St. Petersburg

Jay Luigi St. Petersburg Menu

· 3201 4th St N · Italian

Dinner, Lunch, Brunch, Happy Hour, Drinks. 200 items read from Jay Luigi's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: Margie $18, Half Sandwich & Daily Soup $11, Carbonara** $18.

Jay Luigi Dinner Menu

St. Petersburg · 49 items

Fancy Plates

  • Jay’s Caesar**$13

    romaine, radicchio, dried black cherry, Marcona almonds, house-made croutons, crumbled egg yolk, grana padano

  • Jimmy’s Meatballs$11

    Jimmy’s famous balls made with beef, pork, grana padano, tomato add house-made ricotta +3

  • Luigi’s Impossible Meatballs

    Luigi’s plant-based impossible meatballs

  • Charred Shrimp Scampi$15

    tiger shrimp, garlic herb butter, grilled sourdough

  • Roasted Shishito

    roasted garlic aioli, charred lemon, smoked paprika panko

  • Daily Bread

    naturally fermented sourdough, served with herbs and extra virgin olive oil pomodoro fondue + 3 house-made ricotta with honey + 3 butter with olive oil + 3 all three spreads + 7

  • Sliced Steak

    steak, Italian verde sauce, chili flakes, crispy capers

  • Crispy Chicken Parmesan Tenders$11

    pomodoro fondue dip

  • Rustic Sourdough

    naturally fermented sourdough, campari tomatoes, mozzarella, smoked provolone

  • Charred Broccolini

    cashew-balsamic, garlic, lemon, chopped cashews

Salads see more salad in St. Petersburg

  • Jay’s Caesar**$13

    romaine, radicchio, dried black cherry, Marcona almonds, house-made croutons, crumbled egg yolk, grana padano

  • Luca

    kale, romaine, radicchio, Marcona almonds, dried black cherry, cashew-balsamic

  • The 516

    romaine, marinated olives, blistered tomatoes, pickled red onion, smoked provolone, grana padano, prosciutto, soppressata, balsamic red wine vinaigrette

Salad Adds see more salad in St. Petersburg

  • Burrata
  • Italian Sausage
  • Traditional Meatball
  • Impossible Meatball
  • Grilled Chicken Breast
  • Shrimp
  • Crispy Milanese Chicken
  • Basil Salmon**

Fresh Pasta see more pasta in St. Petersburg

  • NYC Plain Jane

    tomato, mozzarella

  • Queen Stella Margherita

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, grana padano, basil

  • Sweet Jamie Kay$17

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, sopressata, calabrian honey

  • Nevaeh$19

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, Ezzo all natural pepperoni, parsley

  • Jess Knows Best

    truffle honey, goat cheese, mushroom, caramelized onion, thyme

  • Margie$18

    tomato, ricotta, Italian sausage, roasted red pepper, caramelized onions, ricotta salata

  • Tomato Confit

    spaghetti alla chitarra, tomato conserva, olive oil, garlic, basil add house-made ricotta +3

  • Creamy Tomato Vodka

    rigatoni, olive oil, garlic, chili flakes, grana padano

  • Cacio E Pepe

    spaghetti alla chitarra, cracked black pepper, panko breadcrumbs, grana padano

  • Baked Lasagna Rotolo

    serves 2 pomodoro, bechamel, ricotta, mozzarella, grana padano

  • Brunetti’s Traditional Alfredo

    fettuccine, garlic, grana padano, cream

  • Carbonara**$18

    spaghetti alla chitarra, grana padano, bacon, egg, cracked black pepper

  • Drunken Mushroom

    treccione, tomato, white wine, cremini mushrooms, garlic, chili flakes, mushroom stock, grana padano

  • Bolognese$19

    fettuccine, beef, red wine, tomato, grana padano

  • House-made Rigatoni, Treccione, Spaghetti Alla Chittara, Fettuccine
  • Gluten Free Fettuccine (contains dairy & egg)

Protein Plates

  • Chicken Plate

    choice of grilled chicken breast or crispy milanese chicken, arugula, pickled red onion, shaved grana padano, lemon, extra virgin olive oil

  • Steak Plate**

    Italian verde marinated steak, arugula, burrata, blistered tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction

  • Salmon Plate**

    basil salmon, charred broccolini, cashew balsamic, garlic, lemon

Pasta Adds see more pasta in St. Petersburg

  • Burrata
  • Italian Sausage
  • Traditional Meatball
  • Impossible Meatball
  • Grilled Chicken Breast
  • Shrimp
  • Crispy Milanese Chicken
  • Basil Salmon**

Naturally Fermented Sourdough Crust Options

  • Gluten Free Crust (contains dairy & egg)

Jay Luigi Lunch Menu

St. Petersburg · 39 items

Sandwiches see more sandwich in St. Petersburg

  • Fancy Plates
  • Charred Broccolini

    cashew-balsamic, garlic, lemon, chopped cashews

  • Jimmy’s Meatballs$11

    Jimmy’s famous balls made with beef, pork, grana padano, tomato add house-made ricotta +3

  • Luigi’s Impossible Meatballs

    Luigi’s plant-based impossible meatballs

  • Daily Soup$7
  • Crispy Chicken Caesar$15

    folded Neapolitan pizza dough, breaded chicken breast, romaine, grana padano, caesar dressing

  • Prosciutto Caprese$15

    prosciutto, burrata, tomato conserva, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction

  • Milanese$15

    breaded chicken breast, grana padano, tomato conserva, arugula, lemon, extra virgin olive oil

  • Meatball$15

    your choice of Jimmy’s Traditional or Luigi’s Impossible, pomodoro, grana padano, mozzarella

  • Big Petey’s Chicken Parmigiano$15

    breaded chicken breast, tomato vodka sauce, smoked provolone, grana padano, chili flakes

  • Italiano$15

    prosciutto, soppressata, mortadella, mozzarella, romaine, campari tomatoes, red pepper pesto

Lunch Combos

  • Pizza & Side Salad$11

    your choice of two slices of stella or nevaeh pizza with any side salad

  • Half Sandwich & Daily Soup$11

    your choice of any half sandwich with a soup

  • Half Sandwich & Side Salad$11

    your choice of any half sandwich with any side salad

  • Side Salad & Daily Soup$11

    your choice of any side salad with a soup

Daily Bread

  • Daily Bread

    naturally fermented sourdough, served with herbs and extra virgin olive oil pomodoro fondue + 3 house-made ricotta with honey + 3 butter with olive oil + 3 all three spreads + 7

Crispy Chicken Parmesan Tenders see more chicken in St. Petersburg

  • Crispy Chicken Parmesan Tenders$11

    pomodoro fondue dip

Fancy Plates

  • NYC Plain Jane

    tomato, mozzarella

  • Queen Stella Margherita

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, grana padano, basil

  • Margie$18

    tomato, ricotta, Italian sausage, roasted red pepper, caramelized onions, ricotta salata

  • Sweet Jamie Kay$17

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, sopressata, calabrian honey

  • Nevaeh$19

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, Ezzo all natural pepperoni, parsley

  • Jess Knows Best

    truffle honey, goat cheese, mushroom, caramelized onion, thyme

  • Jay’s Caesar**$13

    romaine, radicchio, dried black cherry, Marcona almond, house-made croutons, crumbled egg yolk, grana padano

  • The 516

    romaine, marinated olives, blistered tomatoes, pickled red onion, smoked provolone, grana padano, prosciutto, soppressata, balsamic red wine vinaigrette

  • Luca

    kale, romaine, Marcona almonds, dried black cherry, cashew-balsamic

Pizza see more pizza in St. Petersburg

  • Cacio E Pepe

    spaghetti alla chitarra, cracked black pepper, panko breadcrumbs, grana padano

  • Carbonara**$18

    spaghetti alla chitarra, grana padano, bacon, egg, cracked black pepper

Fresh Pasta see more pasta in St. Petersburg

  • Tomato Confit

    spaghetti alla chitarra, tomato conserva, olive oil, garlic, basil add house-made ricotta +3

  • Creamy Tomato Vodka

    rigatoni, olive oil, garlic, chili flakes, grana padano

Salad & Pasta Adds see more salad in St. Petersburg

  • Burrata
  • Italian Sausage
  • Traditional Meatball
  • Impossible Meatball
  • Grilled Chicken Breast
  • Shrimp
  • Crispy Milanese Chicken
  • Basil Salmon**

Jay Luigi Brunch Menu

St. Petersburg · 32 items

Goat Cheese Hash **

  • Goat Cheese Hash **

    over easy eggs, crispy potatoes, mozzarella, grana padano, spicy pomodoro, basil pesto, goat cheese

Breakfast Egg Sandwich ** see more breakfast in St. Petersburg

  • Breakfast Egg Sandwich **$15

    eggs, bacon, mozzarella, tomato conserva, calabrian aioli with crispy potatoes or fresh fruit

Cacio E Pepe Benedict ** see more cacio e pepe in St. Petersburg

  • Cacio E Pepe Benedict **$14

    naturally fermented sourdough, prosciutto, arugula, poached egg, black pepper hollandaise, grana padano

Tiramisu French Toast see more french toast in St. Petersburg

  • Tiramisu French Toast

    sweet mascarpone, berries, cocoa powder, powdered sugar

Hell ’s Chicken ** see more chicken in St. Petersburg

  • Hell ’s Chicken **$15

    fried chicken, over easy eggs, calabrian aioli, crispy potatoes, calabrian honey

Cured Salmon & Whipped Ricotta Toast **

  • Cured Salmon & Whipped Ricotta Toast **$15

    beet cured salmon, house-made whipped ricotta, naturally fermented sourdough, pickled mustard seeds, red onion, basil oil

Cinnamon Sticks

  • Cinnamon Sticks

    naturally fermented sourdough, cinnamon butter, lemon ricotta glaze

Mix Your Mimosa see more mimosa in St. Petersburg

  • Mix Your Mimosa$8

    prosecco & choice of juice: orange, cranberry, pineapple, peach

Pour Decision: get the bottle

  • Pour Decision: get the bottle$30

Tira-Me-Booze

  • Tira-Me-Booze$15

    rum, coffee liqueur, chocolate hazelnut liqueur, cream, vanilla, chocolate bitters, egg white, lady finger

Wake & Bake

  • Wake & Bake

Fancy Plates

  • Steak Plate**

    Italian verde marinated steak, arugula, burrata, blistered tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, balsamic reduction

  • Jimmy’s Meatballs$11

    Jimmy’s famous balls made with beef, pork, grana padano, tomato add house-made ricotta +3

  • Luigi’s Impossible Meatballs

    Luigi’s plant-based impossible meatballs

  • House Sangria$7

    rich, fruity, and refreshingly smooth—just like an Italian summer

  • Orange Creamsicle$14

    vanilla vodka, orange curacao, orange cold foam

  • Daily Bread

    naturally fermented sourdough, served with herbs and extra virgin olive oil pomodoro fondue + 3 house-made ricotta with honey + 3 butter with olive oil + 3 all three spreads + 7

  • Crispy Chicken Parmesan Tenders$11

    pomodoro fondue dip

  • NYC Plain Jane

    tomato, mozzarella

  • Queen Stella Margherita

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, grana padano, basil

  • Nevaeh$19

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, Ezzo all natural pepperoni, parsley

  • Jess Knows Best

    truffle honey, goat cheese, mushroom, caramelized onion, thyme

  • Sweet Jamie Kay$17

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, sopressata, calabrian honey

  • Margie$18

    tomato, ricotta, Italian sausage, roasted red pepper, caramelized onions, ricotta salata

  • Jay’s Caesar**$13

    romaine, radicchio, dried black cherry, Marcona almond, house-made croutons, crumbled egg yolk, grana padano

  • Luca

    kale, romaine, Marcona almonds, dried black cherry, cashew-balsamic

  • The 516

    romaine, marinated olives, blistered tomatoes, pickled red onion, smoked provolone, grana padano, prosciutto, soppressata, balsamic red wine vinaigrette

Pizza see more pizza in St. Petersburg

  • Creamy Tomato Vodka

    rigatoni, olive oil, garlic, chili flakes, grana padano

  • Tomato Confit

    spaghetti alla chitarra, tomato conserva, olive oil, garlic, basil add house-made ricotta +3

  • Carbonara**$18

    spaghetti alla chitarra, grana padano, bacon, egg, cracked black pepper

  • Cacio E Pepe

    spaghetti alla chitarra, cracked black pepper, panko breadcrumbs, grana padano

Jay Luigi Happy Hour Menu

St. Petersburg · 27 items

Drinks

  • $12 Martinis$12
  • Pistachio Espresso Martini
  • Espresso Martini
  • Corpse Reviver #2

Aperitivo Hour

  • Brunetti Polpette

    zucchini, egg, bread crumbs, grana padano, calabrian aioli

  • Meatball Sliders

    meatball, sourdough bread, goat cheese, calabrian pepper sauce, basil

  • Chicken Parm Sliders

    crispy chicken, sourdough bread, pomodoro, fondue, mozzarella

  • Crispy Truffle Potatoes

    crispy potatoes, truffle oil, grana padano, roasted garlic aioli

$88 Fancy Plates $$88 Salads Salads see more salad in St. Petersburg

  • Jay’s Caesar

    romaine, radicchio, dried black cherry, Marcona almonds, house-made croutons, crumbled egg yolk, grana padano

  • The 516

    romaine, marinated olives, blistered tomatoes, pickled red onion, smoked provolone, grana padano, prosciutto, soppressata, balsamic red wine vinaigrette

  • Luca

    kale, romaine, radicchio, Marcona almonds, dried black cherry, cashew-balsamic

$12 Pizzas$12 Pastas see more pizza in St. Petersburg

  • NYC Plain Jane

    tomato, mozzarella

  • Queen Stella Margherita

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, grana padano, basil

  • Sweet Jamie Kay

    tomato, house-made mozzarella, soppressata, calabrian honey

  • Luigi’s Pomodoro

    spaghetti alla chitarra, tomato, olive oil, basil

  • Creamy Tomato Vodka

    rigatoni, olive oil, chili flakes, grana padano

  • Cacio E Pepe

    spaghetti alla chitarra, cracked black pepper, panko bread crumbs, grana padano

$8 Spritz

  • Sarti Spritz
  • Limoncello Spritz

$6 House Wine see more wine in St. Petersburg

  • Pinot Noir
  • Cabernet Sauvignon
  • Super Tuscan
  • Chardonnay
  • Pinot Grigio

After Dinner

  • CoffeeCoffee
  • SweetsSweets
  • CocktailsCocktails

Jay Luigi Drinks Menu

St. Petersburg · 53 items

Sarti Spritz

  • Sarti Spritz$13

    sarti rosa, prosecco, soda

Limoncello Spritz

  • Limoncello Spritz$12

    limoncello, prosecco, soda

The Bormio Slopes

  • The Bormio Slopes$15

    vodka, alpe genepy, vermouth rosso, sparkling rosé, strawberry, lemon

Ava Gardner

  • Ava Gardner$15

    gin, orange curacao, raspberry, lemon, club soda

Seasonal Spritz

  • Seasonal Spritz

    inquire with our team for our seasonal offering!

The Berg

  • The Berg$18

    bourbon, sweet vermouth, orange curacao, filthy cherry

Italian Holiday

  • Italian Holiday$16

    gin, aperol, basil, lemon, fee foam

Corpse Reviver #2

  • Corpse Reviver #2$14

    gin, orange curacao, lillet blanc, lemon, absinthe rinse

Spicy Limoncello Margarita see more margarita in St. Petersburg

  • Spicy Limoncello Margarita$15

    blanco tequila, limoncello, calabrian pepper, agave, lemon

Orange You Glad To See Me

  • Orange You Glad To See Me$16

    mezcal, aperol, cardamaro, blood orange

Olive Oil Sour

  • Olive Oil Sour$16

    vodka, olive oil, olive brine, lemon, fee foam

Mango #5

  • Mango #5$12

    ritual “gin”, lemon, mango, orgeat, club soda

Mockingbird Mule

  • Mockingbird Mule$12

    ritual “tequila”, lime, strawberry, agave, ginger beer

VAZ THC Lim ón

  • VAZ THC Lim ón$9

VAZ THC Pink Lim ón

  • VAZ THC Pink Lim ón$9

A’ Siciliana - Sicily Blood Orange Soda

  • A’ Siciliana - Sicily Blood Orange Soda$5

A’ Siciliana - Sicily Lemon Soda

  • A’ Siciliana - Sicily Lemon Soda$5

Spritz

  • Peroni$7
  • N/A Peroni$7
  • Michelob Ultra$6
  • Miller Lite$6
  • Yuengling$6
  • Juice Lord IPA (16oz)$10
  • Escape Other West Coast IPA (16oz)$9
  • Keel Farms Elderberry Cider$9

Espresso Martini see more espresso martini in St. Petersburg

  • Pistachio Espresso Martini$17

    vanilla vodka, kahwa espresso, pistachio cream

  • JL Espresso Martini$15

    vodka, kahwa espresso, cinnamon, vanilla, mr. black

ZZero Proofero Proof Cocktails

  • ZZero Proofero Proof Cocktails

Seasonal Espresso Martini see more espresso martini in St. Petersburg

  • Seasonal Espresso Martini

    inquire with our team for our seasonal offering!

Speedy Gonzalez

  • Speedy Gonzalez$18

    reposado tequila, kahwa espresso, mr. black, salted caramel

Tini Tree

  • Tini Tree$38

    one tree. four flavors. who said you have to pick just one?

Wine List see more wine in St. Petersburg

  • JayLuigi, Veneto Pinot Noir9/44
  • JayLuigi, Veneto Cabernet Sauvignon9/44
  • JayLuigi, Veneto Super Tuscan12/44
  • Threadcount by Quilt, North Coast, CA Red Blend15/50
  • Langhe Nebbiolo Prunotto “Occhetti”, Piedmont Chianti15/56
  • Castello di Bossi, Tuscany Cabernet Sauvignon12/45
  • Bonanza, North Coast, CA Ken Wright, Williamette Valley, OR Pinot Noir$66
  • Crossbarn by Paul Hobbs, Sonoma, CA Pinot Noir$66

White

  • JayLuigi, Veneto Chardonnay$9
  • JayLuigi, Veneto Pinot Grigio$9
  • Whispering Angel, Provence, France Rosé
  • Alan Scott, Marlborough, NZ Sauvignon Blanc14/50
  • Marchesi di Barolo, Piedmont Gavi12/44
  • Bravium, Russian River Valley, CA Chardonnay12/44
  • Argiolas, Sardinia Vermentino14/52
  • Alois Lageder Terra Alpina, Dolomites Pinot Grigio11/40
  • Crossbarn by Paul Hobbs, Sonoma, CA Chardonnay48/68

Bubbly

  • Prosecco Zardetto Private Cuvee, Veneto$10
  • Brut Rosé Villa Sandi Fresco, Trevisan Land8/28
  • Brut Franciacorta Monogram Brut Saten, Lomardy10/36
  • Brut Champagne Vueve Clicquot, France68/165

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Jay Luigi at other St. Petersburg restaurants

Each card opens that dish's St. Petersburg results, every place ranked, so you can compare Jay Luigi with the rest of the city.

Salad8 on the menuThe 516Pasta24 on the menuMargie$18$5 under city medianPizza5 on the menuCarbonara**$18$2 over city medianSandwich14 on the menuHalf Sandwich & Daily Soup$11$2.50 under city medianChicken parm3 on the menuBig Petey’s Chicken Parmigiano$15about the city medianGluten free2 on the menuGluten Free Fettuccine (contains dairy & egg)Breakfast1 on the menuBreakfast Egg Sandwich **$15$2.51 over city medianCacio e pepe1 on the menuCacio E Pepe Benedict **$14$19 under city median

What things cost at Jay Luigi

Jay Luigi's signature plates against the St. Petersburg median for the same dish.

Own Jay Luigi? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in St. Petersburg

See all 43 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in St. Petersburg

See all 135 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho6Cheeseburger52Pepperoni pizza26Cuban sandwich17Fried rice20Cheesesteak17Italian sub9Spaghetti and meatballs14Grouper sandwich15Fish and chips23General tso3Vodka sauce8Pad thai8Smash burger17Birria tacos8Filet mignon27Ribeye37Fettuccine alfredo4Chicken parm30Lasagna16Breakfast burrito5Lo mein7Brisket7Pulled pork27Baby back ribs7Cold brew23Iced latte26Margarita60Mojito26Espresso martini18Acai bowl4Pancakes35French toast34Eggs benedict10Bacon egg and cheese8Key lime pie15Ceviche21Grilled salmon98Caesar salad87Chicken sandwich64Calamari46Cheesecake45Ipa44Old fashioned44Caprese37Mac and cheese37Espresso36Onion rings35Sangria33Mimosa32Hummus31Omelette31Ahi tuna29Dumplings28Burrata26Crab cakes26Fried shrimp25Bloody mary23Edamame22Ravioli20Guacamole20Egg roll19Mozzarella sticks18Reuben17Spring rolls17Cortadito17Paloma17Empanadas16Avocado toast16Fish tacos16Gyro14Pina colada14Mahi sandwich14Eggplant parm13Teriyaki13Clam chowder13Fajitas13Chicken and waffles13Bolognese12Lobster roll12NY strip12Chocolate cake12Shrimp scampi11Lobster tail11Coconut shrimp11Cannoli10Poke bowl10Croquetas10Margherita pizza9Patty melt9Bagel and lox9Biscuits and gravy9Milkshake9Baked ziti8Falafel8Thai curry8Tom yum8Chicken noodle soup8Gelato8Churros8Al pastor8Flan8Tiramisu7Wagyu7Crab rangoon7Negroni7Bao buns7Enchiladas7Meatball sub6Pastrami6Gnocchi6Spicy tuna roll6California roll6Wonton soup6French onion soup6Prime rib6Aperol spritz6Matcha latte6Carbonara6Tostones6Carne asada6Korean fried chicken5Conch fritters5Moscow mule5Drunken noodles5Samosa4Jerk chicken4Elote4Nashville hot chicken4Lobster bisque4Garlic naan3Cacio e pepe3Tres leches3Tamales3Oxtail3