Panama City
Gary's Oyster Shack, Panama City

Gary's Oyster Shack Panama City Menu & Prices

1320 N Tyndall Pkwy · restaurant

Panama City. 59 items read from Gary's Oyster Shack's own menu. Menu reviewed November 2026. Signature plates: Fried Seafood Platter $35, Quesabarria Taco $18, Smokehouse Cheddar Burger $15.

Gary's Oyster Shack Panama City Menu

Panama City · 59 items

Appetizers

  • Smoked Wings$10
  • Smoked Tuna Dip$14
  • Loaded BBQ Nachos$15

    Thursday-Saturday. House-smoked pulled pork layered over house made wonton nachos smothered in melted cheese sauce and our signature BBQ sauce. Topped with jalapeño slaw for the perfect balance of hea

  • Cup Gumbo$8

    Traditional southern gumbo with sausage, okra and shrimp in a rich roux thickened broth

  • Parmesan Truffle Fries$12

    Crispy fries fried in beef tallow tossed in house made garlic parmesan herb oil and finished with a truffle salt

  • Fried Pickles$12
  • Crab Fingers$21

Lunch Menu - Seafood Basket see more seafood in Panama City

  • Catfish Basket$14
  • Pick Two Basket$17

    Shrimp, oyster, bay scallop, crab cake, catfish (grouper upcharge)

  • Crab Cakes Basket$17

    House made Cajun style crab cakes

  • Butterflied Shrimp Basket$15
  • Bay Scallop Basket$16
  • Chicken Tender Basket and Fries$14

In the Bread

  • Shrimp Po'boy$16
  • Oyster Po'boy$18
  • Prime Rib Melt$19
  • Grouper Sandwich$21

Shack Favorites

  • Linguine Alfredo$12

    Add shrimp or chicken for an additional cost

  • Cajun Pasta$23

    Shrimp, scallops and smoked sausage in a Cajun cream sauce

  • Loaded Surf & Turf$28

    Tender filet steak bites with grilled shrimp, over red potatoes topped with creamy imperial sauce & loaded with bacon and cheese

  • Shack Stack$35

    Grouper, crab cake, sea scallop and shrimp stacked up and topped with house seafood sauce. Served with 2 sides

  • Shrimp Tacos$15
  • Lunch Stack$19.99

    Grilled fish, crab cake, and shrimp stacked up and topped with house seafood sauce. Served with 1 side

  • Hand Cut Ribeye$32

    12 oz . Open flame grilled and topped with our signature steak butter. Add butterflied shrimp for an additional cost

  • Taste of Orleans$22

    American raised catfish topped with shrimp étouffée served with red Beans & rice. Add crab cake for an additional cost

  • Shack Shrimp Tacos$18

    2 tacos filled with crispy fried shrimp tossed in our signature bang bang sauce over sweet slaw

  • Quesabarria$18

    2 crispy grilled tortillas filled with slow braised prime rib and melted cheese served with rich au jus

Brisket Burgers see more brisket in Panama City

  • Smokehouse Cheddar Burger$15
  • Banging Bacon Burger$15
  • Brisket Burger$13
  • Bacon Jam Burger$16

Dinner Menu - Tacos see more tacos in Panama City

  • Shack Shrimp Taco$18

    2 tacos filled with crispy fried shrimp tossed in our signature bang bang sauce over sweet slaw

  • Grouper Tacos$19
  • Tacos$15

    2 flour tortillas filled with grilled seafood and signature jalapeño slaw

  • Quesabarria Taco$18

    2 crispy grilled tortillas filled with slow braised prime rib and melted cheese served with rich au jus

Dinner Menu - Seafood Dinner see more seafood in Panama City

  • Catfish Dinner$18
  • Pick Two$28

    Shrimp, oyster, bay scallop, crab cake, catfish (grouper upcharge)

  • Fried Seafood Platter$35

    Shrimp, oyster, bay scallop, crab cake, catfish (substitute grouper upcharge)

  • Bay Scallop Dinner$18
  • Butterflied Shrimp Basket$18
  • Whole Fried Flounder$25

    Add butterflied shrimp for an additional cost

Fresh Salads see more salad in Panama City

  • Shack Salad$18

    Gulf shrimp, a scoop of smoked tuna dip, jalapeño slaw & sweet slaw over a house salad

  • Shrimp Caesar Salad$16
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad$16
  • Grouper Caesar Salad$20

    A classic Caesar with tomatoes dressed with a fresh parmesan herb Caesar vinaigrette

  • Chicken Finger Salad$14

Catering Menu - Trays

  • Family Hogpen Tray$65

    1/2 lb pulled pork, 1/2 lb brisket, 8 wings, 1/2 lb smoked chicken, 2 large quart sides and rolls. Serves 4 - 6

  • Family Four Pack Tray$45

    2 pounds of meat with 2 large quart sides and rolls

  • ChicnPig Slider Tray$40

    Smoked chicken, bacon, and cheese topped with ranch on sweet slider rolls

  • Pulled Pork Slider Tray$36
  • Chicken Slider Tray$36
  • Brisket Slider Tray$45

Catering Menu - Meat By The Pound

  • Jumbo Smoked Wings$30
  • Pulled Pork$16
  • Smoked Chicken$16

    1 lb. smoked whole white meat chicken

  • Smoked Brisket$32

Catering Menu - Party Sides

  • Quart Pan$12

    Serves 6-8

  • Half Pan$25

    Serves 15-20

  • Full Pan$40

    Serves 30-40 people

Search popular dishes & drinks found at Gary's Oyster Shack at other Panama City restaurants

Each card opens that dish's Panama City results, every place ranked, so you can compare Gary's Oyster Shack with the rest of the city.

What things cost at Gary's Oyster Shack

Gary's Oyster Shack's signature plates against the Panama City median for the same dish.

Own Gary's Oyster Shack? Claim it free, add photos & videos

Every cuisine and category in Panama City

See all 35 cuisines and categories as a list

Every dish and drink in Panama City

See all 62 dishes and drinks as a list