Ophelia's on the Bay Sarasota Menu & Prices
· 9105 Midnight Pass Rd · restaurant
Dinner, Dessert, Wine. 126 items read from Ophelia's on the Bay's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: Frenched Rack of Grassfed New Zeal $58, Classic Caprese of Imported Buffal $17, Colossal Lump Blue Crab Cake $22.
Search popular dishes & drinks found at Ophelia's on the Bay at other Sarasota restaurants
Each card opens that dish's Sarasota results, every place ranked, so you can compare Ophelia's on the Bay with the rest of the city.
Salad3 on the menuOphelia's House Salad$17$3 over city medianGluten free10 on the menuFrenched Rack of Grassfed New Zealand Lamb$58$41.01 over city medianCaesar salad1 on the menuBaby Romaine Caesar Salad$16$3.50 over city medianCaprese1 on the menuClassic Caprese of Imported Buffalo Mozzarella$17$2 over city medianCheesecake1 on the menuTropical Cheesecake$16$6 over city medianCrab cakes1 on the menuColossal Lump Blue Crab Cake$22$2 over city medianFilet mignon1 on the menu8oz Center Cut Filet Mignon of BMS 5 Australian $75$24 over city medianGelato1 on the menuImported Italian Gelato or Sorbet$11about the city median
Key lime pie1 on the menuKey Lime Pie$15$5 over city medianLobster bisque1 on the menuButter Poached Maine Lobster Bisque$19$9.01 over city medianNachos1 on the menuYellowfin Tuna Tartare Nachos$22$7.01 over city medianSteak1 on the menuSteak Tartare of Darling Downs Australian Wagyu $20$6.79 under city medianSurf and turf1 on the menuSurf and Turf$60$12 over city medianWagyu1 on the menu8oz Center Cut Filet Mignon of BMS 5 Australian $75$33 over city medianWine39 on the menu606 TOR Wines, Oakville 2022$150$108 over city median
What things cost at Ophelia's on the Bay
Ophelia's on the Bay's signature plates against the Sarasota median for the same dish.
- Frenched Rack of Grassfed New Zealand Lamb $58 over the Sarasota gluten free median of $16.99
- Classic Caprese of Imported Buffalo Mozzarella $17 over the Sarasota caprese median of $15
- Colossal Lump Blue Crab Cake $22 over the Sarasota crab cakes median of $20
- 8oz Center Cut Filet Mignon of BMS 5 Australian Wa $75 over the Sarasota filet mignon median of $51
- Butter Poached Maine Lobster Bisque $19 over the Sarasota lobster bisque median of $9.99
- Yellowfin Tuna Tartare Nachos $22 over the Sarasota nachos median of $14.99
Own Ophelia's on the Bay? Claim it free, add photos & videos
Every cuisine and category in Sarasota
American / BBQDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianDessertCoffeeBeer / WineSeafoodItalianMexicanCocktailsSteakBrunchJapaneseChineseLatin / CaribbeanMediterraneanIndianPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamSandwichPastaSmoothiesSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersChicken
See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ280Dietary Restrictions166Gluten free92Vegan42Vegetarian119Dessert150Coffee144Beer / Wine143Seafood138Italian134Mexican127Cocktails127Steak113Brunch86Japanese31Chinese24Latin / Caribbean20Mediterranean17Indian6Pizza65Burger131Sushi22Tacos94Wings87Burrito44Ice cream38Sandwich130Pasta82Smoothies20Soup131Breakfast77Salad225Fries149Chicken tenders71Tea117Fried chicken22Hot dog32Nachos47Quesadilla65Oysters35Chicken221
Every dish and drink in Sarasota
CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonCalamariChicken sandwichMac and cheeseCapreseOmeletteCheesecakeCrab cakesIpaEspressoOnion ringsSangriaAhi tunaOld fashionedHummusPoke bowlMimosaBurrataBologneseAvocado toastDumplingsRavioliGuacamoleReubenBloody maryGnocchiTeriyakiCoconut shrimpMozzarella sticksFried shrimpClam chowderLobster tailNY stripEgg rollSpring rollsChocolate cakeLobster rollWagyuEggplant parmGyroCarbonaraPalomaTiramisuEdamameFish tacosBiscuits and gravyLobster bisqueMahi sandwichGelatoFalafelEmpanadasFajitasShrimp scampiPina coladaMeatball subEnchiladasFrench onion soupMilkshakeMargherita pizzaChurrosThai curryCortaditoAperol spritzNegroniChicken and wafflesMoscow muleCroquetasFlanPrime ribBagel and loxEloteCacio e pepeCrab rangoonTamalesCannoliChilaquilesCarne asadaSpicy tuna rollNashville hot chickenKorean bbqMatcha lattePatty meltPicanhaBurnt endsTom yumBao bunsCalifornia rollWonton soupButter chickenPaneerBiryaniBaked zitiChicken noodle soupJerk chickenAl pastorConch frittersSeafood boilSurf and turfPastramiGarlic naanChurrascoTres lechesRopa viejaTostonesStone crabSamosa
See all 146 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger66Pepperoni pizza30Cuban sandwich23Fried rice19Cheesesteak18Italian sub5Spaghetti and meatballs10Grouper sandwich17Fish and chips46General tso5Vodka sauce11Tikka masala6Shawarma3Pad thai6Smash burger21Birria tacos11Filet mignon40Ribeye38Fettuccine alfredo5Chicken parm35Lasagna26Breakfast burrito12Lo mein8Orange chicken7Brisket19Pulled pork15Baby back ribs16Cold brew15Iced latte37Margarita70Mojito31Espresso martini28Acai bowl8Pancakes48French toast39Eggs benedict15Bacon egg and cheese6Key lime pie22Ceviche24Caesar salad133Grilled salmon122Calamari81Chicken sandwich73Mac and cheese56Caprese52Omelette49Cheesecake49Crab cakes48Ipa45Espresso45Onion rings45Sangria44Ahi tuna44Old fashioned43Hummus39Poke bowl37Mimosa35Burrata35Bolognese32Avocado toast32Dumplings29Ravioli29Guacamole28Reuben27Bloody mary26Gnocchi26Teriyaki25Coconut shrimp25Mozzarella sticks24Fried shrimp24Clam chowder23Lobster tail22NY strip22Egg roll21Spring rolls21Chocolate cake20Lobster roll19Wagyu19Eggplant parm19Gyro18Carbonara18Paloma18Tiramisu17Edamame16Fish tacos16Biscuits and gravy14Lobster bisque14Mahi sandwich14Gelato14Falafel14Empanadas14Fajitas14Shrimp scampi13Pina colada13Meatball sub13Enchiladas12French onion soup12Milkshake11Margherita pizza11Churros10Thai curry10Cortadito10Aperol spritz9Negroni9Chicken and waffles9Moscow mule8Croquetas8Flan8Prime rib8Bagel and lox8Elote8Cacio e pepe7Crab rangoon7Tamales7Cannoli7Chilaquiles7Carne asada6Spicy tuna roll6Nashville hot chicken6Korean bbq6Matcha latte6Patty melt6Picanha5Burnt ends5Tom yum5Bao buns5California roll5Wonton soup5Butter chicken5Paneer5Biryani5Baked ziti4Chicken noodle soup4Jerk chicken4Al pastor4Conch fritters4Seafood boil4Surf and turf4Pastrami4Garlic naan4Churrasco3Tres leches3Ropa vieja3Tostones3Stone crab3Samosa3