Pensacola

Key lime pie in Pensacola

Every key lime pie on every menu we have read in Pensacola, with the price each place charges, their photos and videos, and a link to the menu.

4 places in Pensacola have key lime pie on the menu, from $6.99 at Sunset Grille to $34.31 at Hot Spot Barbecue. Highest rated: Sunset Grille (4.5). 3 of 4 list a price.

Sunset Grille

14050 Canal A Way · Seafood · website

Full menu 4.5 (2,752)1 key lime pie
1
  • Homemade Key Lime Pie$6.99

Homemade Key Lime Pie at Sunset Grille is $6.99 in Pensacola. Sunset Grille on 14050 Canal A Way is a seafood rated 4.5 (2,752 reviews). The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $6.99, below the Pensacola median of $10. Also on the menu: burger, calamari, chicken.

Own Sunset Grille? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Hot Spot Barbecue, Pensacola

Hot Spot Barbecue

901 E La Rua St · barbecue · website

Full menu 3 key lime pies
2
  • Key Lime Pie (Slice)$6.99

    Creamy key lime, graham cracker crust

  • Key Lime Pie (Full)$32.94

    Creamy Key Lime Flavor Graham Cracker Crust Seasonal

  • Key Lime Pie Full$34.31

    Seasonal

Key Lime Pie (Slice) at Hot Spot Barbecue is $6.99 in Pensacola. Hot Spot Barbecue on 901 E La Rua St is a barbecue. The menu lists 3 key lime pies, from $6.99 for the Key Lime Pie (Slice) to $34.31, below the Pensacola median of $10. Also on the menu: bbq, brisket, burnt ends.

Own Hot Spot Barbecue? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

Pearl & Horn, Pensacola

Pearl & Horn

1504 W Intendencia St · seafood · website

Full menu 1 key lime pie
3
  • KEY Lime PIE$10

    a buttery graham crust with layers of traditional key lime pie & key lime cream, finished with whipped cream and key lime zest

KEY Lime PIE at Pearl & Horn is $10 in Pensacola. Pearl & Horn on 1504 W Intendencia St is a seafood. The menu lists 1 key lime pie at $10, around the Pensacola median of $10. Also on the menu: beer, caesar salad, calamari.

Own Pearl & Horn? Claim it free, add your photos and videos

About key lime pie in Pensacola

4 of the 202 restaurants and bars we track in Pensacola list key lime pie. Prices run from $6.99 at Sunset Grille to $34.31 at Hot Spot Barbecue, with a median of $10. Most of them sit along Canal A Way and E La Rua St. The highest rated is Sunset Grille (4.5).

4places
$6.99–$34.31price range
$10median
Sunset Grilletop rated
Cheapest
$6.99 at Sunset Grille
Most expensive
$34.31 at Hot Spot Barbecue
Most spots
Canal A Way · E La Rua St · W Garden St
Menus read
October 2026, from each venue's own site

Related

See more in Pensacola

Questions

Where is the cheapest key lime pie in Pensacola?

Sunset Grille lists Homemade Key Lime Pie at $6.99. Median across 4 places is $10.

Which Pensacola spot has the best-rated key lime pie?

Sunset Grille (4.5 from 2,752 reviews).

How many places in Pensacola serve key lime pie?

4 of the 202 menus we have read in Pensacola list key lime pie.

Every cuisine and category in Pensacola

See all 41 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Pensacola

See all 114 dishes and drinks as a list

Craving something else?