The Villages

Cheesecake in The Villages

Every cheesecake on every menu we have read in The Villages, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

19 places in The Villages have cheesecake on the menu, from $6.25 at Sammy Joe's to $12 at Wolfgang Puck Kitchen + Bar. Highest rated: Olive Garden Italian Restaurant (4.3), NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages (4.3), Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille (4.2). Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace, Carrabba's Italian Grill run a happy hour. 15 of 19 list a price.

NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages

4046 Wedgewood Ln · Pizza · website

Full menu 4.3 (1,343)4 cheesecakes
1
  • Mini Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.

  • Flight Mini Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.

  • Slice of Cheesecake

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.

  • Whole Cheesecakes

    Locally Sourced with Cheesecake Chino's. Our Artisan Treats, Quality Handcrafted Cheesecakes.

NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages on 4046 Wedgewood Ln is a pizza rated 4.3 (1,343 reviews). The menu lists 4 cheesecakes. Also on the menu: bolognese, cannoli, caprese.

Own NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

3680 Wedgewood Ln · Italian · website

Full menu 4.3 (3,195)1 cheesecake
2
  • Sicilian Cheesecake$37.99

    Our rich and creamy ricotta cheesecake features a shortbread cookie crust and is topped with a seasonal strawberry sauce. Order a whole or half cake today.

Sicilian Cheesecake at Olive Garden Italian Restaurant is $37.99 in The Villages. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant on 3680 Wedgewood Ln is an italian rated 4.3 (3,195 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $37.99, above the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, calamari, chicken.

Own Olive Garden Italian Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Glenview Country Club

3194 Glenview Rd · Restaurant · website

Full menu 4.2 (1,610)1 cheesecake
3
  • NY Style Cheesecake$7.99

NY Style Cheesecake at Glenview Country Club is $7.99 in The Villages. Glenview Country Club on 3194 Glenview Rd is a restaurant rated 4.2 (1,610 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $7.99, below the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, bolognese, burger.

Own Glenview Country Club? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Tequila Cantina Mexican Kitchen

3551 Wedgewood Ln · Mexican · website

Full menu 4.2 (1,109)1 cheesecake
4
  • Cheesecake Chimichanga$9

    Cream cheese wrapped in a pastry tortilla & fried till crisp. Paired with chocolate, banana, and caramel sauce

Cheesecake Chimichanga at Tequila Cantina Mexican Kitchen is $9 in The Villages. Tequila Cantina Mexican Kitchen on 3551 Wedgewood Ln is a mexican rated 4.2 (1,109 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9, around the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: beer, burger, burrito.

Own Tequila Cantina Mexican Kitchen? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Prima Italian Steakhouse, The Villages

Prima Italian Steakhouse

3660 Kiessel Rd · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 11 AM-4 PM1 cheesecake
5
  • Seasonal Cheesecake$9

Seasonal Cheesecake at Prima Italian Steakhouse is $9 in The Villages. Prima Italian Steakhouse on 3660 Kiessel Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9, around the The Villages median of $9. Happy hour Daily 11 AM-4 PM. Also on the menu: bolognese, burger, caesar salad.

Own Prima Italian Steakhouse? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

RJ Gator's Florida Sea Grill & Bar, The Villages

RJ Gator's Florida Sea Grill & Bar

1015 Lake Shore Dr #1693 · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
6
  • Cheesecake of the Day$9.99

Cheesecake of the Day at RJ Gator's Florida Sea Grill & Bar is $9.99 in The Villages. RJ Gator's Florida Sea Grill & Bar on 1015 Lake Shore Dr #1693 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9.99, above the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: burger, caesar salad, chicken.

Own RJ Gator's Florida Sea Grill & Bar? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Chop House at Lake Sumter, The Villages

Chop House at Lake Sumter

1045 Old Camp Rd · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 11 AM-4 PM; Daily 8 PM1 cheesecake
7
  • Lemon Vanilla Cheesecake$9.90

    served with fresh berries and whipped cream

Lemon Vanilla Cheesecake at Chop House at Lake Sumter is $9.90 in The Villages. Chop House at Lake Sumter on 1045 Old Camp Rd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9.90, above the The Villages median of $9. Happy hour Daily 11 AM-4 PM; Daily 8 PM-close. Also on the menu: burger, burrata, cheeseburger.

Own Chop House at Lake Sumter? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille

925 Lake Shore Dr · American · website

Full menu 4.2 (2,721)1 cheesecake
8
  • Pina Colada Cheesecake$11

Pina Colada Cheesecake at Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille is $11 in The Villages. Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille on 925 Lake Shore Dr is an american rated 4.2 (2,721 reviews). The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $11, above the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, beer, burger.

Own Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, The Villages

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza

729 Kristine Way · pizza · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 11 AM-6 PM2 cheesecakes
9
  • New York Style Cheesecake$7.99

    Classic cream cheese custard with a graham cracker crust & whipped cream

  • Salted Caramel Cheesecake$8.99

    Sea salt & smooth caramel swirled together in this rich cheesecake with whipped cream

New York Style Cheesecake at Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza is $7.99 in The Villages. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza on 729 Kristine Way is a pizza. The menu lists 2 cheesecakes, from $7.99 for the New York Style Cheesecake to $8.99, below the The Villages median of $9. Happy hour Daily 11 AM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, bolognese.

Own Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace, The Villages

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace

3539 Wedgewood Ln · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 11 AM-6 PM2 cheesecakes
10
  • New York Style Cheesecake$7.99

    Classic cream cheese custard with a graham cracker crust & whipped cream

  • Salted Caramel Cheesecake$8.99

    Sea salt & smooth caramel swirled together in this rich cheesecake with whipped cream

New York Style Cheesecake at Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace is $7.99 in The Villages. Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace on 3539 Wedgewood Ln is a restaurant. The menu lists 2 cheesecakes, from $7.99 for the New York Style Cheesecake to $8.99, below the The Villages median of $9. Happy hour Daily 11 AM-6 PM. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, bolognese.

Own Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant, The Villages

TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant

1129 Canal St · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
11
  • Cheesecake with Strawberries

    Our homemade New York style cheesecake with graham cracker walnut crust topped with garden fresh strawberries and purée

TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant on 1129 Canal St is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake. Also on the menu: avocado toast, breakfast, brisket.

Own TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Ednas' On The Green, The Villages

Ednas' On The Green

5227 Marsh Bend Trl · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
12
  • Stop in to see this months flavor!

Ednas' On The Green on 5227 Marsh Bend Trl is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake. Also on the menu: bbq, beer, burger.

Own Ednas' On The Green? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Carrabba's Italian Grill, The Villages

Carrabba's Italian Grill

650 US-441 · restaurant · website

Full menu Happy Hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM1 cheesecake
13
  • Strawberry Cheesecake$11.99

    Creamy New York-style cheesecake topped with our strawberry puree.

Strawberry Cheesecake at Carrabba's Italian Grill is $11.99 in The Villages. Carrabba's Italian Grill on 650 US-441 is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $11.99, above the The Villages median of $9. Happy hour Daily 4 PM-6 PM. Also on the menu: beer, burrata, caesar salad.

Own Carrabba's Italian Grill? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Evans Prairie - Country Club Restaurant, The Villages

Evans Prairie - Country Club Restaurant

1825 Evans Prairie Trail · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
15
  • Pumpkin Cheesecake$8.99

Pumpkin Cheesecake at Evans Prairie - Country Club Restaurant is $8.99 in The Villages. Evans Prairie - Country Club Restaurant on 1825 Evans Prairie Trail is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $8.99, below the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: bolognese, burger, caesar salad.

Own Evans Prairie - Country Club Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Sammy Joe's, The Villages

Sammy Joe's

8760 SE 165th Mulberry Ln · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
16
  • Philidelphia Cheesecake$6.25

    Slice of cheesecake drizzled wtih chocolate or caramel and garnished with whipped cream

Philidelphia Cheesecake at Sammy Joe's is $6.25 in The Villages. Sammy Joe's on 8760 SE 165th Mulberry Ln is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $6.25, below the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: breakfast, chicken, chicken parm.

Own Sammy Joe's? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant

2835 Brownwood Blvd · restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
18
  • Cheesecake with Strawberries

    Our homemade New York style cheesecake with graham cracker walnut crust topped with garden fresh strawberries and purée

TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant on 2835 Brownwood Blvd is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake. Also on the menu: avocado toast, breakfast, brisket.

Own TooJay’s Deli • Bakery • Restaurant? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Arnold Palmer Legends Country Club

1635 Palmer Wy · Restaurant · website

Full menu 1 cheesecake
19
  • Turtle Caramel Cheesecake$9

Turtle Caramel Cheesecake at Arnold Palmer Legends Country Club is $9 in The Villages. Arnold Palmer Legends Country Club on 1635 Palmer Wy is a restaurant. The menu lists 1 cheesecake at $9, around the The Villages median of $9. Also on the menu: ahi tuna, burger, caesar salad.

Own Arnold Palmer Legends Country Club? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About cheesecake in The Villages

19 of the 71 restaurants and bars we track in The Villages list cheesecake. Prices run from $6.25 at Sammy Joe's to $12 at Wolfgang Puck Kitchen + Bar, with a median of $9. Most of them sit along Wedgewood Ln and Kristine Way. The highest rated is Olive Garden Italian Restaurant (4.3), and Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace pair it with a happy hour.

19places
$6.25–$12price range
$9median
Olive Garden Italitop rated
Cheapest
$6.25 at Sammy Joe's
Most expensive
$12 at Wolfgang Puck Kitchen + Bar
Most spots
Wedgewood Ln · Kristine Way · Brownwood Blvd
Happy hour
Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza, Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace, Carrabba's Italian Grill, Chop House at Lake Sumter
Menus read
November 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in The Villages

Questions

Where is the cheapest cheesecake in The Villages?

Sammy Joe's lists Philidelphia Cheesecake at $6.25. Median across 19 places is $9.

Which The Villages spot has the best-rated cheesecake?

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant (4.3 from 3,195 reviews), NYPD Pizzeria At The Villages (4.3 from 1,343 reviews), Lighthouse Point Bar and Grille (4.2 from 2,721 reviews).

Any cheesecake places with a happy hour?

Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza: Daily 11 AM-6 PM; Piesanos Stone Fired Pizza - Southern Trace: Daily 11 AM-6 PM; Carrabba's Italian Grill: Daily 4 PM-6 PM.

Every cuisine and category in The Villages

See all 34 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in The Villages

See all 80 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?