The Villages

Key lime pie in The Villages

Every key lime pie on every menu we have read in The Villages, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

4 places in The Villages have key lime pie on the menu, from $7.95 at Fenney Grill to $8.99 at The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club. Highest rated: The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club (4.3). 3 of 4 list a price.

Sawgrass Tavern, The Villages

Sawgrass Tavern

810 Marilee Pl · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
1
  • Key Lime Pie

    key lime sauce, graham crackers, whipped cream

Sawgrass Tavern on 810 Marilee Pl is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 key lime pie. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, beer, breakfast.

Own Sawgrass Tavern? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club

17155 Buena Vista Blvd · Bar · website

Full menu 4.3 (202)1 key lime pie
2
  • Florida KEY Lime PIE$8.99

    with Real Key Lime Juice & Whipped Cream

Florida KEY Lime PIE at The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club is $8.99 in The Villages. The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club on 17155 Buena Vista Blvd is a bar rated 4.3 (202 reviews). The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $8.99, around the The Villages median of $8.99. Also on the menu: bloody mary, burger, chicken sandwich.

Own The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About key lime pie in The Villages

4 of the 71 restaurants and bars we track in The Villages list key lime pie. Prices run from $7.95 at Fenney Grill to $8.99 at The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club, with a median of $8.99. Most of them sit along Buena Vista Blvd and Fenney Grill. The highest rated is The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club (4.3).

4places
$7.95–$8.99price range
$8.99median
The Pool Bar at Natop rated
Cheapest
$7.95 at Fenney Grill
Most expensive
$8.99 at The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club
Most spots
Buena Vista Blvd · Fenney Grill · 6706-000-005
Menus read
November 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in The Villages

Questions

Where is the cheapest key lime pie in The Villages?

Fenney Grill lists Mike's Key Lime Pie at $7.95. Median across 4 places is $8.99.

Which The Villages spot has the best-rated key lime pie?

The Pool Bar at Nancy Lopez Country Club (4.3 from 202 reviews).

How many places in The Villages serve key lime pie?

4 of the 71 menus we have read in The Villages list key lime pie.

Every cuisine and category in The Villages

See all 34 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in The Villages

See all 80 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?