Orlando

I Love NY Pizza & Subs Orlando Menu & Prices

· 6602 Old Winter Garden Rd · restaurant

Specialty Pizza, Everyday Special, Menu PDF "Menu". 130 items read from I Love NY Pizza & Subs' own menu. Menu reviewed September 2026. Signature plates: Two 18” Pizza w/ 1 Topping Each $29.99, 6 Wings $7.50, Chicken Alfredo (Ziti or Spaghetti $15.99.

Specialty Pizza 15Everyday Special 9Menu PDF "Menu" 106

I Love NY Pizza & Subs Specialty Pizza Menu

Orlando · 15 items

Specialty Pizza see more pizza in Orlando

  • 5 Cheese Pizza

    With Ricotta, Parmesan, Feta, Provologne & Mozzarella

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza

    Homemade BBQ Chicken Pizza made with BBQ Sauce, Mozzarella & Chicken

  • Chicken Wing Pizza

    Magnificent flavor with chicken, Mild Blue Cheese, or Hot

  • Deluxe / Supreme

    The perfect most delicious full deluxe supreme pizza baked fresh out

  • Eggplant Parmigiana Pizza

    Pizza night! with X-Mozzarella, Eggplant, Ricotta, and Marinara

  • Hawaiian Pizza

    Our Tasty and Juicy Hawaiian Pizza with Ham & Pineapple

  • Italian Chicken

    Chicken Pizza Italiano with Chicken, Roma Tomato, and Garlic

  • Italian Mix Pizza

    Italian Pizza with Salami, Ham, Pepperoni, and Provologne

  • Lasagna Pizza

    Delicious Pizza with Ricotta, Meatballs, Mozzarella, and Marinara

  • Meat Lover’s Pizza

    Meat Lover’s Pizza packed with Bacon, Sausage, Pepperoni & Ham

  • NY White Pizza

    A New-York Style white pizza with drizzled olive oil, Ricotta, Garlic Sauce, and Mozzarella

  • Primavera Pizza

    With Spinach, Roma Tomato, Onion, Green Pepper Mushrooms & Black Olives

  • Rio Rancho Pizza

    Pizza Rancho with Beacon, Tomato, and Ranch Dressing

  • Roma Spinach Pizza

    Health Pizza with Spinach, Fresh Garlic, Mozzarella Feta, Roma Tomato

  • Steak & Cheese

    Pizza with Steak, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onion & Mozzarella Cheese

I Love NY Pizza & Subs Everyday Special

Orlando · 9 items

Everyday Special

  • Xxlg 18” Cheese$13.95

    PICK UP ONLY Extra topping: for 1.95 each

  • LG 14” Cheese$9.25

    PICK UP ONLY Extra topping: for 1.50 each

  • Two XXLG 18” Cheese$49.99

    20 Wings, 6 Garlic Knots Extra topping: for 1.95 each

  • One XXLG 18” Cheese$34.99

    20 Wings, 6 Garlic Knots Extra topping: for 1.95 each

  • One XXLG 18” Cheese$24.99

    10 Wings, 6 Garlic Knots Extra topping: for 1.95 each

  • One XXLG 18″ Cheese Breadsticks, 6 garlic knots$23.99

    Extra topping: for 1.95 each

  • One LG 14″ 1 Topping, 10 wings, and 6 garlic knots$23.99

    Extra topping: for 1.50 each

  • Two 14″ Pizza 1 Topp. Each$21.99

    Two lg 14″ Pizza with One Topping Each Extra topping: for 1.50 each

  • Two 18” Pizza 1 Topp. Each$31.99

    Two xxlg 18″ Pizza with One Topping Each Extra topping: for 1.95 each

Search popular dishes & drinks found at I Love NY Pizza & Subs at other Orlando restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Orlando results, every place ranked, so you can compare I Love NY Pizza & Subs with the rest of the city.

Pizza30 on the menuTwo 18” Pizza w/ 1 Topping Each$29.99$11.99 over city medianWings9 on the menu6 Wings$7.50$7.49 under city medianSalad6 on the menuAntipasto Salad Pepperoni, Ham, Salami & ProvoloChicken5 on the menuChicken Alfredo (Ziti or Spaghetti)$15.99$1.99 over city medianChicken parm2 on the menuChicken Parmigiana$15.99$4.80 under city medianEggplant parm2 on the menuEggplant Parmigiana Spaghetti$15.99$2.50 under city medianFries2 on the menuFrench Fries Small Large$2$6.95 under city medianOnion rings2 on the menuMix 5 Onion Rings & 5 Mozzarela Sticks$7.50about the city median

What things cost at I Love NY Pizza & Subs

I Love NY Pizza & Subs' signature plates against the Orlando median for the same dish.

Own I Love NY Pizza & Subs? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Orlando

American / BBQDessertCoffeeDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianSteakBeer / WineSeafoodItalianCocktailsMexicanBrunchJapaneseLatin / CaribbeanChineseMediterraneanThaiIndianVietnameseKoreanPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamRamenSandwichPastaSmoothiesDim sumSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersBobaTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersHibachiChicken
See all 48 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ660Dessert388Coffee375Dietary Restrictions346Gluten free97Vegan96Vegetarian271Steak326Beer / Wine288Seafood286Italian247Cocktails245Mexican231Brunch150Japanese113Latin / Caribbean111Chinese94Mediterranean29Thai19Indian17Vietnamese8Korean6Pizza123Burger250Sushi81Tacos143Wings267Burrito68Ice cream103Ramen30Sandwich228Pasta159Smoothies37Dim sum6Soup300Breakfast113Salad461Fries383Chicken tenders196Boba26Tea327Fried chicken81Hot dog41Nachos109Quesadilla117Oysters77Hibachi21Chicken552

Every dish and drink in Orlando

PhoCheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka sauceTikka masalaShawarmaPad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheLomo saltadoGrilled salmonCaesar saladCheesecakeCalamariMac and cheeseDumplingsChicken sandwichSangriaIpaOld fashionedOnion ringsTeriyakiEmpanadasEdamameSpring rollsEspressoGuacamoleHummusBurrataEgg rollOmeletteMozzarella sticksMimosaNY stripCapreseTostonesLobster tailWagyuFried shrimpRavioliBloody maryCrab cakesFajitasPoke bowlPina coladaChocolate cakeAvocado toastAhi tunaChurrascoCortaditoPalomaCoconut shrimpChurrosShrimp scampiMilkshakeEggplant parmCarne asadaCroquetasFlanTiramisuBologneseChicken and wafflesFish tacosTres lechesCarbonaraGnocchiEnchiladasMargherita pizzaFalafelPicanhaWonton soupBao bunsGyroThai curryMeatball subChicken noodle soupCalifornia rollEloteOxtailFrench onion soupTom yumSpicy tuna rollAl pastorTamalesNashville hot chickenArepasLobster rollCannoliSamosaReubenChilaquilesLobster bisqueBiscuits and gravyClam chowderJerk chickenPaneerPatty meltCrab rangoonPastramiGelatoBiryaniGarlic naanButter chickenAperol spritzMahi sandwichRopa viejaKorean fried chickenNegroniMoscow muleBibimbapPrime ribBaked zitiBurnt endsDrunken noodlesKorean bbqMatcha latteTonkotsu ramenSurf and turfSeafood boilBanh miCacio e pepeBagel and loxIdliConch frittersMiso ramenDosa
See all 157 dishes and drinks as a list
Pho12Cheeseburger121Pepperoni pizza70Cuban sandwich37Fried rice96Cheesesteak38Italian sub12Spaghetti and meatballs27Grouper sandwich5Fish and chips57General tso34Vodka sauce27Tikka masala13Shawarma11Pad thai21Smash burger34Birria tacos28Filet mignon67Ribeye99Fettuccine alfredo28Chicken parm73Lasagna34Breakfast burrito10Lo mein41Orange chicken15Brisket49Pulled pork30Baby back ribs32Cold brew26Iced latte53Margarita133Mojito57Espresso martini34Acai bowl12Pancakes58French toast65Eggs benedict12Bacon egg and cheese13Key lime pie23Ceviche77Lomo saltado17Grilled salmon262Caesar salad228Cheesecake162Calamari140Mac and cheese131Dumplings128Chicken sandwich123Sangria99Ipa99Old fashioned92Onion rings87Teriyaki84Empanadas81Edamame78Spring rolls73Espresso67Guacamole64Hummus63Burrata62Egg roll61Omelette61Mozzarella sticks58Mimosa58NY strip56Caprese55Tostones53Lobster tail49Wagyu48Fried shrimp48Ravioli47Bloody mary46Crab cakes46Fajitas45Poke bowl44Pina colada44Chocolate cake43Avocado toast42Ahi tuna41Churrasco41Cortadito41Paloma39Coconut shrimp38Churros37Shrimp scampi36Milkshake36Eggplant parm34Carne asada34Croquetas34Flan34Tiramisu33Bolognese32Chicken and waffles32Fish tacos32Tres leches32Carbonara31Gnocchi30Enchiladas27Margherita pizza27Falafel26Picanha25Wonton soup24Bao buns23Gyro22Thai curry22Meatball sub22Chicken noodle soup21California roll21Elote21Oxtail20French onion soup20Tom yum20Spicy tuna roll20Al pastor19Tamales19Nashville hot chicken19Arepas18Lobster roll18Cannoli18Samosa17Reuben16Chilaquiles15Lobster bisque14Biscuits and gravy14Clam chowder14Jerk chicken13Paneer13Patty melt13Crab rangoon12Pastrami12Gelato11Biryani11Garlic naan11Butter chicken11Aperol spritz11Mahi sandwich11Ropa vieja10Korean fried chicken10Negroni10Moscow mule9Bibimbap9Prime rib9Baked ziti9Burnt ends8Drunken noodles7Korean bbq7Matcha latte7Tonkotsu ramen6Surf and turf5Seafood boil5Banh mi5Cacio e pepe5Bagel and lox5Idli4Conch fritters4Miso ramen4Dosa3