Tallahassee

Key lime pie in Tallahassee

Every key lime pie on every menu we have read in Tallahassee, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

5 places in Tallahassee have key lime pie on the menu, from $6 at Village Inn to $19 at Village Inn. Highest rated: Village Inn (4.2), R&R Eatery (3.9). The Brass Tap Midtown, The Monroe run a happy hour. 3 of 5 list a price.

Village Inn

1225 E Park Ave · Breakfast · website

Full menu 4.2 (1,460)2 key lime pies
1
  • Key Lime Pie Slice$6

    Cool and refreshing, this is a summer seasonal favorite. Tangy Key limes are blended with sweetened condensed milk and eggs, baked inside a graham cracker crust, then topped with real whipped cream an

  • Whole Key Lime Pie$19

    Cool and refreshing! Tangy Key limes are blended with sweetened condensed milk and eggs, baked inside a graham cracker crust, then topped with real whipped cream and a fresh slice of lime for the perf

Key Lime Pie Slice at Village Inn is $6 in Tallahassee. Village Inn on 1225 E Park Ave is a breakfast rated 4.2 (1,460 reviews). The menu lists 2 key lime pies, from $6 for the Key Lime Pie Slice to $19, below the Tallahassee median of $10. Also on the menu: biscuits and gravy, breakfast, burger.

Own Village Inn? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Monroe, Tallahassee

The Monroe

1327 S Monroe St Suite 5 · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Thu 5 PM-7 PM1 key lime pie
2
  • KEY Lime PIE

    Creamy key lime filling, buttery graham crust, fresh whipped cream, fresh blueberries

The Monroe on 1327 S Monroe St Suite 5 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Happy hour Mon-Thu 5 PM-7 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.

Own The Monroe? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

R&R Eatery

826 W Gaines St · Restaurant · website

Full menu 3.9 (53)1 key lime pie
3
  • Key Lime Pie

R&R Eatery on 826 W Gaines St is a restaurant rated 3.9 (53 reviews). The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: breakfast, brunch, burger.

Own R&R Eatery? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Brass Tap Midtown, Tallahassee

The Brass Tap Midtown

1321 Thomasville Rd · bar · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Fri (late night Thu-Sat)1 key lime pie
4
  • Coconut Key Lime Pie Shot$6

Coconut Key Lime Pie Shot at The Brass Tap Midtown is $6 in Tallahassee. The Brass Tap Midtown on 1321 Thomasville Rd is a bar. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $6, below the Tallahassee median of $10. Happy hour Mon-Fri (late night Thu-Sat) 4-7 PM (Fri 3-7 PM, late night 12-2 AM). Also on the menu: bbq, burger, caesar salad.

Own The Brass Tap Midtown? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Georgio's Fine Food And Spirits, Tallahassee

Georgio's Fine Food And Spirits

2971 Apalachee Pkwy · fine dining · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
5
  • Key Lime Pie$10

    Florida's most popular pie made from key lime juice with graham cracker pie crust and topped with fresh whipped cream

Key Lime Pie at Georgio's Fine Food And Spirits is $10 in Tallahassee. Georgio's Fine Food And Spirits on 2971 Apalachee Pkwy is a fine dining. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $10, around the Tallahassee median of $10. Also on the menu: caesar salad, calamari, cheesecake.

Own Georgio's Fine Food And Spirits? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About key lime pie in Tallahassee

5 of the 213 restaurants and bars we track in Tallahassee list key lime pie. Prices run from $6 at Village Inn to $19 at Village Inn, with a median of $10. Most of them sit along E Park Ave and W Gaines St. The highest rated is Village Inn (4.2), and The Brass Tap Midtown, The Monroe pair it with a happy hour.

5places
$6–$19price range
$10median
Village Inntop rated
Cheapest
$6 at Village Inn
Most expensive
$19 at Village Inn
Most spots
E Park Ave · W Gaines St · Apalachee Pkwy
Happy hour
The Brass Tap Midtown, The Monroe
Menus read
October 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Tallahassee

Questions

Where is the cheapest key lime pie in Tallahassee?

Village Inn lists Key Lime Pie Slice at $6. Median across 5 places is $10.

Which Tallahassee spot has the best-rated key lime pie?

Village Inn (4.2 from 1,460 reviews), R&R Eatery (3.9 from 53 reviews).

Any key lime pie places with a happy hour?

The Brass Tap Midtown: Mon-Fri (late night Thu-Sat) 4-7 PM (Fri 3-7 PM, late night 12-2 AM); The Monroe: Mon-Thu 5 PM-7 PM.

Every cuisine and category in Tallahassee

See all 42 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Tallahassee

See all 133 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho3Cheeseburger45Pepperoni pizza14Cuban sandwich10Fried rice20Cheesesteak15Spaghetti and meatballs7Grouper sandwich4Fish and chips9General tso14Vodka sauce3Tikka masala5Shawarma3Pad thai7Smash burger14Birria tacos7Filet mignon13Ribeye31Fettuccine alfredo9Chicken parm21Lasagna12Breakfast burrito7Lo mein10Orange chicken8Brisket16Pulled pork15Baby back ribs10Cold brew9Iced latte10Margarita28Mojito11Espresso martini7Pancakes16French toast22Eggs benedict6Bacon egg and cheese5Key lime pie5Ceviche11Caesar salad61Grilled salmon54Cheesecake45Chicken sandwich39Mac and cheese35Onion rings30Calamari26Egg roll23Dumplings23Old fashioned21Spring rolls20Guacamole18Mozzarella sticks18Omelette18Fajitas18Sangria18Edamame17Hummus17Ahi tuna17Crab cakes16Fried shrimp15Mimosa15Caprese15Ipa14Biscuits and gravy14Teriyaki13Espresso12Churros12Milkshake12Empanadas11Ravioli11Chicken and waffles11Wonton soup11Gyro10Enchiladas10NY strip10Eggplant parm9Paloma9Cortadito9Reuben9Chocolate cake8Avocado toast8Carne asada7Shrimp scampi7Tostones7Bloody mary7Coconut shrimp7Fish tacos7Burnt ends7Thai curry6Crab rangoon6Tiramisu6Oxtail6Croquetas6Pina colada6Falafel6Wagyu6Bolognese6Burrata6Cannoli6Lobster tail5Mahi sandwich5Biryani5Garlic naan5Samosa5Paneer5Chicken noodle soup5Al pastor5Prime rib5Gnocchi5Elote5Tom yum4Carbonara4Spicy tuna roll4Negroni4Patty melt4French onion soup4Tamales4Chilaquiles4Drunken noodles3Banh mi3Tonkotsu ramen3Poke bowl3Jerk chicken3Ropa vieja3Churrasco3Seafood boil3Bao buns3Flan3Butter chicken3Pastrami3Bagel and lox3Margherita pizza3Nashville hot chicken3Tres leches3

Craving something else?