Sarasota
Eggstraordinary Cafe, Sarasota

Eggstraordinary Sarasota Menu

Eggstraordinary Cafe · 3981 Cattlemen Rd · restaurant

Breakfast, Lunch. 131 items read from Eggstraordinary's own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026.

Eggstraordinary Breakfast Menu

Sarasota · 85 items

Breakfast see more breakfast in Sarasota

  • Traditional Breakfast Plate

    Two eggs cooked your way, choice of house potatoes, hash browns, or grits, and choice of toast

  • Biscuits & Gravy Plate

    Served with two eggs cooked your way with a choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits

  • Supreme Plate

    Choice of sausage, bacon, ham, turkey bacon, house potatoes, hash brown or grits and a choice of toast

  • 2-2-2

    Two eggs, two meats of your choice, two pancakes or French toast. (1-1-1- for $2 less)

  • Shrimp & Grits

    Blackened shrimp over grits topped with Gouda cheese, caramelized onions and diced tomatoes

  • Corned Beef Hash Plate

    Homemade hash with caramelized onions and dijon mustard. Served with two eggs your way

  • Steak & Eggs Plate

    8oz. steak served with two eggs, choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits and a choice of toast

Healthy Choices

  • Mama's Cocktail

    A healthy parfait with layers of low-fat yogurt, homemade granola and fresh fruit

  • Oatmeal Supreme

    Topped with homemade granola, mixed berry compote and fresh fruit. Served with a biscuit or choice of toast

  • Veggie Quiche

    Spinach, roasted red pepper, artichoke, red onion, Monterey jack and parmesan cheese. Choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits

  • Avocado Toast

    Hardy whole wheat topped with vegan mayo, avocado, spring mix and two eggs cooked your way, served with sliced tomatoes

  • Lox Plate

    Smoked lox, (salmon), tomatoes, red onion slices, capers and creamed cheese with your choice of bagel

  • Quinoa Bowl

    Quinoa topped with roasted vegetable medley, portabello mushrooms, caramelized onions and herbs and can be made with your choice of meat. Topped with a fresh farm egg

Omelets

  • ALL Omelets:

    All omelets served with a choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits and toast

  • Mama's Garden Omelet

    Sauteed mushrooms, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, fresh spinach and cheddar cheese

  • Harbor Master Omelet MKT

    Monterey jack cheese, sauteed New England lobster and shrimp topped with homemade hollandaise sauce

  • The Greek Omelet

    Feta cheese, Kalamata olives, fresh spinach and tomato

  • Meat Lover's Omelet

    Ham, applewood smoked bacon, sausage and cheddar cheese

  • Western Omelet

    Cheddar cheese, ham, green peppers and onions

  • Turkey Florentine Omelet

    Oven roasted turkey, fresh spinach, tomatoes and cheddar cheese

  • Tio Juan's Omelet

    Monterey jack cheese, sausage, onions, peppers, mushrooms, salsa, and sour cream

  • Build Your Own Omelet Add $1

    Swiss cheese, feta, provolone, Monterey jack, goat cheese, crumbled blue cheese, white cheddar cheese, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, spinach, kalamata olives, salsa and sour cream

  • Half Avocado Add $2 | Full Avocado Add $3
  • Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Turkey or Turkey Bacon Add $2
  • Substitute Egg Whites for $1 up charge

Pancake Parlor & Griddle see more pancakes in Sarasota

  • Our buttermilk pancakes and crepes are always made from scratch, never
  • All pancakes come 3 to an order or short stack, $1 less | Single cake
  • Plain Ol' Cakes
  • Chocolate Chip Cakes
  • Blueberry Cakes
  • Cranberry & Walnut Cakes
  • French Toast

    Texas style with a hint of vanilla and cinnamon

  • Stuffed Toast

    With cream cheeses and a mixed berry compote

  • Tropical Toast

    Pineapple, sliced banana and toasted coconut

Waffles

  • Made from our own recipe • Real maple syrup Add $2
  • Waffle

    Served with butter and syrup

  • Waffle N' Eggs

    Served with 2 eggs cooked your way, with choice of bacon, ham or sausage

  • Berry Waffle

    Mixed berry compote, fresh fruit and a dusting of powdered sugar

  • Pecan Waffle

    Belgian waffle with pecans on the side, topped with fresh whipped cream and crumbled pecans

Savory Crepes

  • Our crepes are served with a Mornay sauce on top
  • Veggies Crepes

    Spinach, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and tomatoes

  • Berry Crepes

    Stuffed with mixed berry compote and cream cheese

  • Florentine Crepes

    Oven roasted turkey, fresh spinach and tomatoes

  • Harborside Crepes MKT

    Sauteed New England lobster and shrimp, with pineapple and mango

Benedicts

  • Choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits
  • Veggie Benny

    Mushrooms, spinach, onions, peppers, and fried green tomatoes

  • Lox Benny

    Smoked lox, diced tomatoes, red onions and capers

  • Harbor Benny MKT

    Sauteed New England lobster and shrimp

  • Irish Benny

    Homemade corned beef has with sauteed mushrooms and onions, topped with homemade hollandaise sauce

  • Classic Benny

    With grilled ham and applewood bacon

  • Florentine Benny

    Oven roasted turkey, fresh spinach and tomatoes

Breakfast Sandwiches see more breakfast in Sarasota

  • Choice of house potatoes, hash browns or grits
  • Breakfast Wrap

    Scrambled eggs, sausage, green peppers, onions, tomatoes and Monterey Jack cheese in a flour tortilla, served with a side of salsa

  • Egg Sandwich

    Choice of bread, English muffin or croissant. Scrambled eggs, provolone cheese, choice of ham, bacon or sausage

Sides

  • Turkey Bacon
  • Sausage
  • Ham
  • Corn Beef Hash
  • Apple Wood Bacon
  • House Potatoes
  • Hash Browns
  • Grits
  • Cup of Oatmeal
  • Bowl of Oatmeal
  • Fried Green Tomatoes
  • Large Homemade Chips
  • Small Homemade Chips
  • French Fries
  • Full Avocado
  • Half Avocado
  • Sliced Tomatoes
  • Cup of Fruit
  • Bowl of Fruit
  • Croissant
  • English Muffin
  • Biscuit
  • Toast

    choice of sour dough, wheat marble rye

  • Bagel with Creamed Cheese

    choice of plain, or everything bagel

  • Cinnamon Raisin Toast
  • Tropical Slaw
  • Potato Salad
  • Side of Creamed Cheese
  • Side of Mornay
  • Sausage Gravy
  • Homemade Hollandaise

Eggstraordinary Lunch Menu

Sarasota · 46 items

Soup & Salad see more salad in Sarasota

  • Add to any salad: chicken breast
  • Shrimp
  • 8OZ. Steak
  • Soup of the Day Cup or Crock
  • lobster Bisque Cup
  • or Crock
  • French Onion Cup
  • Greek Salad

    Crisp romaine lettuce, topped with imported Greek feta cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, olives, green peppers and Italian dressing

  • Spinach Salad

    Fresh spinach, goat cheese, tomatoes, cucumbers, sliced apples, dried cranberries and candied walnuts. Served with a warm bacon dressing

  • Chef's Salad

    Spring mix and romaine with country ham, roasted turkey, Swiss and provolone cheeses, tomato, cucumbers, red onion and sliced egg with your choice of dressing

  • House Salad Small or Large

    Tomatoes, lettuce and cucmbers, red onions with your choice of dressings

  • Caesar Salad Small or Large

    Crisp romaine lettuce, garlic croutons and Parmesan cheese, tossed in a creamy Caesar dressing

Burgers see more burger in Sarasota

  • Black & Bleu

    Blackened seasoning with melted gorgonzola cheese on top

  • Portabello Burger

    Grilled and marinated portabello mushroom

  • Bacon Cheeseburger

    Applewood bacon and your choice of cheese

  • Eggs-Traordinary Burger

    Our tasty homemade burger topped with applewood bacon, over medium egg and cheddar cheese

  • Build A Burger

    Our homemade burger with your choice of toppings

  • Half Avocado | Full Avocado
  • Bacon, Ham, Sausage, Turkey or Turkey Bacon

Paninis

  • Choice of homemade chips, French fries, potato salad or tropical slaw
  • Mama's Nini $9$9

    Swiss cheese, turkey, tropical slaw and thousand island dressing

  • Chic a Nini $10$10

    Marinated chicken breast, applewood bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayo

  • Monte Cristo Nini $9$9

    Ham, turkey and Swiss cheese with thousand island dressing

  • West Coast Nini $10$10

    Hot turkey, bacon, red onion, tomato and spinach with Swiss cheese and pesto mayo

  • French Dip Nini $10$10

    Sliced roast beef, provolone cheese with creamy horseradish sauce and au jus on the side

Wraps

  • Any wrap can be made into a sandwich. Choice of bread: sour dough, who
  • BLT Wrap

    Our BLT wrap comes with fried green tomatoes

  • Tuna Salad Wrap

    With chopped tomato, lettuce

  • Veggie Wrap

    Vegetarian: Containing no animal meat

  • Sauteed spinach, mushrooms, onions, lettuce and tomato with a homemade
  • Tarragon Chicken Salad Wrap

    Chicken breast diced with red onions and granny smith apples mixed in a tarragon mayo with a hint of lemon

  • Turkey Club Wrap

    Homemade oven roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, applewood bacon and mayo

  • California Wrap

    Turkey, applewood bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo

  • lobster Dill Wrap MKT

    main lobster mixed in a creamy dill sauce with chopped mango and pineapple

Sandwiches see more sandwich in Sarasota

  • Served with choice of homemade chips, French fries, potato salad or tr
  • Tuna Melt

    Grilled English, muffin topped with tuna salad, grilled sliced tomato and Swiss cheese

  • Grouper Sandwich

    Sauteed or blackened grouper with lettuce and tomato served with mango dressing on a Kaiser roll

  • Turkey or Corned Beef Reuben

    Oven roasted turkey or shredded corn beef, sauerkraut, 1000 island dressing on grilled rye

  • The Gobbler

    Oven roasted turkey and Swiss cheese on a croissant served with a cranberry mayo

  • lobster Dill MKT

    Maine lobster mixed in a creamy dill sauce with chopped mango and pineapple on a croissant

Lunch Combos

  • Substitute crock size soup to any combo for $1 up charge
  • Choice of cheese: Swiss cheese, American cheese, Monterey jack, chedda
  • House Salad & Half Sandwich

    Soup of the Day & Choice of House Salad or Caesar Salad

  • French Onion & Half Sandwich
  • Lobster Bisque & Half Sandwich
  • Soup of the Day & Half Sandwich

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Eggstraordinary at other Sarasota restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Sarasota results, every place ranked, so you can compare Eggstraordinary with the rest of the city.

Own Eggstraordinary? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Sarasota

See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Sarasota

CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonCalamariChicken sandwichMac and cheeseCapreseOmeletteCheesecakeCrab cakesIpaEspressoOnion ringsSangriaAhi tunaOld fashionedHummusPoke bowlMimosaBurrataBologneseAvocado toastDumplingsRavioliGuacamoleReubenBloody maryGnocchiTeriyakiCoconut shrimpMozzarella sticksFried shrimpClam chowderLobster tailNY stripEgg rollSpring rollsChocolate cakeLobster rollWagyuEggplant parmGyroCarbonaraPalomaTiramisuEdamameFish tacosBiscuits and gravyLobster bisqueMahi sandwichGelatoFalafelEmpanadasFajitasShrimp scampiPina coladaMeatball subEnchiladasFrench onion soupMilkshakeMargherita pizzaChurrosThai curryCortaditoAperol spritzNegroniChicken and wafflesMoscow muleCroquetasFlanPrime ribBagel and loxEloteCacio e pepeCrab rangoonTamalesCannoliChilaquilesCarne asadaSpicy tuna rollNashville hot chickenKorean bbqMatcha lattePatty meltPicanhaBurnt endsTom yumBao bunsCalifornia rollWonton soupButter chickenPaneerBiryaniBaked zitiChicken noodle soupJerk chickenAl pastorConch frittersSeafood boilSurf and turfPastramiGarlic naanChurrascoTres lechesRopa viejaTostonesStone crabSamosa
See all 146 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger66Pepperoni pizza30Cuban sandwich23Fried rice19Cheesesteak18Italian sub5Spaghetti and meatballs10Grouper sandwich17Fish and chips46General tso5Vodka sauce11Tikka masala6Shawarma3Pad thai6Smash burger21Birria tacos11Filet mignon40Ribeye38Fettuccine alfredo5Chicken parm35Lasagna26Breakfast burrito12Lo mein8Orange chicken7Brisket19Pulled pork15Baby back ribs16Cold brew15Iced latte37Margarita70Mojito31Espresso martini28Acai bowl8Pancakes48French toast39Eggs benedict15Bacon egg and cheese6Key lime pie22Ceviche24Caesar salad133Grilled salmon122Calamari81Chicken sandwich73Mac and cheese56Caprese52Omelette49Cheesecake49Crab cakes48Ipa45Espresso45Onion rings45Sangria44Ahi tuna44Old fashioned43Hummus39Poke bowl37Mimosa35Burrata35Bolognese32Avocado toast32Dumplings29Ravioli29Guacamole28Reuben27Bloody mary26Gnocchi26Teriyaki25Coconut shrimp25Mozzarella sticks24Fried shrimp24Clam chowder23Lobster tail22NY strip22Egg roll21Spring rolls21Chocolate cake20Lobster roll19Wagyu19Eggplant parm19Gyro18Carbonara18Paloma18Tiramisu17Edamame16Fish tacos16Biscuits and gravy14Lobster bisque14Mahi sandwich14Gelato14Falafel14Empanadas14Fajitas14Shrimp scampi13Pina colada13Meatball sub13Enchiladas12French onion soup12Milkshake11Margherita pizza11Churros10Thai curry10Cortadito10Aperol spritz9Negroni9Chicken and waffles9Moscow mule8Croquetas8Flan8Prime rib8Bagel and lox8Elote8Cacio e pepe7Crab rangoon7Tamales7Cannoli7Chilaquiles7Carne asada6Spicy tuna roll6Nashville hot chicken6Korean bbq6Matcha latte6Patty melt6Picanha5Burnt ends5Tom yum5Bao buns5California roll5Wonton soup5Butter chicken5Paneer5Biryani5Baked ziti4Chicken noodle soup4Jerk chicken4Al pastor4Conch fritters4Seafood boil4Surf and turf4Pastrami4Garlic naan4Churrasco3Tres leches3Ropa vieja3Tostones3Stone crab3Samosa3