Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza St. Petersburg Menu & Prices

· 3523 49th Street N · restaurant

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza, Drinks. 57 items read from Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: White Plain $18.99, 15. Steak all the Way, Onion, Mush $10.79, 16. Lasagna w/Bread $11.99.

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza 42 Drinks 15

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza Menu

St. Petersburg · 42 items

Pizza see more pizza in St. Petersburg

Small, Plain$17.99
16 Inch - Thin NY Style
Large, Plain$19.49
18 Inch Thin NY Style
Sicilian Plain$20.49
16 x 16 Square Thick Crust
White Plain$18.99
Ricotta, Mozzarella, Provolone and Parmesan
By the Slice Plain$3.15

Specialty Pizzas see more pizza in St. Petersburg

Little Italy Special$22.99
Pepperoni, Sausage, Onions, Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Extra Cheese
Meat
Pepperoni, Bacon, Meatball, Sausage, Ham, Extra Cheese
Veggie
Onion, Gr. Pepper, 81. Olive, Mushroom, Extra Cheese
White
Ricotta, Fresh Mushroom, Tomato, Spinach
Garlic Mozzarella. Provolone

Toppings

Whole 1.60 | Half .80 | Slice .40
Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushroom, Extra O,eese, Garlic, Onion, Green Pepper, Anchovies, Pineapple, Banana Peppers. Boiled Ham, Bacon, Black Olive, Ricotta, Spinach. Tomato, Meatball, Jal.apenos

Cold Subs

On toasted Italian roll with lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian dress
1. Provolone, Boiled Ham, Salami, and Capicola$10.49
2. Provolone, Proscuittini, Salami, and Capicola$10.49
3. Provolone, Capicola, and Proscuitiini$10.19
4. Italian, Provolone, Proscuittini, Salami, Capicola, and Ham$10.69
5. Provolone, Salami, and Boiled Ham$10.19
6. Provolone, Bolonga & Salami$10.19
7. Provolone, Boiled Ham & Bolonga$10.19
8. Provolone$9.99
9. Roast Beef$10.69
10. Tuna$10.39
Ham & Cheese or Turkey & Cheese$10.19

Hot Classics

11. Calzone$10.99
Ricotta, mozzarella and choice of ingredients
Extra Ingredients$75
12. Stromboli$10.99
Sausage, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Green Pepper, Onion & Mozzarella
Pepperoni & Cheese Roll$7.99
Sausage, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Green Pepper, Onion & Mozzarella

Philly Steaks see more steak in St. Petersburg

13. Steak & Cheese$10.49
14. Steak, Onion & Cheese$10.69
15. Steak all the Way, Onion, Mushroom$10.79
Green Pepper & Cheese

Other Classics

16. Lasagna w/Bread$11.99
17. Meatball Sub$9.49
18. Meatball Mozz$10.49
19. Sausage Onion & Pepper Sub$10.69
Garlic Knots$6.39
(6) w/Marinara Sauce

Salads see more salad in St. Petersburg

Tossed$6.69
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pepperoncini & Olives
Chef$10.29
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Provolone, Ham & Turkey
Antipasto$10.49
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pepperoncini, Olive, Provolone, Ham, and Salami
Tuna$10.39
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pepperoncini & Olives

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza Drinks Menu

St. Petersburg · 15 items

Beverages

Coca Cola Products (one size)$2.49
Coke, Diet Coke, Cherry Coke, Sprite, Mr. Phibb, Root Beer, Fruit Punch, Lemonade
Brewed Iced Tea (one size)$2.49
Sweet or Unsweetened
Coffee$1.99
Bottled Water$1.89
Bottled Gourmet Soda$2.69

Beer & Wine see more beer in St. Petersburg

Beer on Tap
Domestic 12 oz$3.09
Domestic 20 oz$4.29
Domestic Pitcher$9.99
Bottled Beer
Domestic$3.59
Import$4.09
Wine
Chablis, Chianti, White Zinfandel, Rose
Small$4.99
Large$6.59

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza at other St. Petersburg restaurants

Each card opens that dish's St. Petersburg results, every place ranked, so you can compare Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza with the rest of the city.

Pizza7 on the menuWhite Plain$18.99$2.99 over city median Steak2 on the menu15. Steak all the Way, Onion, Mushroom$10.79$6.16 under city median Salad3 on the menuChef$10.29$2.36 under city median Lasagna1 on the menu16. Lasagna w/Bread$11.99$6 under city median Meatball sub1 on the menu17. Meatball Sub$9.49about the city median Beer2 on the menuBeer on Tap Wine1 on the menuWine Coffee1 on the menuCoffee$1.99$2.01 under city median

What things cost at Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza

Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza's signature plates against the St. Petersburg median for the same dish.

White Plain $18.99 over the St. Petersburg pizza median of $16
15. Steak all the Way, Onion, Mushroom $10.79 under the St. Petersburg steak median of $16.95
16. Lasagna w/Bread $11.99 under the St. Petersburg lasagna median of $17.99
17. Meatball Sub $9.49 under the St. Petersburg meatball sub median of $9.99

Own Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in St. Petersburg

See all 43 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in St. Petersburg

Pho Cheeseburger Pepperoni pizza Cuban sandwich Fried rice Cheesesteak Italian sub Spaghetti and meatballs Grouper sandwich Fish and chips General tso Vodka sauce Pad thai Smash burger Birria tacos Filet mignon Ribeye Fettuccine alfredo Chicken parm Lasagna Breakfast burrito Lo mein Brisket Pulled pork Baby back ribs Cold brew Iced latte Margarita Mojito Espresso martini Acai bowl Pancakes French toast Eggs benedict Bacon egg and cheese Key lime pie Ceviche Grilled salmon Caesar salad Chicken sandwich Calamari Cheesecake Ipa Old fashioned Caprese Mac and cheese Espresso Onion rings Sangria Mimosa Hummus Omelette Ahi tuna Dumplings Burrata Crab cakes Fried shrimp Bloody mary Edamame Ravioli Guacamole Egg roll Mozzarella sticks Reuben Spring rolls Cortadito Paloma Empanadas Avocado toast Fish tacos Gyro Pina colada Mahi sandwich Eggplant parm Teriyaki Clam chowder Fajitas Chicken and waffles Bolognese Lobster roll NY strip Chocolate cake Shrimp scampi Lobster tail Coconut shrimp Cannoli Poke bowl Croquetas Margherita pizza Patty melt Bagel and lox Biscuits and gravy Milkshake Baked ziti Falafel Thai curry Tom yum Chicken noodle soup Gelato Churros Al pastor Flan Tiramisu Wagyu Crab rangoon Negroni Bao buns Enchiladas Meatball sub Pastrami Gnocchi Spicy tuna roll California roll Wonton soup French onion soup Prime rib Aperol spritz Matcha latte Carbonara Tostones Carne asada Korean fried chicken Conch fritters Moscow mule Drunken noodles Samosa Jerk chicken Elote Nashville hot chicken Lobster bisque Garlic naan Cacio e pepe Tres leches Tamales Oxtail

See all 135 dishes and drinks as a list

Pho6 Cheeseburger52 Pepperoni pizza26 Cuban sandwich17 Fried rice20 Cheesesteak17 Italian sub9 Spaghetti and meatballs14 Grouper sandwich15 Fish and chips23 General tso3 Vodka sauce8 Pad thai8 Smash burger17 Birria tacos8 Filet mignon27 Ribeye37 Fettuccine alfredo4 Chicken parm30 Lasagna16 Breakfast burrito5 Lo mein7 Brisket7 Pulled pork27 Baby back ribs7 Cold brew23 Iced latte26 Margarita60 Mojito26 Espresso martini18 Acai bowl4 Pancakes35 French toast34 Eggs benedict10 Bacon egg and cheese8 Key lime pie15 Ceviche21 Grilled salmon98 Caesar salad87 Chicken sandwich64 Calamari46 Cheesecake45 Ipa44 Old fashioned44 Caprese37 Mac and cheese37 Espresso36 Onion rings35 Sangria33 Mimosa32 Hummus31 Omelette31 Ahi tuna29 Dumplings28 Burrata26 Crab cakes26 Fried shrimp25 Bloody mary23 Edamame22 Ravioli20 Guacamole20 Egg roll19 Mozzarella sticks18 Reuben17 Spring rolls17 Cortadito17 Paloma17 Empanadas16 Avocado toast16 Fish tacos16 Gyro14 Pina colada14 Mahi sandwich14 Eggplant parm13 Teriyaki13 Clam chowder13 Fajitas13 Chicken and waffles13 Bolognese12 Lobster roll12 NY strip12 Chocolate cake12 Shrimp scampi11 Lobster tail11 Coconut shrimp11 Cannoli10 Poke bowl10 Croquetas10 Margherita pizza9 Patty melt9 Bagel and lox9 Biscuits and gravy9 Milkshake9 Baked ziti8 Falafel8 Thai curry8 Tom yum8 Chicken noodle soup8 Gelato8 Churros8 Al pastor8 Flan8 Tiramisu7 Wagyu7 Crab rangoon7 Negroni7 Bao buns7 Enchiladas7 Meatball sub6 Pastrami6 Gnocchi6 Spicy tuna roll6 California roll6 Wonton soup6 French onion soup6 Prime rib6 Aperol spritz6 Matcha latte6 Carbonara6 Tostones6 Carne asada6 Korean fried chicken5 Conch fritters5 Moscow mule5 Drunken noodles5 Samosa4 Jerk chicken4 Elote4 Nashville hot chicken4 Lobster bisque4 Garlic naan3 Cacio e pepe3 Tres leches3 Tamales3 Oxtail3