Lefty's Oyster & Seafood Bar Sarasota Menu & Prices

Ginger Rosemary Demerara, fresh squeezed lime juice & Ginger Beer

Once Upon A Coconut, fresh pressed lime juice, pineapple juice, housemade simple syrup & topped with whipped cream

Chilled Espresso, housemade vanilla simple syrup & whipped cream

Coconut Berry Red Bull, fresh squeezed lime juice, mint & Club soda

Absolut Tabasco, Bloody Mary Mix & Tajin Rim

Tito's Vodka Shot & Oyster

Baked with Parmesan Breadcrumbs, Garlic Butter, Bacon & Cayenne

Steamed in white wine garlic broth with celery & onion. Served with crostinis

½ lb. served with drawn butter

White wine garlic broth with celery & onion. Served with Fries

Coconut, curry & spices. Served with Fries

Served with housemade remoulade

Voted "Best Local Ceviche"! Our freshest catch marinated in citrus juice & cilantro, with diced peppers & jalapeño

Lightly dusted & tossed with banana peppers, garlic butter & spicy marinara

Served with Lefty’s sauce & grilled lemon

A classic Southern dish of thick-cut green tomatoes coated in cornmeal & fried until golden. Served with Lefty's housemade Cajun remoulade

Lightly fried & served with Lefty's housemade tartar sauce

Marinated Gator tail bites, fried crispy & served with housemade remoulade

Butterflied & panko-breaded, served with housemade cocktail sauce

Served with saltine crackers

Served with Lefty's housemade hot honey butter

Stacked Ahi Tuna with fresh avocado, tropical salsa & a kick of wasabi & sriracha. Served with tortilla chips

Lightly fried with bacon, lettuce, tomato & Lefty’s sauce

Prepared grilled, blackened or fried with lettuce, tomato, onion & our housemade tartar sauce

Served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle & Lefty’s sauce. ADD: Bacon +2

Premium Maine lobster meat, lightly tossed with celery, onion & mayo then piled into two toasted, buttered split rolls

Served on a crispy & soft roll with lettuce, tomato, dill pickle chips & our housemade remoulade sauce

This Lefty’s favorite was added to our menu after its popular debut at The Bay park. Every time you enjoy this dish, Watershed Hospitality Concepts makes a donation to The Bay Large Snow crab, peel &

Ahi tuna topped with ponzu sauce and served with Soba noodles

A full pound with corn and red potatoes Add extra cluster +21

10 oz. Skirt Steak with Chimichurri sauce. Served with Fries

Pan seared with white wine, lemon & shallots

Prepared grilled, blackened or fried

Prepared grilled or blackened & served with our housemade Dill crema

Our take on the classic Greek. Romaine, red onion, cucumber, Kalamata olives, tomatoes, pepperoncini & feta cheese

Romaine, croutons, parmesan & our housemade Caesar dressing

Romaine, onions, cucumbers, tomatoes, mixed cheese, housemade croutons

Crisp Iceberg lettuce with bleu cheese crumbles, tomatoes, red onion, bacon, bleu cheese dressing & drizzled with a balsamic glaze

Cream base chock full of Gulf Grouper & clams

Dirty rice with red beans, andouille sausage, bell peppers & onions

Alligator & pork sausage, chicken, dirty rice & okra

Shrimp, Bay scallops & North Atlantic white fish served with our housemade tartar sauce

Shrimp, Gator bites & Gulf Grouper bites served with our housemade tartar sauce

Beer Battered North Atlantic white fish served with our housemade tartar sauce

Cajun cornmeal dusted and served with a coupla hush puppies

Panko breaded and fried. Served with housemade cocktail sauce

Lobster, scallops, shrimp served over linguine with a shallot garlic butter sauce

Jumbo Gulf shrimp grilled and paired with creamy Southern grits, peppers & andouille. Make it Sea Scallops & Grits — MKT

With garlic, shallots & a white wine butter sauce

Cavatappi pasta, bell peppers, onions & parmesan

Hibiscus-infused Tito's Vodka with fresh lemonade. Lefty's is honored to partner with RUCK9, a non-profit that provides animals the chance to experience the happiest life they were intended to live. T

Empress Indigo Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, fresh lime juice, cucumber, mint & Prosecco

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon, Rosemary Ginger Demerara Syrup, Orange Bitters & torched Rosemary

Nolet's Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, Ginger Liqueur, housemade vanilla simple syrup & lime juice

Deep Eddy Peach Vodka, Riesling, ginger beer & a lime wedge

Siesta Key Coconut Rum, banana liqueur & tropical juices. Topped with an orange and a cherry

Ketel Cucumber Vodka, white cranberry juice, cucumber & lime. Topped with fresh basil

Don Julio Blanco, Cointreau, lime and lemon juice's, agave simple syrup & a Grand Marnier floater

Exotico Blanco, Grapefruit liqueur, lime juice, Grapefruit Soda with a candied grapefruit wheel

Casamigos Reposado, mango puree, Mike's Hot Honey, lemon & lime juices, orange bitters & Tajin half rim

Tito's Vodka, Liquid Alchemist Prickly Pear, Cointreau Liqueur & lime juice

Borghetti Liqueur, vodka & espresso

Absolut Vanilla Vodka, Bailey's Irish Cream, housemade vanilla simple syrup, caramel & a caramelized brown sugar top

Explore our extensive collection of wines, featuring a curated variety of reds, whites, rosés, and sparkling wines. Whether you’re in the mood for a bold cabernet, a crisp chardonnay, a refreshing ros

The Watershed Hospitality Concepts family of restaurants is proud to partner with our local craft breweries and we always offer a diverse selection of classic domestic & imported beers

Ask your friendly bartender or server about our extensive list of rotating taps & seasonal craft beer offerings