Schmagel's Bagels St. Augustine Menu

69 Hypolita St #3656 · Bagel shop

41 items read from Schmagel's Bagels' own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026.

Full 41

Schmagel's Bagels Menu

St. Augustine · 41 items

Choose a Bagel

Garlic Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Minced Garlic. No Additives or Preservatives
Poppy Seed
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Imported Turkish Poppy Seeds No Additives or Preservatives
Onion Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Onion. No Additives or Preservatives
Salt Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Large Grain Sea Salt. No Additives or Preservatives
Cheddar Jalapeno Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Jalapeño Peppers and a mound of Cheddar and Monterrey-Jack Cheeses, No Additives or Preservatives
Tuscan Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with Tuscan Seasonings - Garlic, Rosemary, Basil, Dried Peppers. No Additives or Preservatives
Whole Wheat Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. All Whole Wheat with no Additives or Preservatives
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Fresh California Raisins. No Additives or Preservatives
Everything Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Generously Topped with, well, Everything. No Additives or Preservatives
Seseame Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with White, Unbleached Sesame Seeds. No Additives or Preservatives
Plain Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. No Additives or Preservatives
Everything Wheat Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. A Whole Wheat Bagel Generously Topped with, well, Everything. No Additives or Preservatives
French Toast
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Cinnamon, Vanilla and Fresh Eggs create a fusion of two breakfast favorites. No Additives or Preservatives
Cheddar-Jack Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. Topped with a mound of Cheddar and Monterrey-Jack Cheeses, No Additives or Preservatives
Blueberry Bagel
Brooklyn Style, Boiled and Baked Fresh Daily. No Additives or Preservatives

House Made Cream Cheeses

Scallion CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with fresh Scallions
Jalapeno CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with Jalapeños
Vegetable CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with fresh local vegetables
Green Olive CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with green olives
Honey Almond CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with local honey and sliced almonds
Herb CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with fresh herbs and spices
Cheddar-Garlic CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with garlic and cheddar cheeses
Strawberry CC
Homemade Cream Cheese blended with Strawberries
Plain CC
Daily Fresh Homemade Cream Cheese
Flavor of Month CC
Experimental Homemade Cream Cheese changed monthly

Bagel w/Topping

Bagel w/Topping
Freshly made, fermented, boiled and baked Brooklyn style bagels. No additives, GMOs, preservatives or ingredients we can't pronouce

Schmagel's Bagels Breakfast Sandwiches Menu see more breakfast in St. Augustine

Grilled Egg & Cheese
Farm Fresh XL Egg Grilled with Premium White American Cheese and includes any of our Home-Made Cream Cheeses. Add-ons include Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Pork Roll, or any Veggie Combination
Lox & Cream Cheese
Wild Caught Nova Salmon Served with Scallion Cream Cheese, Capers, Red Onion, Tomato on Choice of Bagel
Jammin Salmon
Wild Caught Nova Salmon, Herb Cream Cheese, Red Onion, Capers, Tomato, Cucumber & Lettuce on Choice of Bagel
The Angry Cornelius
Grilled Egg, Thinly Sliced Boars Head Ham, Applewood Bacon, Pepperoni, Jalapeno Cream Cheese, Melted Swiss Cheese, Chipotle Aioli, Drizzle of Hot Honey, Hot Cherry Peppers
The Dirty Duval
Grilled Egg, Applewood Bacon, White American Cheese, Sriracha Infused Pimento Cheese Spread, Dirty South Sauce, Jalapeno Peppers, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion
Avo-Bac-Ado
Grilled Egg, Applewood Bacon, White American Cheese, Smashed Avocado, Herb Cream Cheese, Truffle Aioli, Tomato, Romaine, and a shake of Everything Seasoning

Specialty Sandwiches see more sandwich in St. Augustine

The Scam
Boar’s Head Ham, Scallion Cream Cheese, Swiss, Lettuce, Banana Peppers, Cucumbers & Tomato
Shakin Bacon
Applewood Bacon, Lettuce & Tomato, Green Olive Cream Cheese
The Mediterranean
Choice of Hummus or Green Olive Cream Cheese, with Red Onion, Roasted Red Peppers, Tomatoes & Cucumbers. Option to Add Balsamic & Goat Cheese

Beverages

Hot Coffee
Cold Brew, Kyoto Style
Slowly melting ice drips through fresh ground coffee for 12 to 18 hours to produce a brew that has exceptionally low acidity with a high level of caffeine
Iced Coffee
Espresso Double Shot
Double Shot of Espresso
Specialty Iced Coffees of the Day
Toffee Nut Mudslide, Iced Matcha Latte, Iced Dirty Chai Latte

Snacks

Muffins
Weekends Only - Limited Quantity

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Schmagel's Bagels at other St. Augustine restaurants

Each card opens that dish's St. Augustine results, every place ranked, so you can compare Schmagel's Bagels with the rest of the city.

Bagel and lox1 on the menuLox & Cream Cheese French toast1 on the menuFrench Toast Grilled salmon1 on the menuJammin Salmon Vegetarian1 on the menuGrilled Egg & Cheese Coffee3 on the menuHot Coffee Cold brew1 on the menuCold Brew, Kyoto Style Espresso1 on the menuEspresso Double Shot

Own Schmagel's Bagels? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in St. Augustine

See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in St. Augustine

Cheeseburger Pepperoni pizza Cuban sandwich Fried rice Cheesesteak Italian sub Spaghetti and meatballs Grouper sandwich Fish and chips Vodka sauce Pad thai Smash burger Filet mignon Ribeye Fettuccine alfredo Chicken parm Lasagna Breakfast burrito Brisket Pulled pork Baby back ribs Cold brew Iced latte Margarita Mojito Espresso martini Pancakes French toast Eggs benedict Bacon egg and cheese Key lime pie Ceviche Caesar salad Grilled salmon Chicken sandwich Calamari Ipa Onion rings Mac and cheese Hummus Cheesecake Sangria Crab cakes Fried shrimp Espresso Omelette Caprese Reuben Guacamole Ahi tuna Mimosa Empanadas Biscuits and gravy Old fashioned NY strip Dumplings Eggplant parm Avocado toast Ravioli Milkshake Edamame Fajitas Fish tacos Conch fritters Poke bowl Mozzarella sticks Egg roll Cortadito Bagel and lox Spring rolls Bloody mary Clam chowder Burrata Coconut shrimp Gnocchi Thai curry Shrimp scampi Chicken and waffles Teriyaki Lobster tail Lobster roll Patty melt Crab rangoon Tom yum Carne asada Tiramisu Prime rib Baked ziti Enchiladas Gyro Drunken noodles Tamales Cannoli Chocolate cake Pina colada Margherita pizza French onion soup Churros Jerk chicken Bolognese Croquetas Carbonara Wagyu Arepas Surf and turf Matcha latte Churrasco Tostones Spicy tuna roll Mahi sandwich Paloma Pastrami Banh mi Burnt ends Lobster bisque Negroni

See all 116 dishes and drinks as a list

Cheeseburger33 Pepperoni pizza13 Cuban sandwich11 Fried rice15 Cheesesteak10 Italian sub6 Spaghetti and meatballs9 Grouper sandwich3 Fish and chips23 Vodka sauce5 Pad thai7 Smash burger6 Filet mignon14 Ribeye18 Fettuccine alfredo3 Chicken parm21 Lasagna11 Breakfast burrito6 Brisket9 Pulled pork12 Baby back ribs6 Cold brew12 Iced latte19 Margarita27 Mojito12 Espresso martini8 Pancakes20 French toast27 Eggs benedict7 Bacon egg and cheese10 Key lime pie15 Ceviche16 Caesar salad60 Grilled salmon58 Chicken sandwich45 Calamari43 Ipa32 Onion rings28 Mac and cheese27 Hummus26 Cheesecake26 Sangria26 Crab cakes24 Fried shrimp24 Espresso23 Omelette23 Caprese19 Reuben18 Guacamole17 Ahi tuna17 Mimosa17 Empanadas15 Biscuits and gravy15 Old fashioned15 NY strip14 Dumplings13 Eggplant parm13 Avocado toast13 Ravioli13 Milkshake13 Edamame12 Fajitas12 Fish tacos12 Conch fritters12 Poke bowl11 Mozzarella sticks11 Egg roll10 Cortadito10 Bagel and lox10 Spring rolls10 Bloody mary10 Clam chowder10 Burrata9 Coconut shrimp9 Gnocchi8 Thai curry8 Shrimp scampi8 Chicken and waffles7 Teriyaki7 Lobster tail7 Lobster roll7 Patty melt7 Crab rangoon6 Tom yum6 Carne asada6 Tiramisu6 Prime rib6 Baked ziti6 Enchiladas6 Gyro6 Drunken noodles5 Tamales5 Cannoli5 Chocolate cake5 Pina colada5 Margherita pizza5 French onion soup5 Churros5 Jerk chicken4 Bolognese4 Croquetas4 Carbonara4 Wagyu4 Arepas4 Surf and turf4 Matcha latte3 Churrasco3 Tostones3 Spicy tuna roll3 Mahi sandwich3 Paloma3 Pastrami3 Banh mi3 Burnt ends3 Lobster bisque3 Negroni3