Tallahassee
Gaines Street Pies, Tallahassee

Gaines Street Pies Tallahassee Menu

· 603-4 Gaines Street · pizza

48 items read from Gaines Street Pies' own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026.

Full 48

Gaines Street Pies Menu

Tallahassee · 48 items

Appetizers

  • Garlic Knots

    6 stone-baked, puffy wonders of garlicky, buttery goodness topped with Romano cheese, served with a side of marinara

  • Cheesy Breads

    10" garlic-buttered hand-tossed dough loaded with mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, and Romano cheeses, served with homemade ranch

  • Spinach and Artichoke Dip

    Fresh, hot and delicious, made in house and served with our freshly baked pita bread

  • Caprese Salad

    Layers of tomato and fresh mozzarella, topped with basil and balsamic reduction

  • Bacon Wrapped Jalapeno Poppers

    Fresh jalapeño poppers stuffed with cream cheese and cheddar, wrapped with bacon and baked, served with homemade ranch

  • Hummus Plate

    A generous portion of hummus served with baked fresh pita bread, roasted red peppers, cucumber slices, kalamata olives, and feta cheese

Salads see more salad in Tallahassee

  • Side Salad

    House or Caesar

  • GSP House Salad

    Romaine w/ mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomato and mozzarella cheese. Add chicken +$2

  • Spinach Salad

    Spinach, tomatoes, bacon, egg, onions and feta, served with house vinaigrette dressing

  • Stay Classy Caesar Salad

    Romaine in homemade caesar dressing tossed in pecorino Romano, onion, tomato and baked croutons. Add chicken +$2

  • Southern Style Greek Salad

    Crisp romaine lettuce, fresh tomatoes, feta cheese, onions, kalamata olives, and a scoop of homemade potato salad, sun dried tomato dressing

  • Cobb Salad

    Romaine topped with grilled chicken, tomato, bacon, cucumber, egg, gorgonzola and homemade ranch

  • Arugula Apple Salad

    Arugula, thinly sliced green apples, roasted fig, goat cheese crumbles and candied walnuts, house vinaigrette

Calzones

  • 10" Calzone

    One topping

  • 14" Calzone

    One topping

  • Chicken Florentine Calzone

    Tender sliced chicken breast, ricotta, mozzarella and house made spinach and artichoke dip

Heroes and Villains Specialty Pies

  • Pesto Chicken Pizza

    Basil pesto topped with fresh tomato, onions and baked chicken breast

  • Derek Sanders is a Vegetarian

    Green peppers, black olives, onions, spinach, mushrooms, fresh tomato and garlic

  • Smitty Pizza

    Double pepperoni, mushrooms, sriracha infused pizza sauce and garlic

  • Metal Mike Pizza

    Chicken, bacon, ranch, garlic, sriracha and green onions

  • Margherita Mayhem Pizza

    Fresh cut basil, tomato and extra virgin olive oil with a smoked mozzarella twist, cracked black pepper

  • The One With Everything On It Pizza

    Pepperoni, italian sausage, ham, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms and black olives

  • Guy on a Buffalo...Pizza

    Ranch dressing base, buffalo sauce, chicken, gorgonzola, green onion, and candied jalapeños

  • Figure 4 Pizza

    Hot capicola, roasted figs, fresh garlic and goat cheese with an olive oil base

  • The White Sword Pizza

    Oil and garlic base with chicken, fresh pineapple, feta and arugula, balsamic reduction and fresh basil

  • This Is Animal Pizza

    Pepperoni, meatball, ham, bacon, and romano

  • Saucy Minx Pizza

    Marinara sauce base topped with homemade meatballs, ricotta cheese dollops, bell peppers and fresh basil

  • Honey I Shrunk The Pigs Pizza

    Smoked andouille sausage, cream cheese, orange blossom honey and candied jalapeños

  • White Album Pizza

    Ricotta base with arugula, tomato, onion, garlic, basil and truffle oil

  • The Temptation Pizza (Vegan)

    "Cheese", garlic and olive oil base, portabello mushroom, arugula, pineapple, basil and balsamic glaze

  • Freaks & Greeks Pizza

    Olive oil sun-dried tomato base with artichoke, roasted red peppers, pepperoncinis, feta and kalamata olives

  • Bruno Sammartino Pizza

    Pepperoni pizza with ham, capicola, pepperoncinis, and garlic

  • The Mitchka Pizza

    Savory blend of sausage, baked eggplant, fresh garlic, romano and mozzarella

  • Bacon Bleus Pizza

    Bacon, gorgonzola and house roasted red peppers

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Light tomato sauce, smothered with house BBQ sauce, chicken and yellow onions

  • Mo Rockin'

    Basil pesto base, eggplant, onions, feta, fresh garlic, basil, and cracked black pepper

  • The Harty Party

    Vodka cream sauce base with fresh mozzarella and a pesto swirl

Sandwiches see more sandwich in Tallahassee

  • Newsom's Italian Sub

    Pepperoni, capicola, ham, arugula, onion and tomato with cheese and balsamic vinaigrette

  • Chicken Parmesan Sub

    Fresh grilled chicken breast, house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll, served w/side

  • Meatball Parmesan Sub

    Family recipe homemade meatballs with house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll

  • Chicken Caesar Sub by Mark Forbes

    Tender chicken breast, mozzarella, crisp romaine and onion tossed in romano and house caesar dressing, served w/side

  • Eggplant Parmesan Sub

    Eggplant with house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll, served w/side

Wraps

  • BBQ Chicken Wrap

    Grilled chicken, onion, mozzarella and cheddar tossed in bbq sauce and baked until crispy

  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Grilled chicken, sliced onion, mozzarella and gorgonzola, tossed in buffalo sauce and homemade ranch

  • Bowsers Bluff

    Grilled chicken, bacon, homemade spinach/artichoke dip, mozzarella, goat cheese and sriracha infused ranch

  • The Hero Wrap

    Chicken breast, fresh spinach, kalamata olives, onion, mozzarella and feta with homemade sun-dried tomato dressing

Desserts see more dessert in Tallahassee

  • The Cheesecake Calzone

    New York cheesecake filling and milk chocolate baked into a 10" calzone and topped with cinnamon

  • Cookies and Cream Pie

    Hand-tossed dough topped with a delicious blend of rich butter, cream cheese, white chocolate and Oreos

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Gaines Street Pies at other Tallahassee restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Tallahassee results, every place ranked, so you can compare Gaines Street Pies with the rest of the city.

Salad6 on the menuCaprese SaladSandwich5 on the menuNewsom's Italian SubDessert2 on the menuThe Cheesecake CalzoneCaesar salad2 on the menuStay Classy Caesar SaladBBQ1 on the menuBBQ Chicken WrapCaprese1 on the menuCaprese SaladCheesecake1 on the menuThe Cheesecake CalzoneChicken1 on the menuChicken Florentine Calzone

Own Gaines Street Pies? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Tallahassee

American / BBQDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianCoffeeDessertSeafoodMexicanItalianSteakCocktailsBeer / WineBrunchJapaneseChineseLatin / CaribbeanMediterraneanThaiIndianPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamRamenSandwichPastaSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersChicken
See all 42 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ187Dietary Restrictions110Gluten free33Vegan29Vegetarian81Coffee103Dessert96Seafood87Mexican77Italian68Steak67Cocktails67Beer / Wine66Brunch43Japanese22Chinese20Latin / Caribbean14Mediterranean7Thai6Indian5Pizza35Burger83Sushi13Tacos50Wings84Burrito25Ice cream30Ramen12Sandwich69Pasta42Soup64Breakfast34Salad130Fries107Chicken tenders51Tea92Fried chicken17Hot dog15Nachos36Quesadilla39Oysters30Chicken143

Every dish and drink in Tallahassee

PhoCheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonCheesecakeChicken sandwichMac and cheeseOnion ringsCalamariEgg rollDumplingsOld fashionedSpring rollsGuacamoleMozzarella sticksOmeletteFajitasSangriaEdamameHummusAhi tunaCrab cakesFried shrimpMimosaCapreseIpaBiscuits and gravyTeriyakiEspressoChurrosMilkshakeEmpanadasRavioliChicken and wafflesWonton soupGyroEnchiladasNY stripEggplant parmPalomaCortaditoReubenChocolate cakeAvocado toastCarne asadaShrimp scampiTostonesBloody maryCoconut shrimpFish tacosBurnt endsThai curryCrab rangoonTiramisuOxtailCroquetasPina coladaFalafelWagyuBologneseBurrataCannoliLobster tailMahi sandwichBiryaniGarlic naanSamosaPaneerChicken noodle soupAl pastorPrime ribGnocchiEloteTom yumCarbonaraSpicy tuna rollNegroniPatty meltFrench onion soupTamalesChilaquilesDrunken noodlesBanh miTonkotsu ramenPoke bowlJerk chickenRopa viejaChurrascoSeafood boilBao bunsFlanButter chickenPastramiBagel and loxMargherita pizzaNashville hot chickenTres leches
See all 133 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho3Cheeseburger45Pepperoni pizza14Cuban sandwich10Fried rice20Cheesesteak15Spaghetti and meatballs7Grouper sandwich4Fish and chips9General tso14Vodka sauce3Tikka masala5Shawarma3Pad thai7Smash burger14Birria tacos7Filet mignon13Ribeye31Fettuccine alfredo9Chicken parm21Lasagna12Breakfast burrito7Lo mein10Orange chicken8Brisket16Pulled pork15Baby back ribs10Cold brew9Iced latte10Margarita28Mojito11Espresso martini7Pancakes16French toast22Eggs benedict6Bacon egg and cheese5Key lime pie5Ceviche11Caesar salad61Grilled salmon54Cheesecake45Chicken sandwich39Mac and cheese35Onion rings30Calamari26Egg roll23Dumplings23Old fashioned21Spring rolls20Guacamole18Mozzarella sticks18Omelette18Fajitas18Sangria18Edamame17Hummus17Ahi tuna17Crab cakes16Fried shrimp15Mimosa15Caprese15Ipa14Biscuits and gravy14Teriyaki13Espresso12Churros12Milkshake12Empanadas11Ravioli11Chicken and waffles11Wonton soup11Gyro10Enchiladas10NY strip10Eggplant parm9Paloma9Cortadito9Reuben9Chocolate cake8Avocado toast8Carne asada7Shrimp scampi7Tostones7Bloody mary7Coconut shrimp7Fish tacos7Burnt ends7Thai curry6Crab rangoon6Tiramisu6Oxtail6Croquetas6Pina colada6Falafel6Wagyu6Bolognese6Burrata6Cannoli6Lobster tail5Mahi sandwich5Biryani5Garlic naan5Samosa5Paneer5Chicken noodle soup5Al pastor5Prime rib5Gnocchi5Elote5Tom yum4Carbonara4Spicy tuna roll4Negroni4Patty melt4French onion soup4Tamales4Chilaquiles4Drunken noodles3Banh mi3Tonkotsu ramen3Poke bowl3Jerk chicken3Ropa vieja3Churrasco3Seafood boil3Bao buns3Flan3Butter chicken3Pastrami3Bagel and lox3Margherita pizza3Nashville hot chicken3Tres leches3