Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub Cape Coral Menu & Prices
1708 Cape Coral Pkwy W #1 · restaurant
Daily Specials, Monthly Specials, Drinks. 304 items read from Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub's own menu. Menu reviewed October 2026. Signature plates: Build Your Own (Large 16") $17.95, Mahi Sandwich $15.95, Cajun Burger $17.45.
Search popular dishes & drinks found at Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub at other Cape Coral restaurants
Each card opens that dish's Cape Coral results, every place ranked, so you can compare Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub with the rest of the city.
Salad23 on the menuOT House Salad$10.95$2.05 under city medianBurger8 on the menuCajun Burger$17.45$1.50 over city medianSandwich15 on the menuMahi Sandwich$15.95$2.95 over city medianPizza16 on the menuBuild Your Own (Large 16")$17.95$2.05 under city medianWings6 on the menuWings$15.45about the city medianPasta8 on the menuMac 'N CheeseChicken7 on the menuChicken Marsala$18.95$4 over city medianFries6 on the menuSweet Potato Fries$6about the city median
BBQ4 on the menuBourbon BBQ$16.95about the city medianCaesar salad4 on the menuClassic Caesar$11.95about the city medianFettuccine alfredo4 on the menuChicken Fettuccine Alfredo$19.95about the city medianVodka sauce4 on the menuPenne Alla Vodka$14.95$2.05 under city medianSteak3 on the menuSD Steak$15.95$3.55 under city medianBaby back ribs2 on the menuFull Baby Back Ribs$23.95about the city medianCaprese2 on the menuAvocado Caprese$14.95about the city medianChicken parm2 on the menuChicken Parmesan$18.95about the city medianMeatball sub2 on the menuMeatball Parm$14.95about the city medianNY strip2 on the menuHand Cut NY Strip$25.95about the city medianOnion rings2 on the menuOnion Rings$6$1.95 under city medianSpaghetti and meatballs2 on the menuSpaghetti & Meatballs$15.95about the city medianCalamari1 on the menuCalamari$15.95about the city medianCheesesteak1 on the menuPhilly CheesesteakChicken tenders1 on the menuChicken Tender Basket$14.95$2.95 over city medianEggplant parm1 on the menuEggplant Parmesan$16.95about the city medianFajitas1 on the menuFajita$14.95$9.04 under city medianFish and chips1 on the menuFish & ChipsGrilled salmon1 on the menuHoney Glazed Salmon$20.95about the city medianMac and cheese1 on the menuSD Mac and Cheese$6$2 under city medianMargherita pizza1 on the menuMargheritaMozzarella sticks1 on the menuMozzarella Sticks$10.45$1.45 over city medianNachos1 on the menuNachos$14.45$1.54 under city medianPrime rib1 on the menuPrime Rib DinnerQuesadilla1 on the menuChicken Quesadilla$15.45$1.26 over city medianReuben1 on the menuReuben Sandwich$15.45about the city medianTacos1 on the menuTacosVegetarian1 on the menuVegetarian Stromboli$19.95$4.45 over city medianBeer22 on the menuGuinnessTea2 on the menuSurfside TeasCocktails8 on the menuTouchdownWine8 on the menuCopper Ridge Pinot GrigioEspresso martini1 on the menuEspresso Martini
What things cost at Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub
Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub's signature plates against the Cape Coral median for the same dish.
- Build Your Own (Large 16") $17.95 under the Cape Coral pizza median of $20
- Mahi Sandwich $15.95 over the Cape Coral sandwich median of $13
- Cajun Burger $17.45 over the Cape Coral burger median of $15.95
- Chicken Marsala $18.95 over the Cape Coral chicken median of $14.95
- Wings $15.45 over the Cape Coral wings median of $14.95
- Bourbon BBQ $16.95 at the Cape Coral bbq median of $16.95
Own Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub? Claim it free, add photos & videos
Every cuisine and category in Cape Coral
American / BBQMexicanDessertDietary RestrictionsGluten freeVeganVegetarianCoffeeSteakSeafoodItalianBeer / WineBrunchCocktailsJapaneseChineseLatin / CaribbeanPizzaBurgerSushiTacosWingsBurritoIce creamSandwichPastaSmoothiesSoupBreakfastSaladFriesChicken tendersTeaFried chickenHot dogNachosQuesadillaOystersHibachiChicken
See all 40 cuisines and categories as a list
American / BBQ125Mexican71Dessert71Dietary Restrictions70Gluten free23Vegan18Vegetarian59Coffee69Steak66Seafood61Italian59Beer / Wine49Brunch42Cocktails42Japanese16Chinese15Latin / Caribbean10Pizza34Burger60Sushi9Tacos45Wings69Burrito25Ice cream20Sandwich62Pasta35Smoothies7Soup53Breakfast38Salad98Fries84Chicken tenders53Tea58Fried chicken16Hot dog13Nachos29Quesadilla36Oysters18Hibachi5Chicken107
Every dish and drink in Cape Coral
CheeseburgerPepperoni pizzaCuban sandwichFried riceCheesesteakItalian subSpaghetti and meatballsGrouper sandwichFish and chipsGeneral tsoVodka saucePad thaiSmash burgerBirria tacosFilet mignonRibeyeFettuccine alfredoChicken parmLasagnaBreakfast burritoLo meinOrange chickenBrisketPulled porkBaby back ribsCold brewIced latteMargaritaMojitoEspresso martiniAcai bowlPancakesFrench toastEggs benedictBacon egg and cheeseKey lime pieCevicheCaesar saladGrilled salmonMac and cheeseOnion ringsCalamariChicken sandwichCheesecakeFajitasOmeletteMozzarella sticksCoconut shrimpEspressoCapreseReubenDumplingsGuacamoleAhi tunaTeriyakiNY stripEdamameRavioliEgg rollCrab cakesBloody maryFried shrimpAvocado toastEggplant parmPina coladaLobster tailOld fashionedChocolate cakeEmpanadasEnchiladasBiscuits and gravyGyroSpring rollsSangriaIpaCarne asadaMilkshakeFlanBologneseShrimp scampiCannoliClam chowderMimosaCortaditoBurrataPrime ribFish tacosTamalesChicken and wafflesChurrosChurrascoPatty meltLobster rollTiramisuChicken noodle soupPoke bowlTostonesGnocchiWonton soupThai curryMeatball subCrab rangoonBurnt endsMargherita pizzaFrench onion soupChilaquilesCarbonaraWagyuPalomaConch frittersNashville hot chickenLobster bisquePastramiTres lechesButter chickenHummusTom yumBagel and lox
See all 118 dishes and drinks as a list
Cheeseburger39Pepperoni pizza16Cuban sandwich6Fried rice17Cheesesteak21Italian sub6Spaghetti and meatballs5Grouper sandwich6Fish and chips20General tso8Vodka sauce7Pad thai4Smash burger10Birria tacos7Filet mignon13Ribeye17Fettuccine alfredo5Chicken parm20Lasagna11Breakfast burrito5Lo mein7Orange chicken5Brisket8Pulled pork13Baby back ribs12Cold brew10Iced latte13Margarita19Mojito9Espresso martini8Acai bowl4Pancakes21French toast20Eggs benedict6Bacon egg and cheese4Key lime pie3Ceviche11Caesar salad50Grilled salmon42Mac and cheese33Onion rings32Calamari32Chicken sandwich30Cheesecake27Fajitas23Omelette22Mozzarella sticks20Coconut shrimp19Espresso19Caprese18Reuben17Dumplings17Guacamole16Ahi tuna15Teriyaki15NY strip14Edamame14Ravioli14Egg roll13Crab cakes13Bloody mary12Fried shrimp12Avocado toast12Eggplant parm12Pina colada11Lobster tail11Old fashioned10Chocolate cake10Empanadas10Enchiladas10Biscuits and gravy10Gyro10Spring rolls10Sangria10Ipa9Carne asada9Milkshake9Flan8Bolognese8Shrimp scampi8Cannoli8Clam chowder8Mimosa8Cortadito7Burrata7Prime rib7Fish tacos7Tamales7Chicken and waffles7Churros6Churrasco6Patty melt6Lobster roll6Tiramisu6Chicken noodle soup6Poke bowl6Tostones5Gnocchi5Wonton soup5Thai curry5Meatball sub5Crab rangoon5Burnt ends5Margherita pizza4French onion soup4Chilaquiles4Carbonara4Wagyu4Paloma4Conch fritters4Nashville hot chicken4Lobster bisque4Pastrami3Tres leches3Butter chicken3Hummus3Tom yum3Bagel and lox3