $19.99, above the Fort Myers median of $9. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-5:30 PM. Also on the menu: acai bowl, ahi tuna, beer.
Own Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
KEY Lime PIE, Bread Pudding, Crème Brulee, OR Warm at Courtney's Continental Cuisine is $8.50 in Fort Myers. Courtney's Continental Cuisine on 20351 Summerlin Rd #111 is a fine dining. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $8.50, below the Fort Myers median of $9. Happy hour Tue-Sat 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, breakfast, caesar salad.
Own Courtney's Continental Cuisine? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
13499 S Cleveland Ave · seafood · website
whipped cream
Key Lime Pie at Blue Pointe Oyster Bar is $9.99 in Fort Myers. Blue Pointe Oyster Bar on 13499 S Cleveland Ave is a seafood. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $9.99, above the Fort Myers median of $9. Happy hour Daily 3 – 6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, burger, caesar salad.
Own Blue Pointe Oyster Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos
11 of the 262 restaurants and bars we track in Fort Myers list key lime pie. Prices run from $5 at Burntwood Tavern to $24 at Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House, with a median of $9. Most of them sit along Gulf Center Dr and Second St. The highest rated is The Veranda (4.5), and Blue Pointe Oyster Bar, Burntwood Tavern pair it with a happy hour.
Iced latte15 places
Ice cream31 places
Dessert120 places
Cheesecake52 places
Chocolate cake17 places
Milkshake16 placesTres leches4 places
Flan4 places
Gelato4 places
Dessert in Fort Myers
American / BBQ237 placesCoffee124 placesDietary Restrictions119 places
Beer / Wine118 placesSeafood115 placesItalian111 places
Steak101 places
Mexican100 places
Cocktails85 places
Brunch55 placesEverything in Fort Myers262 places · 172 dishes and drinksBurntwood Tavern lists Key Lime Pie* at $5. Median across 11 places is $9.
The Veranda (4.5 from 1,425 reviews).
Blue Pointe Oyster Bar: Daily 3 – 6 PM; Burntwood Tavern: Daily 3 – 6 PM & 9 PM – Close; Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant: Mon-Fri 3 PM-5:30 PM.