Taste of New York Pizzeria Tampa Menu & Prices
· 17503-C Preserve Walk Ln · restaurant
Taste of New York Pizzeria's. 84 items read from Taste of New York Pizzeria's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta $18.99, Chicken Roll with Ricotta $9.99, Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $19.99.
Search popular dishes & drinks found at Taste of New York Pizzeria at other Tampa restaurants
Each card opens that dish's Tampa results, every place ranked, so you can compare Taste of New York Pizzeria with the rest of the city.
NY style pizza1 on the menuMargherita Pizza$18.99$6 over city medianPizza18 on the menuWhite Spinach Pizza with Ricotta$18.99$1.99 over city medianSalad6 on the menuGarden Salad Catering$31.20$18.20 over city medianDessert4 on the menuCheesecake$4.15$4.35 under city medianChicken4 on the menuChicken Roll with Ricotta$9.99$5 under city medianChicken parm4 on the menuChicken Parmigiana Pizza$19.99about the city medianPasta4 on the menuPasta with Beef Sausage$11.99$8.96 under city medianEggplant parm3 on the menuEggplant Parmigiana$12.99$5 under city median
Baked ziti2 on the menuBaked Ziti Catering$48.90$31.40 over city medianFries2 on the menuSide Fries$2$6 under city medianRavioli2 on the menuBaked Cheese Ravioli$13.99$3.85 under city medianChicken tenders1 on the menuChicken Tenders$7.99$3.51 under city medianItalian sub1 on the menuItalian Sub$10.99$1 under city medianMozzarella sticks1 on the menuMozzarella Sticks$7.99$1.91 under city medianVegetarian1 on the menuVeggie Pizza$19.99$6 over city medianWings1 on the menuChicken Wings$8.99$7 under city median
What things cost at Taste of New York Pizzeria
Taste of New York Pizzeria's signature plates against the Tampa median for the same dish.
- White Spinach Pizza with Ricotta $18.99 over the Tampa pizza median of $17
- Chicken Roll with Ricotta $9.99 under the Tampa chicken median of $14.99
- Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $19.99 at the Tampa chicken parm median of $19.99
- Pasta with Beef Sausage $11.99 under the Tampa pasta median of $20.95
- Eggplant Parmigiana $12.99 under the Tampa eggplant parm median of $17.99
- Baked Ziti Catering $48.90 over the Tampa baked ziti median of $17.50
Own Taste of New York Pizzeria? Claim it free, add photos & videos
Every cuisine and category in Tampa
American / BBQDessertCoffeeDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianBeer / WineSteakCocktailsSeafoodMexicanItalianBrunchJapaneseLatin / CaribbeanChineseMediterraneanThaiIndianPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamRamenSandwichPastaSmoothiesSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersBobaTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersHibachiChicken
See all 45 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ475Dessert267Coffee265Dietary Restrictions248Gluten free72Vegan75Vegetarian187Beer / Wine231Steak214Cocktails207Seafood204Mexican203Italian201Brunch137Japanese63Latin / Caribbean61Chinese50Mediterranean25Thai8Indian8Pizza102Burger217Sushi54Tacos108Wings195Burrito55Ice cream63Ramen13Sandwich205Pasta130Smoothies25Soup194Breakfast111Salad356Fries265Chicken tenders134Boba10Tea238Fried chicken40Hot dog27Nachos80Quesadilla101Oysters65Hibachi6Chicken386
Every dish and drink in Tampa
PhoCheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheLomo saltadoCaesar saladGrilled salmonChicken sandwichMac and cheeseCheesecakeCalamariOld fashionedSangriaIpaHummusOnion ringsEspressoOmeletteDumplingsCapreseMozzarella sticksEgg rollBurrataMimosaRavioliNY stripTeriyakiEmpanadasCrab cakesChurrosAvocado toastFried shrimpAhi tunaEdamamePoke bowlSpring rollsChicken and wafflesBologneseGuacamoleCroquetasFajitasReubenCortaditoFlanEggplant parmBloody maryCrab rangoonGnocchiWagyuLobster tailMilkshakeChurrascoTostonesGyroChocolate cakeFalafelCarbonaraFish tacosTiramisuShrimp scampiBiscuits and gravyPina coladaFrench onion soupCannoliMargherita pizzaCoconut shrimpGelatoRopa viejaNegroniWonton soupMeatball subLobster rollPalomaAl pastorEnchiladasThai curryClam chowderTres lechesAperol spritzOxtailCarne asadaBaked zitiCalifornia rollMoscow muleChicken noodle soupPrime ribBao bunsSamosaPaneerPatty meltBagel and loxChilaquilesSpicy tuna rollJerk chickenTom yumArepasButter chickenKorean bbqNashville hot chickenEloteCacio e pepeLobster bisqueConch frittersPastramiTamalesMahi sandwichMatcha lattePicanhaBiryaniDrunken noodlesGarlic naanBurnt endsNY style pizzaSeafood boilTonkotsu ramenBanh miMiso ramenKorean fried chicken
See all 154 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho4Cheeseburger107Pepperoni pizza57Cuban sandwich54Fried rice49Cheesesteak35Italian sub10Spaghetti and meatballs27Grouper sandwich16Fish and chips52General tso10Vodka sauce23Tikka masala8Shawarma15Pad thai14Smash burger38Birria tacos18Filet mignon58Ribeye56Fettuccine alfredo15Chicken parm63Lasagna32Breakfast burrito14Lo mein13Orange chicken11Brisket22Pulled pork31Baby back ribs20Cold brew31Iced latte54Margarita105Mojito43Espresso martini52Acai bowl7Pancakes69French toast69Eggs benedict18Bacon egg and cheese8Key lime pie18Ceviche44Lomo saltado7Caesar salad182Grilled salmon182Chicken sandwich124Mac and cheese110Cheesecake101Calamari97Old fashioned84Sangria81Ipa74Hummus70Onion rings70Espresso65Omelette60Dumplings58Caprese58Mozzarella sticks54Egg roll52Burrata50Mimosa48Ravioli45NY strip44Teriyaki43Empanadas43Crab cakes38Churros36Avocado toast36Fried shrimp35Ahi tuna34Edamame33Poke bowl32Spring rolls32Chicken and waffles32Bolognese31Guacamole30Croquetas28Fajitas27Reuben27Cortadito26Flan26Eggplant parm25Bloody mary25Crab rangoon24Gnocchi24Wagyu24Lobster tail23Milkshake23Churrasco23Tostones23Gyro23Chocolate cake23Falafel22Carbonara22Fish tacos21Tiramisu21Shrimp scampi20Biscuits and gravy20Pina colada20French onion soup19Cannoli18Margherita pizza18Coconut shrimp17Gelato16Ropa vieja15Negroni15Wonton soup14Meatball sub14Lobster roll14Paloma14Al pastor13Enchiladas12Thai curry12Clam chowder12Tres leches12Aperol spritz12Oxtail11Carne asada11Baked ziti11California roll11Moscow mule11Chicken noodle soup10Prime rib10Bao buns9Samosa9Paneer9Patty melt9Bagel and lox9Chilaquiles9Spicy tuna roll9Jerk chicken9Tom yum8Arepas8Butter chicken8Korean bbq8Nashville hot chicken8Elote7Cacio e pepe7Lobster bisque7Conch fritters7Pastrami6Tamales6Mahi sandwich6Matcha latte6Picanha6Biryani6Drunken noodles5Garlic naan5Burnt ends4NY style pizza4Seafood boil4Tonkotsu ramen4Banh mi3Miso ramen3Korean fried chicken3