Sarasota

Key lime pie in Sarasota

Every key lime pie on every menu we have read in Sarasota, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

22 places in Sarasota have key lime pie on the menu, from $5 at Seasons 52 to $24 at Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House. Highest rated: Shake Shack UTC Sarasota (3.9). Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village, Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle, Brick's Smoked Meats run a happy hour. 18 of 22 list a price.

Shake Shack UTC Sarasota

190 N Cattlemen Rd Unit 1 · Hamburger · website

Full menu 3.9 (1,591)1 key lime pie
1
  • Key Lime Pie Shake

    Vanilla frozen custard hand-spun with key lime pie curd and graham cracker crunch, topped with whipped cream and graham cracker crunch. PEANUT & TREE NUT ALLERGY UPDATE: Cross-contact may occur with o

Shake Shack UTC Sarasota on 190 N Cattlemen Rd Unit 1 is a hamburger rated 3.9 (1,591 reviews). The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: burger, cheeseburger, chicken sandwich.

Own Shake Shack UTC Sarasota? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Owens Fish Camp, Sarasota

Owens Fish Camp

516 Burns Ct · restaurant · website

Full menu 2 key lime pies
2
  • Key Lime Pie w/Fresh Whipped Cream$11.99
  • Key Lime Pie$11.99

    w/Whipped Cream - GF

Key Lime Pie w/Fresh Whipped Cream at Owens Fish Camp is $11.99 in Sarasota. Owens Fish Camp on 516 Burns Ct is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies at $11.99, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, bloody mary.

Own Owens Fish Camp? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House, Sarasota

Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House

1540 Lakefront Dr Unit 100 · restaurant · website

Full menu 2 key lime pies
3
  • Our Famous Key Lime Pie (slice)$9
  • Key Lime Pie (Whole)$24

Our Famous Key Lime Pie (slice) at Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House is $9 in Sarasota. Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House on 1540 Lakefront Dr Unit 100 is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies, from $9 for the Our Famous Key Lime Pie (slice) to $24, below the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, calamari.

Own Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant, Sarasota

Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant

3130 Fruitville Commons Blvd · american · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-5:30 PM1 key lime pie
4
  • Riesling Slightly sweet with aromas of key lime pie, green apple, hone$19.99

    (Bin 77)

Riesling Slightly sweet with aromas of key lime pi at Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant is $19.99 in Sarasota. Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant on 3130 Fruitville Commons Blvd is an american. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $19.99, above the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-5:30 PM. Also on the menu: acai bowl, ahi tuna, beer.

Own Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Turtles Restaurant, Sarasota

Turtles Restaurant

8875 Midnight Pass Rd · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
5
  • Key lime Pie / Turtle Pie

Turtles Restaurant on 8875 Midnight Pass Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, avocado toast, baby back ribs.

Own Turtles Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar, Sarasota

Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar

428 N Lemon Ave · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Monday-Friday 4pm-6pm1 key lime pie
6
  • Key Lime Pie$9

Key Lime Pie at Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar is $9 in Sarasota. Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar on 428 N Lemon Ave is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $9, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Monday-Friday 4pm-6pm. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, beer, burger.

Own Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Cha Cha Coconuts - Sarasota, Sarasota

Cha Cha Coconuts - Sarasota

417 St. Armands Circle · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
7
  • Key West Key Lime Pie$8

    No meal would be complete without this Florida favorite, made with Key limes and a graham cracker crust

Key West Key Lime Pie at Cha Cha Coconuts - Sarasota is $8 in Sarasota. Cha Cha Coconuts - Sarasota on 417 St. Armands Circle is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $8, below the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: beer, burger, cheesecake.

Own Cha Cha Coconuts - Sarasota? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Clayton's Siesta Grille - Sarasota, Sarasota

Clayton's Siesta Grille - Sarasota

1256 Old Stickney Point Rd · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
8
  • Clayton's Key Lime Pie$12

    Florida key lime pie with a graham cracker crust, topped with fresh berries and whipped cream

Clayton's Key Lime Pie at Clayton's Siesta Grille - Sarasota is $12 in Sarasota. Clayton's Siesta Grille - Sarasota on 1256 Old Stickney Point Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $12, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, calamari.

Own Clayton's Siesta Grille - Sarasota? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Lucky Pelican, Sarasota

Lucky Pelican

6239 Lake Osprey Dr · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
9
  • KEY Lime PIE$9.50

    Graham cracker crust, whipped cream, powdered sugar

KEY Lime PIE at Lucky Pelican is $9.50 in Sarasota. Lucky Pelican on 6239 Lake Osprey Dr is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $9.50, below the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: beer, burger, burrito.

Own Lucky Pelican? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Cafe Gabbiano, Sarasota

Cafe Gabbiano

5104 Ocean Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
10
  • KEY Lime PIE

    A Florida staple. A graham cracker crust pie made with Key West lime juice.

Cafe Gabbiano on 5104 Ocean Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: bolognese, burrata, calamari.

Own Cafe Gabbiano? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Drift Kitchen + Bar, Sarasota

Drift Kitchen + Bar

700 Benjamin Franklin Drive · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
11
  • Key Lime Pie$12

    Vanilla chantilly, red berry coulis.

Key Lime Pie at Drift Kitchen + Bar is $12 in Sarasota. Drift Kitchen + Bar on 700 Benjamin Franklin Drive is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $12, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: bolognese, breakfast, burrata.

Own Drift Kitchen + Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Marina Jack

2 Marina Plaza · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
12
  • Marina Jack Signature Key Lime Pie$10

    Graham Cracker Crust with a Tart Key Lime Filling, Topped with Whipped Cream. Garnished with Raspberry Coulis

Marina Jack Signature Key Lime Pie at Marina Jack is $10 in Sarasota. Marina Jack on 2 Marina Plaza is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $10, around the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, beer, bolognese.

Own Marina Jack? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Seasons 52

170 University Town Center Dr Ste 103 · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM1 key lime pie
13
  • Key Lime Pie (1 Mini)$5

    Tangy key lime custard layered with a graham cracker crust and topped with toasted meringue.

Key Lime Pie (1 Mini) at Seasons 52 is $5 in Sarasota. Seasons 52 on 170 University Town Center Dr Ste 103 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $5, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Mon-Fri 3 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, avocado toast, bolognese.

Own Seasons 52? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Columbia Restaurant - St. Armands Circle, Sarasota

Columbia Restaurant - St. Armands Circle

411 St. Armands Circle · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
14
  • Key Lime Pie$12

    Graham cracker crust, filling made from pasteurized egg yolks, condensed milk and Nellie & Joe's Key lime juice.

Key Lime Pie at Columbia Restaurant - St. Armands Circle is $12 in Sarasota. Columbia Restaurant - St. Armands Circle on 411 St. Armands Circle is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $12, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: chicken, chicken sandwich, churros.

Own Columbia Restaurant - St. Armands Circle? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Ophelia's on the Bay

9105 Midnight Pass Rd · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
15
  • Key Lime Pie$15

    Florida Key Lime Infused with Coconut and Rum Baked on a Graham Crust. Served over Passion Fruit-Mango Coulis with Coconut Chantilly Cream and Fresh Kiwi

Key Lime Pie at Ophelia's on the Bay is $15 in Sarasota. Ophelia's on the Bay on 9105 Midnight Pass Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $15, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: caesar salad, caprese, cheesecake.

Own Ophelia's on the Bay? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill, Sarasota

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill

7119 S Tamiami Trl · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
16
  • Key Lime Pie

    Homemade key lime pie, served with homemade whipped cream

Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill on 7119 S Tamiami Trl is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.

Own Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Brick's Smoked Meats

1528 State Street · barbecue · website

Full menu Happy Hour Mon-Fri 2 PM-6 PM1 key lime pie
17
  • KEY Lime PIE$2.95

    Graham cracker crumb crust, cinnamon, brown sugar, tart key lime filling

KEY Lime PIE at Brick's Smoked Meats is $2.95 in Sarasota. Brick's Smoked Meats on 1528 State Street is a barbecue. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $2.95, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Mon-Fri 2 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, bloody mary.

Own Brick's Smoked Meats? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle

325 John Ringling Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 3 PM-6 PM2 key lime pies
18
  • Tarta de Lima (Key Lime Pie)$9
  • KEY Lime PIE Cocktail14/12

    Florida Flavor. Featuring Siesta Key Toasted Coconut Rum, Stoli Vanilla Vodka & Hard Truth Toasted Coconut Rum Cream with lots of lime juice and a touch of coconut

Tarta de Lima (Key Lime Pie) at Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle is $9 in Sarasota. Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle on 325 John Ringling Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies at $9, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Daily 3 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: avocado toast, beer, bloody mary.

Own Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria, Sarasota

Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria

7515 S Tamiami Trl · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
19
  • Mini Key Lime Pie$12

    A graham cracker base topping with New York cheesecake with a splash of key lime, decorated with a key lime glaze

Mini Key Lime Pie at Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria is $12 in Sarasota. Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria on 7515 S Tamiami Trl is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $12, above the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: bolognese, calamari, caprese.

Own Maestrale Restaurant and Pizzeria? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village

5250 Ocean Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 3 PM-6 PM2 key lime pies
20
  • Tarta de Lima (Key Lime Pie)$9
  • KEY Lime PIE Cocktail

    Florida Flavor. Featuring Siesta Key Toasted Coconut Rum, Stoli Vanilla Vodka & Hard Truth Toasted Coconut Rum Cream with lots of lime juice and a touch of coconut

Tarta de Lima (Key Lime Pie) at Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village is $9 in Sarasota. Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village on 5250 Ocean Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 key lime pies at $9, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Daily 3 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, breakfast.

Own Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key

1250 Stickney Point Rd · seafood · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 3:00 PM - 7:00 PM1 key lime pie
21
  • Key Lime Pie$9

Key Lime Pie at Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key is $9 in Sarasota. Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key on 1250 Stickney Point Rd is a seafood. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $9, below the Sarasota median of $10. Happy hour Daily 3:00 PM - 7:00 PM. Also on the menu: avocado toast, bloody mary, breakfast.

Own Daiquiri Deck South Siesta Key? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro Pub

3550 S Osprey Ave · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
22
  • Key Lime Pie$6.75

    Topped with whipped cream or custard

Key Lime Pie at Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro Pub is $6.75 in Sarasota. Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro Pub on 3550 S Osprey Ave is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $6.75, below the Sarasota median of $10. Also on the menu: bbq, burger, caesar salad.

Own Shakespeare's Craft Beer and Gastro Pub? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About key lime pie in Sarasota

22 of the 313 restaurants and bars we track in Sarasota list key lime pie. Prices run from $5 at Seasons 52 to $24 at Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House, with a median of $10. Most of them sit along Ocean Blvd and St. Armands Circle. The highest rated is Shake Shack UTC Sarasota (3.9), and Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village, Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle pair it with a happy hour.

22places
$5–$24price range
$10median
Shake Shack UTC Satop rated
Cheapest
$5 at Seasons 52
Most expensive
$24 at Deep Lagoon Seafood & Oyster House
Most spots
Ocean Blvd · St. Armands Circle · S Tamiami Trl
Happy hour
Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village, Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle, Brick's Smoked Meats, Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant
Menus read
September 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Sarasota

Questions

Where is the cheapest key lime pie in Sarasota?

Seasons 52 lists Key Lime Pie (1 Mini) at $5. Median across 22 places is $10.

Which Sarasota spot has the best-rated key lime pie?

Shake Shack UTC Sarasota (3.9 from 1,591 reviews).

Any key lime pie places with a happy hour?

Daiquiri Deck Siesta Key Village: Daily 3 PM-6 PM; Daiquiri Deck St. Armands Circle: Daily 3 PM-6 PM; Brick's Smoked Meats: Mon-Fri 2 PM-6 PM.

Every cuisine and category in Sarasota

See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Sarasota

CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonCalamariChicken sandwichMac and cheeseCapreseOmeletteCheesecakeCrab cakesIpaEspressoOnion ringsSangriaAhi tunaOld fashionedHummusPoke bowlMimosaBurrataBologneseAvocado toastDumplingsRavioliGuacamoleReubenBloody maryGnocchiTeriyakiCoconut shrimpMozzarella sticksFried shrimpClam chowderLobster tailNY stripEgg rollSpring rollsChocolate cakeLobster rollWagyuEggplant parmGyroCarbonaraPalomaTiramisuEdamameFish tacosBiscuits and gravyLobster bisqueMahi sandwichGelatoFalafelEmpanadasFajitasShrimp scampiPina coladaMeatball subEnchiladasFrench onion soupMilkshakeMargherita pizzaChurrosThai curryCortaditoAperol spritzNegroniChicken and wafflesMoscow muleCroquetasFlanPrime ribBagel and loxEloteCacio e pepeCrab rangoonTamalesCannoliChilaquilesCarne asadaSpicy tuna rollNashville hot chickenKorean bbqMatcha lattePatty meltPicanhaBurnt endsTom yumBao bunsCalifornia rollWonton soupButter chickenPaneerBiryaniBaked zitiChicken noodle soupJerk chickenAl pastorConch frittersSeafood boilSurf and turfPastramiGarlic naanChurrascoTres lechesRopa viejaTostonesStone crabSamosa
See all 146 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger66Pepperoni pizza30Cuban sandwich23Fried rice19Cheesesteak18Italian sub5Spaghetti and meatballs10Grouper sandwich17Fish and chips46General tso5Vodka sauce11Tikka masala6Shawarma3Pad thai6Smash burger21Birria tacos11Filet mignon40Ribeye38Fettuccine alfredo5Chicken parm35Lasagna26Breakfast burrito12Lo mein8Orange chicken7Brisket19Pulled pork15Baby back ribs16Cold brew15Iced latte37Margarita70Mojito31Espresso martini28Acai bowl8Pancakes48French toast39Eggs benedict15Bacon egg and cheese6Key lime pie22Ceviche24Caesar salad133Grilled salmon122Calamari81Chicken sandwich73Mac and cheese56Caprese52Omelette49Cheesecake49Crab cakes48Ipa45Espresso45Onion rings45Sangria44Ahi tuna44Old fashioned43Hummus39Poke bowl37Mimosa35Burrata35Bolognese32Avocado toast32Dumplings29Ravioli29Guacamole28Reuben27Bloody mary26Gnocchi26Teriyaki25Coconut shrimp25Mozzarella sticks24Fried shrimp24Clam chowder23Lobster tail22NY strip22Egg roll21Spring rolls21Chocolate cake20Lobster roll19Wagyu19Eggplant parm19Gyro18Carbonara18Paloma18Tiramisu17Edamame16Fish tacos16Biscuits and gravy14Lobster bisque14Mahi sandwich14Gelato14Falafel14Empanadas14Fajitas14Shrimp scampi13Pina colada13Meatball sub13Enchiladas12French onion soup12Milkshake11Margherita pizza11Churros10Thai curry10Cortadito10Aperol spritz9Negroni9Chicken and waffles9Moscow mule8Croquetas8Flan8Prime rib8Bagel and lox8Elote8Cacio e pepe7Crab rangoon7Tamales7Cannoli7Chilaquiles7Carne asada6Spicy tuna roll6Nashville hot chicken6Korean bbq6Matcha latte6Patty melt6Picanha5Burnt ends5Tom yum5Bao buns5California roll5Wonton soup5Butter chicken5Paneer5Biryani5Baked ziti4Chicken noodle soup4Jerk chicken4Al pastor4Conch fritters4Seafood boil4Surf and turf4Pastrami4Garlic naan4Churrasco3Tres leches3Ropa vieja3Tostones3Stone crab3Samosa3

Craving something else?